Immersion Freezing in Particle‐Based Aerosol‐Cloud Microphysics: A Probabilistic Perspective on Singular and Time‐Dependent Models

Sylwester Arabas, Jeffrey H. Curtis, Israel Silber, Ann M. Fridlind, Daniel Knopf, Matthew West, Nicole RiemerJournal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems 2023

This paper, recently published in the field of atmospheric physics, dives into the microscopic world of how clouds freeze. Specifically, it looks at immersion freezing—the process where a tiny solid particle (an Ice Nucleating Particle, or INP) inside a water droplet triggers it to turn into ice.

TL;DR

Researchers compared two dominant mathematical ways of modeling cloud freezing: the "singular" (temperature-only) approach and the "time-dependent" (stochastic) approach. Using advanced "super-particle" simulations, they demonstrate that singular models are often limited by the laboratory conditions where they were created, whereas time-dependent models are far more robust for simulating real-world atmospheric dynamics like updrafts and downdrafts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting when and how clouds freeze is one of the biggest headaches in climate modeling. If a cloud is made of liquid droplets, it reflects sunlight differently than if it’s made of ice crystals.

For decades, scientists have used two different "philosophies" to model this:

  1. The Singular Model: Assumes freezing is deterministic. At a specific temperature, a specific particle will cause freezing.
  2. The Time-Dependent Model: Assumes freezing is a game of chance. The longer a droplet stays cold, the more likely it is to freeze.

The problem is that most "singular" models are calibrated using laboratory cloud chamber experiments with very fast cooling rates. When these models are plugged into global weather simulations—where the atmosphere cools much more slowly—they may produce wildly inaccurate results. This paper seeks to quantify that discrepancy and show how "particle-based" modeling can bridge the gap.

Methods

The authors employ particle-based (or "super-particle") microphysics. Unlike traditional models that treat clouds as a smooth fluid, this method tracks thousands of individual computational particles, each representing a "multiplicity" of real-world droplets or aerosols.

They tested the models in two stages:

  • 0D Box Model: A "cloud in a jar" simulation to see how the two freezing theories respond to different cooling rates and particle size distributions (polydispersity).
  • 2D Prescribed-Flow Model: A more complex simulation of a stratiform cloud deck. This allowed them to see how the models behave when particles move through realistic cycles of cooling (updrafts) and warming (downdrafts).

They specifically compared the INAS (Ice Nucleation Active Site) singular parameterization against the ABIFM (Adsorption-Based Ice Nucleation Model) time-dependent parameterization.

Datasets

The study primarily uses experimental fits for mineral dust derived from the AIDA (Aerosol Interactions and Dynamics in the Atmosphere) cloud chamber.

  • The INAS coefficients were taken from Niemand et al. (2012).
  • The ABIFM coefficients were taken from Alpert and Knopf (2016). By using parameters derived from the same experimental facility, the authors ensured a "fair fight" between the two mathematical approaches.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Cooling Rate Signature": The authors show that singular models have the cooling rate of the lab experiment "baked into" their coefficients. If the real atmosphere cools 5x slower than the lab, the singular model might shift the freezing temperature by as much as 2 Kelvin—a massive difference in meteorology.
  • Freezing While Warming: One of the most "aha" moments is the demonstration that time-dependent models allow droplets to freeze even while the air is slightly warming (as long as it's still supercooled). Singular models physically cannot do this; they only trigger freezing when the temperature is dropping.
  • The Rare Event Challenge: INPs are incredibly rare (often 1 INP for every 1,000,000 ordinary cloud particles). The paper highlights a "sampling strategy" where they split the super-particle population to ensure these rare but critical freezing events are statistically represented without needing impossible amounts of computing power.

Key Results

  • Order of Magnitude Differences: In 2D cloud simulations, the singular model predicted an order of magnitude less ice than the time-dependent model. This is because natural atmospheric cooling is much slower than the lab experiments the singular model was tuned for.
  • Convergence: The authors proved that their Monte Carlo time-dependent scheme converges with an inverse square-root error ($1/\sqrt{N}$), confirming the mathematical reliability of using super-particles for stochastic freezing.
  • Polydispersity vs. Cooling: They found that the variety in particle sizes (surface area) can be just as important as the cooling rate. Neglecting the "polydispersity" of the dust particles can lead to errors comparable to a multi-fold change in the cooling rate.

Limitations and Future Work

The 2D simulations used a "prescribed flow," meaning the ice didn't "push back" on the air (no latent heat feedback). The authors also noted that they didn't include "secondary ice production" (where one ice crystal shatters to create more), which is a major factor in real clouds.

Future Work: The authors suggest moving these time-dependent models into full 3D Large Eddy Simulations (LES). They also point out that we still need better ways to handle what happens to "freezing attributes" when two particles collide and merge—a tricky problem for particle-based models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Cloud droplets containing immersed ice‐nucleating particles (INPs) may freeze at temperatures above the homogeneous freezing threshold temperature in a process referred to as immersion freezing. In modeling studies, immersion freezing is often described using either so‐called “singular” or “time‐dependent” parameterizations. Here, we compare both approaches and discuss them in the context of probabilistic particle‐based (super‐droplet) cloud microphysics modeling. First, using a box model, we contrast how both parameterizations respond to idealized ambient cooling rate profiles and quantify the impact of the polydispersity of the immersed surface spectrum on the frozen fraction evolution. Presented simulations highlight that the singular approach, constituting a time‐integrated form of a more general time‐dependent approach, is only accurate under a limited range of ambient cooling rates. The time‐dependent approach is free from this limitation. Second, using a prescribed‐flow two‐dimensional cloud model, we illustrate the macroscopic differences in the evolution in time of ice particle concentrations in simulations with flow regimes relevant to ambient cloud conditions. The flow‐coupled aerosol‐budget‐resolving simulations highlight the benefits and challenges of modeling cloud condensation nuclei activation and immersion freezing on insoluble ice nuclei with super‐particle methods. The challenges stem, on the one hand, from heterogeneous ice nucleation being contingent on the presence of relatively sparse immersed INPs, and on the other hand, from the need to represent a vast population of particles with relatively few so‐called super particles (each representing a multiplicity of real particles). We discuss the critical role of the sampling strategy for particle attributes, including the INP size, the freezing temperature (for singular scheme) and the multiplicity.
BibTeX
@article{arabas2023immersion,
  author = {Sylwester Arabas and Jeffrey H. Curtis and Israel Silber and Ann M. Fridlind and Daniel Knopf and Matthew West and Nicole Riemer},
  title = {{Immersion Freezing in Particle‐Based Aerosol‐Cloud Microphysics: A Probabilistic Perspective on Singular and Time‐Dependent Models}},
  journal = {Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure