Impact of COVID-19 on Adolescent HIV Prevention and Treatment Research in the AHISA Network

Elizabeth D. Lowenthal, Stephanie M. DeLong, Brian C. Zanoni, Irene Njuguna, Kristin Beima‐Sofie, Dorothy E. Dow, Aisa Shayo, Alana Schreibman, Charisse V. Ahmed, Jennifer Chapman, Lydia Y. Chen, Shreya Mehta, Michael T. MbizvoAIDS 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

The COVID-19 pandemic severely disrupted adolescent HIV research in Africa, forcing nearly 90% of study teams to overhaul their protocols and pause recruitment. However, the crisis acted as a catalyst for innovation, proving the viability of remote service delivery and highlighting the need for "adaptive implementation science" that can pivot to meet the basic survival needs of participants during a global crisis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adolescents and young adults (AYA) living with HIV in sub-Saharan Africa are a uniquely vulnerable population, often lagging behind other age groups in treatment outcomes. Implementation science—the study of how to effectively integrate evidence-based interventions into real-world clinical settings—is critical for this group.

When COVID-19 hit, it didn't just create a new health threat; it dismantled the infrastructure required to conduct HIV research. Social distancing, lockdowns, and the repurposing of clinics into COVID centers created a "data void." This paper investigates how research teams within the Adolescent HIV Prevention and Treatment Implementation Science Alliance (AHISA) navigated these disruptions, what adaptations they made, and how the pandemic fundamentally altered the validity and execution of their studies.

Methods

The authors conducted a cross-network program evaluation survey targeting AHISA member teams across Africa.

  • Design: A mixed-methods approach using a survey programmed into REDCap. It collected quantitative data (Likert scales, counts) and qualitative data (open-ended questions about "lessons learned").
  • Coding: Qualitative responses were coded inductively to identify themes regarding protocol modifications, challenges to study validity, and innovations.
  • Synthesis: The researchers synthesized these reports into a framework of "potential solutions" for future disruptions, mapping specific challenges (like selection bias) to innovative responses (like decentralized care).

Datasets

The study relies on a primary dataset generated from the AHISA network survey.

  • Scope: Responses were obtained from 17 distinct AHISA teams representing 9 African countries (Botswana, Ghana, Kenya, Malawi, Nigeria, Rwanda, South Africa, Tanzania, and Zambia).
  • Context: These teams were managing 26 collaborative implementation research projects at the time of the pandemic.
  • Comparison: Unlike standard clinical trial datasets, this is a "meta-research" dataset focused on the operational health of research projects rather than patient-level clinical outcomes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Basic Needs" Pivot: One of the most striking findings was that research cannot exist in a vacuum. Teams found they had to partner with NGOs to provide food, masks, and transport reimbursements just to keep AYA participants engaged. If a participant's basic survival is at stake, research protocols must become secondary.
  • The Remote Paradox: While 88% of teams introduced remote research activities, this created a new "digital divide." Some AYA were more comfortable opening up via phone than in person, leading to better attendance in virtual workshops. Conversely, those without personal phones or internet access were further marginalized.
  • Implementation Science as a Living System: The authors argue that implementation science must be "adjustable." The pandemic proved that rigid protocols fail in a crisis. The "aha moment" here is that adaptations shouldn't just be seen as "noise" in the data, but as the primary subject of study.
  • Staff Morale as a Research Variable: The paper highlights that "operating under uncertainty" and the threat of COVID-19 acquisition took a massive toll on research staff, which directly impacted study execution and data quality.

Key Results

  • Protocol Overhauls: 88% of teams required research protocol modifications and IRB amendments.
  • Widespread Interruptions: 85% of teams experienced interruptions in recruitment, and 86% saw gaps in follow-up. These interruptions lasted anywhere from 2 to 11 months.
  • Funding at Risk: 31% of teams reported that their study funding was threatened due to the inability to meet objectives or the need to reallocate funds to urgent clinical needs.
  • Validity Challenges: The pandemic introduced significant risks of selection bias (only those with resources could participate) and misclassification bias (participants moving back to ancestral villages were often marked as "lost to follow-up" or "non-adherent").

Limitations and Future Work

  • Temporal Snapshot: The survey was conducted before April 2021. It does not capture the impact of subsequent COVID-19 waves (like Delta or Omicron) or the slow rollout of vaccines in Africa.
  • Network Bias: The participants were all part of the NIH-supported AHISA network. Smaller, less-funded local research teams likely faced even more severe challenges that are not reflected here.
  • Generalizability: The findings are specific to the African context; adolescent research in other regions may have faced different structural hurdles.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future research should focus on formalizing "remote service delivery" models that were born out of necessity, ensuring they are optimized for AYA who lack consistent technology access. There is also a call for more robust "documentation plans" to help researchers interpret data collected during periods of high contextual volatility.

Summary updated

Abstract

Members of the Adolescent HIV Prevention and Treatment Implementation Science Alliance (AHISA) network conduct research aiming to close gaps between what is known to be impactful across the HIV prevention and treatment cascade, and services delivered to optimize outcomes for adolescents/young adults (AYA) in high HIV-prevalence settings. The COVID-19 pandemic introduced new challenges which threaten to exacerbate care and access disparities. We report results of a survey among AHISA teams with active AYA HIV research programs in African countries to determine how the pandemic has impacted their efforts. Results highlighted the detrimental impact of the pandemic on research efforts and the expanded need for implementation research to help provide evidence-based, context-specific pandemic recovery support. Key lessons learned included the viability of remote service delivery strategies and other innovations, the need for adaptive systems that respond to evolving contextual needs, and the need for organized documentation plans, within empathic and flexible environments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lowenthal2022impact,
  author = {Elizabeth D. Lowenthal and Stephanie M. DeLong and Brian C. Zanoni and Irene Njuguna and Kristin Beima‐Sofie and Dorothy E. Dow and Aisa Shayo and Alana Schreibman and Charisse V. Ahmed and Jennifer Chapman and Lydia Y. Chen and Shreya Mehta and Michael T. Mbizvo},
  title = {{Impact of COVID-19 on Adolescent HIV Prevention and Treatment Research in the AHISA Network}},
  booktitle = {AIDS},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s10461-022-03811-5},
}
Figure