Impact-induced changes in source depth and volume of magmatism on Mercury and their observational signatures

Sebastiano Padovan, Nicola Tosi, Ana‐Catalina Plesa, Thomas RuedasNature Communications 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses numerical simulations to show how large impacts on Mercury can trigger volcanism long after the impact event by interacting with the planet's internal convection. The findings help explain the timing and volume of volcanic plains observed in large impact basins like Caloris and Rembrandt, suggesting that this volcanism originated from a previously un-convected part of Mercury's mantle.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mercury's crust is largely volcanic, with extensive smooth plains emplaced around 3.7-3.5 billion years ago. While solid-state convection in Mercury's mantle is understood to be the primary driver of this magmatism, the role of large impacts in influencing this process, particularly in generating volcanism that postdates the impact itself, has been less clear. Specifically, how impacts might interact with the mantle's thermal and convective state to produce the observed volumes and timings of volcanic infill in large basins like Caloris and Rembrandt remained an open question. This paper aims to bridge this gap by numerically modeling the coupled effects of impacts and mantle convection on Mercury's magmatic history.

Methods

The researchers employed a 2D numerical convection code (GAIA) to simulate Mercury's thermal evolution. They incorporated various parameters, including mantle viscosity, heat-producing element (HPE) abundance (using enstatite and carbonaceous chondrite models), and the presence of a megaregolith layer. A key aspect of their approach was to simulate the effects of large impacts by using scaling laws to model the thermal anomaly generated by shock pressure. This thermal anomaly was then integrated into the mantle convection simulations to observe its influence on melt production. They specifically modeled impacts of varying sizes (Rembrandt and Caloris-sized basins) at different stages of Mercury's evolution, corresponding to vigorous, waning, and absent melting regimes. The simulations tracked melt production, source depth, and the resulting melt sheet thickness.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations and existing geological and geochronological data for Mercury (e.g., dating of volcanic provinces, basin stratigraphy, crustal thickness estimates) for model validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Impacts as Magma Triggers: Large impacts don't just create craters; they can significantly perturb Mercury's mantle, generating thermal anomalies that enhance or initiate melting long after the impact.
  • Post-Impact Volcanism: The simulations demonstrate that volcanism can be delayed by tens to hundreds of millions of years after a major impact, aligning with observations of volcanic plains within large basins.
  • Stagnant Lid's Role: The "stagnant lid" – a region of the mantle that has not participated in convection – is identified as the source region for this impact-induced volcanism. This implies that these volcanic plains may be derived from pristine mantle material.
  • Convection Regime Matters: The timing and nature of impact-induced volcanism are strongly dependent on the prevailing mantle convection regime (vigorous, waning, or absent) at the time of the impact.
  • Basin Size Influence: The size of the impact basin relative to the scale of mantle convection cells influences how much melt is produced, with larger basins (like Caloris) showing less dependence on the specific impact location (upwelling vs. downwelling).

Key Results

  • The model successfully reproduces the observed volume and timing of melt sheet emplacement in the interiors of Caloris and Rembrandt basins, provided that Mercury's mantle convection was weak around 3.7-3.8 Ga.
  • For impacts occurring during the "vigorous melting" regime, the shallow impact-induced melt is largely masked by deeper, convection-driven melt.
  • In the "waning" and "absent melting" regimes, impact-induced melt becomes more dominant, and its source depth is shallower, originating from the stagnant lid.
  • The model predicts prolonged volcanic activity (tens to hundreds of millions of years) following large impact events, consistent with geological evidence.
  • High extrusive-to-intrusive ratios (e.g., 50-82% for Caloris) are required to match observed melt sheet thicknesses, which is attributed to post-impact crustal removal and lithospheric fracturing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The study uses 2D simulations, which are a simplification of Mercury's potentially 3D dynamics. The megaregolith layer is treated as a simple thermal blanket, and its other physical properties are not fully incorporated.
  • Geochemical Complexity: While the model addresses geodynamical aspects, predicting the precise mineral composition of post-impact melts requires more complex, multi-phase flow dynamics that are beyond the scope of current global convection codes.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future thermo-chemical models should investigate the role of mantle heterogeneities in explaining geochemical anomalies like Mercury's high-magnesium region. Further data from missions like BepiColombo will be crucial for validating models of the southern hemisphere and refining our understanding of Mercury's volcanic history. The study also highlights the need for better geochemical data for regions like the Rembrandt basin.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mercury's crust is mostly the result of partial melting in the mantle associated with solid-state convection. Large impacts induce additional melting by generating subsurface thermal anomalies. By numerically investigating the geodynamical effects of impacts, here we show that impact-generated thermal anomalies interact with the underlying convection modifying the source depth of melt and inducing volcanism that can significantly postdate the impact depending on the impact time and location with respect to the underlying convection pattern. We can reproduce the volume and time of emplacement of the melt sheets in the interior of Caloris and Rembrandt if at about 3.7-3.8 Ga convection in the mantle of Mercury was weak, an inference corroborated by the dating of the youngest large volcanic provinces. The source depth of the melt sheets is located in the stagnant lid, a volume of the mantle that never participated in convection and may contain pristine mantle material.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{padovan2017impact,
  author = {Sebastiano Padovan and Nicola Tosi and Ana‐Catalina Plesa and Thomas Ruedas},
  title = {{Impact-induced changes in source depth and volume of magmatism on Mercury and their observational signatures}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-017-01692-0},
}
Figure