Imaging beyond the super-resolution limits using ultrastructure expansion microscopy (UltraExM)

Davide Gambarotto, Fabian U. Zwettler, Markéta Schmidt Černohorská, Denis Fortun, Susanne Borgers, J. Heine, Jan-Gero Schloetel, Matthias Reuß, Michaël Unser, Edward S. Boyden, Markus Sauer, Virginie Hamel, Paul GuichardbioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new microscopy technique called UltraExM that expands biological samples, allowing standard optical microscopes to achieve near-electron microscopy resolution. This breakthrough enables unprecedented visualization of ultrastructural details in complex cellular machinery like centrioles, revealing features previously only visible with electron microscopy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, understanding the intricate ultrastructure of cellular components like organelles and molecular complexes has been a challenge. Electron Microscopy (EM) offered high resolution but required harsh sample preparation that could alter structures. Super-resolution fluorescence microscopy advanced optical imaging, achieving near-molecular resolution, but still fell short of EM's detail, making it difficult to pinpoint the exact location of specific proteins within these complex structures. This gap meant that some crucial ultrastructural features, like the chirality of centrioles, remained elusive to optical methods.

Methods

The core innovation is UltraExM (Ultrastructure Expansion Microscopy). It builds upon existing expansion microscopy (ExM) techniques but refines the process to better preserve the native ultrastructure of the sample.

Here's a breakdown:

  • Near-Native Expansion: Unlike earlier ExM methods that involved significant protein degradation, UltraExM uses gentler fixation with low concentrations of formaldehyde (0.3-1%) and acrylamide (0.15-1%). This minimizes structural damage and preserves epitopes for antibody binding.
  • Post-Expansion Labeling: After the sample is embedded in a polymer and expanded, fluorescent labels (antibodies) are applied. This "post-labeling" strategy improves antibody accessibility to epitopes on the expanded structure, leading to higher labeling density and reduced linkage error.
  • Standard Optical Microscopy: The expanded sample can then be imaged using conventional confocal microscopes.
  • Super-Resolution Enhancement: For even finer details, UltraExM can be combined with super-resolution techniques like STED (Stimulated Emission Depletion) microscopy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses isolated Chlamydomonas reinhardtii centrioles as its biological model system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Resolution Gap: UltraExM effectively bridges the resolution gap between optical and electron microscopy, offering a more accessible way to visualize ultrastructure.
  • Preserving Molecular Architecture: The key advantage of UltraExM is its ability to preserve the delicate molecular architecture of organelles and macromolecular assemblies, which was a limitation of previous ExM methods.
  • Unveiling Centriole Chirality: The technique successfully revealed the "chirality" of centrioles – a subtle, twisted arrangement of their microtubule triplets – a feature previously only observable with EM.
  • Sub-Microtubule Triplet Localization: UltraExM allowed for the precise localization of tubulin glutamylation (PolyE) to specific components within the microtubule triplets (specifically, the C-microtubule), a level of detail previously unattainable.
  • Improved Labeling Efficiency: Post-expansion labeling in UltraExM leads to better antibody accessibility and higher labeling density compared to pre-expansion labeling in other methods.

Key Results

  • Centriole Diameter and Shape: UltraExM achieved an expansion factor of approximately 4-fold, resulting in centriole diameters of around 195 nm (for α-tubulin) and 225 nm (for PolyE), which closely matched expected dimensions after expansion. The method also demonstrated excellent preservation of centriole shape and isotropic expansion.
  • 9-Fold Symmetry Visualization: UltraExM clearly resolved the 9-fold symmetry of centriole microtubule triplets, both for α-tubulin and PolyE signals, using standard confocal microscopy.
  • UltraExM vs. dSTORM: When compared to dSTORM (a super-resolution technique), UltraExM combined with confocal microscopy showed comparable or even higher labeling efficiency and spatial resolution for certain structures like procentrioles.
  • Centriole Chirality Revealed: Combining UltraExM with STED microscopy allowed for the visualization of the clockwise and anticlockwise orientation of microtubule triplets in procentrioles, confirming centriole chirality.
  • Sub-triplet Localization Accuracy: UltraExM demonstrated a precise localization of PolyE to the C-microtubule of the triplet, with a measured shift of ~21 nm from the tubulin signal, consistent with EM-based models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: While UltraExM significantly improves upon previous methods, the paper notes that the "reliability of the isotropic expansion process at the molecular level remained elusive" prior to their refined protocol. The authors also acknowledge that there is "ample of scope for further improvements."
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that UltraExM, especially when combined with super-resolution microscopy, has the potential to become a standard method for elucidating the structure of macromolecular assemblies. The success in visualizing centriole chirality and sub-triplet localization indicates its broad applicability to other complex cellular structures.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT For decades, electron microscopy (EM) was the only method able to reveal the ultrastructure of cellular organelles and molecular complexes because of the diffraction limit of optical microscopy. In recent past, the emergence of superresolution fluorescence microscopy enabled the visualization of cellular structures with so far unmatched spatial resolution approaching virtually molecular dimensions. Despite these technological advances, currently super-resolution microscopy does not permit the same resolution level as provided by electron microscopy, impeding the attribution of a protein to an ultrastructural element. Here, we report a novel method of near-native expansion microscopy (UltraExM), enabling the visualization of preserved ultrastructures of macromolecular assemblies with subdiffraction-resolution by standard optical microscopy. UltraExM revealed for the first time the ultrastructural localization of tubulin glutamylation in centrioles. Combined with super-resolution microscopy, UltraExM unveiled the centriolar chirality, an ultrastructural signature, which was only visualizable by electron microscopy.
BibTeX
@misc{gambarotto2018imaging,
  author = {Davide Gambarotto and Fabian U. Zwettler and Markéta Schmidt Černohorská and Denis Fortun and Susanne Borgers and J. Heine and Jan-Gero Schloetel and Matthias Reuß and Michaël Unser and Edward S. Boyden and Markus Sauer and Virginie Hamel and Paul Guichard},
  title = {{Imaging beyond the super-resolution limits using ultrastructure expansion microscopy (UltraExM)}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/308270},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure