Impact of Aviation Electrification on Airports: Flight Scheduling and Charging

Boya Hou, Subhonmesh Bose, Lavanya Marla, Kiruba S. HaranIEEE Trans. ITS 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of integrating hybrid-electric aircraft (HEA) into airport operations by developing a framework that jointly optimizes flight schedules and HEA charging. The key insight is that effective HEA adoption hinges on coordinating airport congestion management with grid infrastructure constraints, demonstrating that smart charging and schedule adjustments can significantly reduce peak power demands.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Commercial aviation is a significant contributor to carbon emissions, and electrification is seen as a crucial path towards a carbon-neutral future. Hybrid-electric aircraft (HEA) are a promising step in this direction, but their widespread adoption will impose substantial new demands on airport infrastructure, particularly for charging. This paper addresses the critical question of how airports can manage these new energy demands while also optimizing flight operations. Specifically, it investigates the increased energy and power requirements at US airports due to HEA deployment and proposes solutions to mitigate potential issues like grid strain and airport congestion. The authors highlight that simply adding HEA without considering their charging needs and impact on flight schedules could lead to significant infrastructure upgrades and operational challenges.

Methods

The paper proposes a novel optimization framework that jointly considers flight rescheduling and HEA charging. The core of this framework is an optimization problem that aims to minimize flight schedule displacements from airline requests while simultaneously flattening the aggregate charging power profile of HEA. This is achieved by formulating a mixed-integer linear program (MILP) that decides both flight allocations (when flights operate) and charging profiles for HEA.

The authors also explore two mechanisms for congestion management:

  1. Centralized Airport Control: The airport centrally solves the rescheduling and charging problem, suggesting optimal flight paths and charging strategies.
  2. Iterative Negotiation: Airlines propose schedules, and the airport uses the optimization algorithm to check feasibility, iterating until an agreement is reached.

The paper also introduces a method to estimate HEA energy requirements based on aircraft type, flight distance, battery specific energy density (BSED), and motor factor (MF).

Datasets

The study utilizes the following datasets:

  • US Department of Transportation's Bureau of Transportation Statistics (BTS) on-time performance data for 2018: This dataset provides flight information, including arrival and departure times, which are used to model flight schedules and dwell times at airports.
  • DataSanFrancisco program: Used to obtain average power demand for SFO.
  • O'Hare Modernization Final Environmental Impact Statement: Used to obtain annual total energy demand for ORD.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interdependence of Scheduling and Charging: The most significant insight is that flight scheduling and HEA charging are inextricably linked. Decisions made for one directly impact the other, and they cannot be optimized in isolation.
  • Smart Charging for Peak Shaving: Naive charging of HEA at constant power levels can lead to substantial peak power demands that strain airport grid infrastructure. Smart charging, by intelligently scheduling charging times, can significantly reduce these peaks.
  • Schedule Alterations Amplify Peak Shaving: While smart charging alone is effective, marginal alterations to flight schedules can further reduce peak power demands, offering an additional layer of optimization.
  • Airport Capacity and Charging are Coupled: The capacity of an airport (e.g., runway availability) influences flight schedules, which in turn affects HEA charging profiles and peak demands.
  • Centralized Management Potential: The study suggests that centralized airport control over HEA switching decisions might be more effective in managing congestion and charging compared to airline-driven adjustments.

Key Results

  • Substantial Increase in Energy Demand: Accommodating HEA in commercial aviation can lead to a significant increase in annual electricity demand at major US airports, with projections showing increases of over 100% for some airports even with moderate HEA adoption.
  • Peak Power Reduction: Smart charging can reduce peak power demands substantially. For example, at SFO, a naive charging scheme resulted in a peak demand of 35.9 MW, which was reduced to 14.6 MW with optimized charging and schedule adjustments.
  • Impact of Airport Capacity: Expanding airport capacity (e.g., from R=45 to R=50 movements per hour) reduced aggregate flight displacements and also altered charging profiles, increasing peak power demand slightly due to higher throughput.
  • Mechanism Comparison: The study found that when the airport suggests which HEA routes should switch to conventional aircraft, more HEA routes are operated compared to when airlines self-manage these switches.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty in Technology Growth: The projections of energy requirements are subject to the inherent uncertainty in future technology growth patterns (BSED/MF combinations).
  • Single Airport Focus: The current rescheduling algorithm is designed for a single airport. Future work aims to extend this to jointly schedule flights and charge HEA across multiple airports.
  • Planning Tool vs. Real-time Operations: The current model is a planning tool. Future work will focus on enhancing the model to include tactical recourse decisions that adapt to real-time contingencies like weather or equipment malfunctions.
  • Cost Modeling: The current study does not explicitly model the costs of HEA charging. Future work will investigate the design of contracts among utilities, airports, and airlines to understand the impact of HEA charging costs on ticket prices.
  • Tactical and Real-time Congestion Management: The paper focuses on strategic/planning phase congestion management. A more comprehensive study of tactical or real-time operations is left for future work.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{hou2024impact,
  author = {Boya Hou and Subhonmesh Bose and Lavanya Marla and Kiruba S. Haran},
  title = {{Impact of Aviation Electrification on Airports: Flight Scheduling and Charging}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. ITS},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tits.2023.3324310},
}
Figure