TL;DR
This study uses CFD simulations to investigate how corrugated fins enhance heat transfer in medium-deep coaxial underground heat exchangers (CUHEs) at high flow rates. The research reveals that these fins significantly boost turbulence and mixing, leading to a 1.43–2.19 times increase in heat transfer efficiency while managing acceptable pressure drops, offering a pathway to more efficient geothermal energy utilization.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Geothermal energy, particularly from medium-deep resources, holds immense potential for sustainable energy systems. Coaxial Underground Heat Exchangers (CUHEs) are a promising technology for tapping into this resource due to their efficiency and stability. However, maximizing their heat transfer performance is crucial for widespread adoption. While various heat transfer enhancement techniques exist, there's a need for systematic research into optimizing CUHE designs, especially under the high flow rate conditions (high Reynolds numbers) often encountered in industrial applications. This paper addresses this gap by investigating the impact of corrugated fins on CUHE performance at high Reynolds numbers (12,000–42,000), aiming to understand the underlying mechanisms and identify optimal geometric configurations.
Methods
The researchers employed computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations to model the flow and heat transfer within CUHEs. They specifically focused on the inner tube, which was equipped with corrugated fins. Nine different fin geometries were analyzed. The simulations involved solving the governing equations for fluid flow and heat transfer, including continuity, momentum, and energy equations, using the Realizable k-ε turbulence model. To ensure accuracy, a structured grid was generated with refinement in critical near-wall regions, and a grid independence study was conducted. The model's accuracy was validated by comparing its results for a smooth inner tube against established empirical correlations (Dittus-Boelter and Gnielinski for Nusselt number, Blasius and Petukhov for friction factor). The performance was evaluated using the Nusselt number (Nu) for heat transfer, the friction factor (f) for flow resistance, and the Performance Evaluation Criterion (PEC) to balance these two.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations rather than experimental datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Fins as Turbulence Generators: Corrugated fins are not just passive elements; they actively disrupt the fluid flow, creating vortices and enhancing mixing between the core and near-wall fluid layers. This is the primary mechanism for improved heat transfer, rather than direct wall scouring.
- Near-Wall Enhancement is Key: The fins significantly alter the near-wall temperature field, leading to steeper temperature gradients and thinner thermal boundary layers, which directly boosts heat transfer efficiency.
- Geometric Synergy: There's an interplay between fin width and spacing. Increasing fin width (Hc) generally improves heat transfer and reduces friction, while decreasing fin pitch (Pc) also enhances heat transfer but increases friction.
- PEC as a Holistic Metric: The Performance Evaluation Criterion (PEC) is crucial for design optimization, as it balances the gains in heat transfer (Nu) against the penalty of increased pressure drop (f). A higher PEC indicates a more efficient design for a given pumping power.
Key Results
- Significant Heat Transfer Boost: Corrugated fins increased the Nusselt number (Nu) by a factor of 1.43–2.19 compared to smooth inner tubes.
- Increased Pressure Drop: The friction factor (f) also increased, by a factor of 2.94–6.79, indicating higher pumping power requirements.
- Optimal Configuration: The study identified an optimal configuration with a fin width (Hc) of 15 mm, a pitch (Pc) of 60 mm, and a thickness (Wc) of 5 mm. This configuration achieved a maximum PEC of 1.34 at a Reynolds number (Re) of 12,000, signifying a substantial improvement in overall performance.
- Parameter Effects:
- Increasing fin width (Hc) generally led to higher Nu and PEC, and lower f.
- Decreasing fin pitch (Pc) led to higher Nu and PEC, and higher f.
- High Re Performance: The research successfully analyzed performance in the high Re range (12,000–42,000), which is relevant for industrial applications.
Limitations and Future Work
- Manufacturing Costs: The authors acknowledge that while increased fin width (Hc) improves performance, the associated increase in manufacturing costs for corrugated structures needs to be considered in practical applications, suggesting a need for cost-benefit analysis.
- Limited Geometric Range: The study explored nine fin geometries. Further research could investigate a broader range of parameters, including different corrugation shapes and thicknesses.
- Lower Re Conditions: The current study focused on high Re flows. Investigating performance at lower Re conditions would provide a more complete picture.
- Experimental Validation: While the numerical model was validated against empirical correlations, experimental validation of the proposed designs would be beneficial to confirm the simulation results.
- Structural Optimization: The paper suggests that further structural optimization of these CUHEs is possible, which could lead to even greater efficiency.
Summary updated