Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on the clinical activities related to arrhythmias and electrophysiology in Italy: results of a survey promoted by AIAC (Italian Association of Arrhythmology and Cardiac Pacing)

Giuseppe Boriani, Pietro Palmisano, Federico Guerra, Matteo Bertini, Gabriele Zanotto, Carlo Lavalle, Pasquale Notarstefano, Michele Accogli, Giovanni Bisignani, Giovanni B. Forleo, Maurizio Landolina, Antonio D’Onofrio, Renato Pietro Ricci, Roberto De Ponti, R. Luise, Paul L.e. Grieco, Antonio Pangallo, Glauberto da Silva Quirino, A Talarico, Silvana De Bonis, A. Carbone, Alessio Si̇mone, Felice Nappi, Francesco Rotondi, Giuseppe Stabile, Carlo Uran, Cristina Balla, Giulio Boggian, Valeria Carinci, Gustavo Méndez Barbato, Alessandro Corzani, Paolo Sabbatani, M. Erminio, Jacopo Francesco Imberti, N. Malavasi, Paolo Pastori, Fabio Quartieri, Nicola Bottoni, Davide Saporito, Santo Virzì, Biagio Sassone, Marco Zardini, Angelo Placci, Matteo Ziacchi, Giulia Massaro, Francesco Maria Adamo, Alberto Scaccia, A. Spampinato, Francesco Biscione, A. Castro, Filippo Maria Cauti, Pietro Rossi, Claudio Cinti, Miriam Gatto, Amir Kol, Maria Lucia Narducci, Gemma Pelargonio, N Patruno, Carlo Pignalberi, Danilo Ricciardi, Luca Santini, Mauro Tancredi, Natale Di Belardino, Francesco Pentimalli, Massimo Zoni-Berisso, Giuseppina Belotti, Enrico Chieffo, Silvia Cilloni, Lorenzo A. Doni, Andrea Gardini, Daniele Malaspina, Patrizio Mazzone, P. Della Bella, Roberto W. Dal Negro, Giovanni Battista Perego, Roberto Rordorf, Laura Cipolletta, Alessandra Russo, Mario Luzi, Claudia Amellone, Elisa Ebrille, Elisa Favro, Maria Teresa Lucciola, Chiara Devecchi, Francesco Rametta, Fausto Devecchi, Mario Matta, A. O. Sant’Andrea, Matteo Santagostino, Gabriele Dell’Era, T. R. Candida, V Bonfantino, Domenico Gianfrancesco, Alessandro Guido, P L Pellegrino, Ennio PisanòInternal 2020 · DOI

Introduction

The COVID-19 pandemic caused a massive disruption to cardiac arrhythmia care in Italy, with over 95% of surveyed centers reporting significant reductions in elective procedures. Beyond just postponing "non-essential" care, the crisis led to a concerning drop in emergency interventions. This paper investigates the extent of that disruption within the field of cardiac electrophysiology, quantifying how the pandemic curtailed essential services like pacemaker implantations, defibrillator (ICD) surgeries, and catheter ablations. Understanding this gap is crucial, as untreated arrhythmias can lead to heart failure, stroke, or sudden cardiac death.

Methods and Study Population

The researchers conducted a nationwide survey endorsed by the Italian Association of Arrhythmology and Cardiac Pacing (AIAC). An 18-question questionnaire was distributed to Italian arrhythmia centers between April and May 2020, focusing on the "lockdown" period (March–April 2020) and comparing activity levels to the same period in 2019.

The study relies on responses from 104 physicians representing 84 Italian arrhythmia centers, approximately 22.6% of all operating centers in Italy. These centers were geographically distributed across Northern, Central, and Southern Italy, as shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1: Geographic distribution of COVID-19 incidence and participating arrhythmia centers across Italy, including baseline center characteristics such as number of operators and annual procedure volumes.

Key Findings

Widespread Clinical Disruption

The quantitative drop in activity was staggering. Across the 84 participating centers, the authors estimate that 2,200 fewer devices were implanted and 960 fewer ablations were performed in just two months compared to the previous year.

  • Elective Pacemakers: 95.2% of centers reported a significant reduction; half saw a drop of more than 50%.
  • ICDs (Primary Prevention): 92.9% of centers reported a significant reduction.
  • Elective Ablations: 77.4% of centers reported a significant reduction.

Impact on Emergency Care

One of the most concerning findings was that even emergency procedures—those for life-threatening bradyarrhythmias or "electrical storms"—dropped significantly, with 70% of centers reporting a reduction in urgent device implantations. This suggests that patients may have avoided seeking care due to fear of infection or that emergency referral pathways were fundamentally compromised during the peak of the crisis.

Homogeneous Impact Across Regions

Interestingly, the reduction in device implantations was largely independent of the local COVID-19 incidence. Whether a region was a high-incidence "red zone" or relatively spared (see Figure 2), the impact on cardiac care was similar, suggesting a systemic national shutdown of elective services rather than a purely localized response to hospital capacity.

Figure 2: Regional incidence of COVID-19 cases (confirmed cases per 1,000 population) in Italy during the study period.

Staff Reallocation and Remote Monitoring

The pandemic forced a massive reallocation of specialized resources. In nearly 73% of the centers, at least one electrophysiology specialist was moved to a COVID-19 ward; in nearly half of those centers, the entire team was reassigned. However, the pandemic also acted as a "digital catalyst," with over 50% of centers reporting an increase in remote monitoring (RM) for patients with implanted devices to maintain care while minimizing hospital visits.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the study highlights a severe disruption in cardiac care, it also points toward necessary organizational shifts. The authors suggest that the post-COVID era requires new models, such as shifting toward "day-case" (same-day) admissions for procedures to minimize hospital stay duration and infection risk. Furthermore, they call for a more standardized, reimbursed framework for remote monitoring to ensure it remains a permanent standard of care rather than a temporary emergency measure.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{boriani2020impact,
  author = {Giuseppe Boriani and Pietro Palmisano and Federico Guerra and Matteo Bertini and Gabriele Zanotto and Carlo Lavalle and Pasquale Notarstefano and Michele Accogli and Giovanni Bisignani and Giovanni B. Forleo and Maurizio Landolina and Antonio D’Onofrio and Renato Pietro Ricci and Roberto De Ponti and R. Luise and Paul L.E. Grieco and Antonio Pangallo and Glauberto da Silva Quirino and A Talarico and Silvana De Bonis and A. Carbone and Alessio SİMONE and Antonio D’Onofrio and Felice Nappi and Francesco Rotondi and Giuseppe Stabile and Carlo Uran and Matteo Bertini and Cristina Balla and Giulio Boggian and Valeria Carinci and Gustavo Méndez Barbato and Alessandro Corzani and Paolo Sabbatani and M. Erminio and Jacopo Francesco Imberti and N. Malavasi and Paolo Pastori and Fabio Quartieri and Nicola Bottoni and Davide Saporito and Santo Virzì and Biagio Sassone and Marco Zardini and Angelo Placci and Matteo Ziacchi and Giulia Massaro and Francesco Maria Adamo and Alberto Scaccia and A. Spampinato and Francesco Biscione and A. Castro and Filippo Maria Cauti and Pietro Rossi and Claudio Cinti and Miriam Gatto and Amir Kol and Maria Lucia Narducci and Gemma Pelargonio and N Patruno and Carlo Pignalberi and Renato Pietro Ricci and Danilo Ricciardi and Luca Santini and Mauro Tancredi and Natale Di Belardino and Francesco Pentimalli and Massimo Zoni-Berisso and Giuseppina Belotti and Enrico Chieffo and Silvia Cilloni and Lorenzo A. Doni and Giovanni B. Forleo and Andrea Gardini and Daniele Malaspina and Patrizio Mazzone and P. Della Bella and Roberto W. Dal Negro and Giovanni Battista Perego and Roberto Rordorf and Laura Cipolletta and Alessandra Russo and Mario Luzi and Claudia Amellone and Elisa Ebrille and Elisa Favro and Maria Teresa Lucciola and Chiara Devecchi and Francesco Rametta and Fausto Devecchi and Mario Matta and A. O. Sant’Andrea and Matteo Santagostino and Gabriele Dell’Era and T. R. Candida and V Bonfantino and Domenico Gianfrancesco and Alessandro Guido and P L Pellegrino and Ennio Pisanò},
  title = {{Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on the clinical activities related to arrhythmias and electrophysiology in Italy: results of a survey promoted by AIAC (Italian Association of Arrhythmology and Cardiac Pacing)}},
  booktitle = {Internal},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1007/s11739-020-02487-w},
}
Figure