Abstract
Evolutionary adaptations often occur at the level of cell types and cellular function. Innate immune cells are a promising system for studying cell type evolution, as they are widespread across metazoans, have several conserved functions, and are under selective pressure from pathogens. However, molecular characterizations of invertebrate immune cells are limited, and it remains unclear whether invertebrate immune cell types are homologous to those in vertebrates. Here we use single-cell RNA sequencing, in situ hybridization, and live reporters to define the identity of blood cell states from a basal chordate, Ciona robusta. We find evidence that C. robusta circulating blood contains a differentiation hierarchy that gives rise to at least eight major morphotypes, constituting approximately half of mature blood cell states. The mature cell states include phagocytes, as well as cells variously expressing vanadium-binding proteins, carbonic anhydrases, pattern recognition receptors, cytokines, and complement factors. Despite the expression of homologs to vertebrate immune components, extensive divergence between tunicate and vertebrate immune cells obscures cell state homology. Altogether, this work modernizes blood cell classifications in C. robusta and extends the known repertoire of immune cells within chordates.
Introduction: The Evolutionary Bridge
To understand the origins of the complex human immune system, researchers look to our closest invertebrate relatives: the tunicates. Ciona robusta, a sea squirt, occupies a pivotal position in the tree of life. Sharing a common ancestor with vertebrates approximately 550 million years ago, tunicates possess many of the genetic "building blocks" of immunity—such as complement factors and cytokines—yet they lack the adaptive immune system (T and B cells) characteristic of higher vertebrates.
Historically, tunicate blood cells were classified almost exclusively by their physical morphology under a microscope. This approach left a significant knowledge gap: it was unclear which genes these different shapes expressed, how they developed from stem cells, or if a tunicate "phagocyte" was truly the molecular equivalent of a vertebrate macrophage. This study modernizes tunicate hematology by creating a high-resolution transcriptomic and morphological atlas of Ciona blood cells, testing the limits of cell-type conservation across half a billion years of evolution.
Methodological Innovations
Mapping the cellular landscape of a marine invertebrate requires overcoming unique technical hurdles. The high salinity of tunicate blood typically kills cells in standard sequencing buffers. To address this, the researchers developed a specialized mannitol-based buffer for single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq), allowing them to profile over 15,000 individual blood cells.
To bridge the gap between genetic signatures and physical form, the team employed a multi-modal approach:
- HCR FISH (Hybridization Chain Reaction): This imaging technique labeled specific RNA transcripts in fixed cells, allowing researchers to map transcriptional clusters back to physical morphotypes.
- Live Cell Reporters: By introducing GFP driven by cell-state-specific promoters into Ciona embryos, they observed immune cells circulating and crawling in living, transparent juveniles.
- Computational Cross-Species Mapping: Using the SAMap algorithm and a novel Generalized Sankey (GS) plot method, the team compared Ciona gene expression profiles against human (Tabula Sapiens) and zebrafish datasets.
The Transcriptomic Landscape of Ciona Blood
The study revealed a far more complex system than previously imagined. While traditional microscopy identified only 6–9 distinct cell shapes, transcriptomic data uncovered 33 distinct transcriptional states. This discrepancy suggests that morphology is deceptive; many cells that appear identical under a microscope are performing fundamentally different molecular functions.
The researchers also mapped a hematopoietic hierarchy, showing how multipotent progenitors (cMPPs) give rise to specialized lineages. While the hierarchical structure of blood development is shared with vertebrates, the mature cells at the tips of these branches are unique to tunicates. Among these, the study finally pinpointed the molecular signature of "vanadocytes"—mysterious cells known to accumulate high levels of vanadium—mapping them to a specific cluster (HA-5).
Functional Shuffling and the Limits of Homology
One of the study's most significant findings is the lack of one-to-one cell type homology between tunicates and vertebrates. While Ciona uses many of the same "immune tools" as humans—such as complement factors and pattern recognition receptors (PRRs)—it deploys them in different combinations. For example, complement factor C6, which is produced in the liver in humans, is expressed directly by various circulating blood cells in Ciona.
When comparing human neutrophils to Ciona cells, the "neutrophil-like" genetic signatures were scattered across multiple tunicate cell types rather than concentrated in a single equivalent cell. Cross-species specificity scores were near 1.0, indicating that a tunicate cell is no more similar to its supposed vertebrate "match" than to any other random cell type. This suggests that cell types evolve by "shuffling" gene modules rather than remaining as static, conserved units over hundreds of millions of years.
Results and Future Directions
The study identified 33 clusters categorized into major functional groups, including professional phagocytes (confirmed via zymosan assays), vanadocytes, and cells involved in gas exchange. It also revealed a dramatic expansion of certain immune gene families, such as 13 copies of the complement factor C6, suggesting that tunicates have evolved unique innate strategies that remain poorly understood.
Despite these insights, limitations remain. The study focused on circulating blood, potentially missing immune cells residing in tissue niches like the stolon. Furthermore, while the "parts list" of genes is now available, the specific functions of many tunicate-specific genes remain a mystery. Future research involving broader sequencing across various phyla will be necessary to determine where these gene modules first clustered together and how the ancestral chordate immune cell truly functioned.
Summary updated