Immunization effect of inoculation messages: interventions against consensus and misinformation to improve public acceptance of recycled water

Hanliang Fu, Yuexin Li, Zhifang Wu, Yubing Tan, Weijie He, Jian ZuoHumanities 2025 · DOI

Abstract

The global freshwater crisis is accelerating, posing an urgent need for sustainable water solutions. Despite its potential as a viable alternative, recycled water has yet to gain widespread public acceptance. A key barrier is the public’ low intention to use it. Grounded in inoculation theory, this study explores the mechanism through which different types of information influence public acceptance of recycled water. Using eye-tracking technology, it examines the mediating role of information reception effects. The cognitive processing involved in the interaction between inoculation messages, scientific consensus, and misinformation is examined through the lens of dual-processing theory. The results demonstrate a public preference for misinformation about recycled water, leading to lower acceptance when both scientific consensus and misinformation are presented simultaneously. However, inoculation messages effectively mitigate the impact of misinformation while enhancing the reception effects of scientific consensus, resulting in increased acceptance among participants exposed to inoculation. From a micro-level perspective of eye movement behavior, this study illustrates the underlying cognitive mechanism underlying inoculation theory - specifically, how inoculation messages exert immunization effects by either suppressing cognitive processing of misinformation or reinforcing motivated reasoning of scientific consensus. By integrating inoculation theory and dual-processing theory, this study also provides empirical support for negative preference theory within a cognitive science framework. The findings provide practical insights for public communication campaigns, highlighting the value of inoculation strategies in shaping public attitudes toward recycled water. We recommend that marketing efforts incorporate inoculation strategies to foster public attitudinal resilience and prioritize the integration of scientific consensus and inoculation messages in public outreach materials.

Introduction

As the global freshwater crisis accelerates, recycled water (treated municipal wastewater) offers a viable solution, yet it faces a significant "yuck factor" and persistent psychological resistance. Public acceptance is often a tug-of-war between scientific consensus (e.g., "97% of experts agree it is safe") and misinformation (e.g., "recycled water contains hidden pathogens"). This study addresses a critical gap: understanding the micro-level cognitive mechanisms of how people process these conflicting streams of information. Specifically, it investigates "Negative Preference Theory"—the idea that humans are hardwired to pay more attention to negative information—and tests whether Inoculation Theory can provide a cognitive "antibody" to protect public trust.

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers conducted two eye-tracking experiments using a between-groups design with 215 participants. Unlike traditional surveys, eye-tracking provides an objective, real-time measure of cognitive effort through metrics such as Fixation Duration (time spent on specific text) and Fixation Count (number of returns to a stimulus).

The intervention utilized a "forewarning + refutational pre-emption" paradigm. Participants were divided into groups receiving different message block types to test the efficacy of inoculation against misinformation.

Experimental design showing the four message block types and hypothesized relationships between general and inoculation groups.

The experimental procedure followed a structured sequence of calibration, guidelines, and information display to ensure data accuracy.

The eye-tracking experiment procedure, including calibration, guidelines, and the sequential display of information tips.

Cognitive processing was analyzed through the lens of Dual-Processing Theory, distinguishing between System 1 (fast, intuitive) and System 2 (slow, analytical) thinking.

Key Insights and Results

The "Negative Preference" Trap

Study 1 confirmed that misinformation elicits significantly higher "information reception effects" than scientific consensus. In plain terms: people look at and think about "scary" lies much longer than "boring" facts. Misinformation often hijacks System 2 processing because it creates cognitive dissonance, which, without prior defense, leads to lower acceptance.

Cognitive Immunization

Inoculation works by triggering System 2 processing early. By the time a participant encounters misinformation, they have already formed "attitudinal antibodies."

  • Acceptance Boost: In Study 2, the group exposed to both scientific consensus and inoculation messages showed a significant increase in acceptance (Mean difference = 0.904, $p < 0.001$).
  • Mitigating Damage: When scientific consensus and misinformation were presented together without inoculation, acceptance plummeted. Adding an inoculation message mitigated this negative impact, resulting in a post-test mean score 1.46 points higher than the non-inoculated group.
  • Processing Shift: Most interestingly, once inoculated, participants spent less effort processing misinformation (dismissing it via System 1) and more effort on scientific consensus (reinforcing it via motivated reasoning).

Discussion and Future Work

Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) confirmed that information reception effects (eye fixations) directly mediated the relationship between message type and final acceptance ($R^2 = 0.826$). This provides empirical support for negative preference theory within a cognitive science framework.

While promising, the study's reliance on university students suggests a need for broader demographic testing. Future research should also examine the long-term durability of these "immunization" effects and explore "algorithmic inoculation"—using AI to deliver preemptive strikes against misinformation in real-time digital environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

The global freshwater crisis is accelerating, posing an urgent need for sustainable water solutions. Despite its potential as a viable alternative, recycled water has yet to gain widespread public acceptance. A key barrier is the public’ low intention to use it. Grounded in inoculation theory, this study explores the mechanism through which different types of information influence public acceptance of recycled water. Using eye-tracking technology, it examines the mediating role of information reception effects. The cognitive processing involved in the interaction between inoculation messages, scientific consensus, and misinformation is examined through the lens of dual-processing theory. The results demonstrate a public preference for misinformation about recycled water, leading to lower acceptance when both scientific consensus and misinformation are presented simultaneously. However, inoculation messages effectively mitigate the impact of misinformation while enhancing the reception effects of scientific consensus, resulting in increased acceptance among participants exposed to inoculation. From a micro-level perspective of eye movement behavior, this study illustrates the underlying cognitive mechanism underlying inoculation theory - specifically, how inoculation messages exert immunization effects by either suppressing cognitive processing of misinformation or reinforcing motivated reasoning of scientific consensus. By integrating inoculation theory and dual-processing theory, this study also provides empirical support for negative preference theory within a cognitive science framework. The findings provide practical insights for public communication campaigns, highlighting the value of inoculation strategies in shaping public attitudes toward recycled water. We recommend that marketing efforts incorporate inoculation strategies to foster public attitudinal resilience and prioritize the integration of scientific consensus and inoculation messages in public outreach materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fu2025immunization,
  author = {Hanliang Fu and Yuexin Li and Zhifang Wu and Yubing Tan and Weijie He and Jian Zuo},
  title = {{Immunization effect of inoculation messages: interventions against consensus and misinformation to improve public acceptance of recycled water}},
  booktitle = {Humanities},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1057/s41599-025-05675-1},
}
Figure