Illumination Power, Stability, and Linearity Measurements for Confocal, Widefield and Multiphoton Microscopes v1

Nathalie Gaudreault, Luis-Francisco Acevedo-Hueso, Rizwan Ali, Sergiy Avilov, Steve Bagley, Rodrigo Roberto Bammann, Fábio Barachati, L Barna, Valeria Berno, Cristina Bertocchi, Veronika Boczonadi, Ulrike Boehm, Manel Bosch, Craig Brideau, Mariana T. Carvalho, N. Chatterjee, Pina Colarusso, Richard Cole, N. Darwish, Suat Dervish, Ralf Dietzel, Sam Duwé, Frank Eismann, Orestis Faklaris, Andreas Felscher, Zannatul Ferdous, Thomas Guilbert, Manfred Gonnert, David Grünwald, Tingting Gu, Birgit Hoffmann, Marcel Kirchner, Ayse Aslihan Koksoy, Gabriel Krens, Alex Laude, Jeffrey LeDue, Penghuan Liu, Pascal Lorentz, Gabriel G. Martins, Valeria.MezzanoRobinson not provided, Mišo Mitkovski, Glyn Nelson, Michael S. Nelson, Roland Nitschke, Alex L. Payne-Dwyer, Jaime A. Pimentel, Santosh Podder, Britta Schroth‐Diez, Stanley Schwartz, Ronian Siew, Sathya Srinivasan, Roland Thuenauer, Kees van der Oord, Douglas J. Taatjes, Chloë van Oostende‐Triplet, Tse-Luen Wee, Kurt Weiss, Laurent Gelman2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a standardized community protocol from the QUAREP-LiMi consortium to measure the power, stability, and linearity of microscope illumination. By moving beyond arbitrary "percentage" settings to absolute milliwatt measurements, researchers can ensure their imaging data is reproducible across different days, systems, and laboratories.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In light microscopy, "10% laser power" is a deceptive metric. Because light sources age, optical fibers shift, and environmental conditions fluctuate, 10% power today might deliver a significantly different number of photons than 10% power next month. Furthermore, 10% on a Zeiss confocal is not comparable to 10% on a Leica system.

This lack of standardization is a major hurdle for quantitative biology. If you are comparing fluorescence intensities to measure protein expression or tracking a signal over a long time-lapse, you need to know that your light source is stable and that your power increments are linear. Without these measurements, "quantitative" results are often just relative observations prone to instrumental drift.

Methods

The authors, representing a collective of over 50 imaging scientists, outline a rigorous procedure using calibrated external power sensors (photodiodes or thermal sensors).

Key steps include:

  • System Warm-up: Defining specific stabilization times for different sources (e.g., ~1 hour for gas lasers, minutes for LEDs).
  • Sensor Alignment: Centering the illumination on the sensor at the objective plane to avoid edge effects and clipping.
  • Stability Testing:
    • Short-term: Recording power every second for 5 minutes.
  • Long-term: Recording every 30 seconds for 120 minutes to mimic a long-lived experiment.
  • Linearity Testing: Measuring power at 10% increments (0% to 100%) to calculate the coefficient of determination ($r^2$).
  • Environmental Monitoring: Tracking temperature, humidity, and airflow, which can significantly impact laser stability.

The protocol distinguishes between different hardware setups, providing specific advice for widefield, confocal (raster and spinning disk), and multiphoton systems.

Datasets

As this is a protocol paper, it does not introduce a new machine-learning dataset. However, it references the QUAREP-LiMi database, a community-driven repository where members have historically shared stability and linearity measurements from various microscope models to establish performance benchmarks. It also points to the QUAREP Github repository, which contains scripts for automating these measurements on Nikon and Zeiss systems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Percentage Trap": The paper emphasizes that software-reported percentages are often non-linear, especially at the extreme low and high ends of the power range.
  • Thermal Sensitivity: A major "aha moment" for many will be the impact of ambient environment. Even a slight draft from an AC vent can cause measurable fluctuations in laser power, particularly when using thermal sensors.
  • Sensor Selection is Critical: You cannot use a standard photodiode for high-power multiphoton lasers; the peak power of pulsed lasers can easily destroy sensitive electronics. The paper provides a guide for choosing between photodiode, thermal, and pyroelectric sensors.
  • Standardized Stability Formula: The paper provides a specific formula to calculate % variation, ensuring everyone in the community calculates "stability" the same way: $$\Delta Power (\%) = 100 \times (1 - \frac{P_{max} - P_{min}}{P_{max} + P_{min}})$$

Key Results

The paper provides several "Expected Result" figures that serve as benchmarks:

  • Laser Aging: One example shows an aging Argon laser that was significantly unstable compared to its replacement, highlighting how routine monitoring can catch hardware failure before it ruins an experiment.
  • Warm-up Curves: Data plots illustrate how power can fluctuate wildly in the first 20 minutes of a session, proving that "pre-warming" the system is a requirement for quantitative work, not a suggestion.
  • Linearity Benchmarks: A perfectly calibrated system should show an $r^2$ value very close to 1.0. The paper shows real-world examples where systems maintain high linearity across multiple months of tracking.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Manual Effort: Performing these measurements manually is time-consuming. The authors acknowledge this and suggest using the QUAREP-LiMi Tool Kit for automation, though they note that not all microscope manufacturers provide the necessary open APIs for easy integration.
  • Hardware Specifics: While the protocol is broad, some specific troubleshooting steps are tailored toward Thorlabs and Coherent hardware, which are common but not universal.
  • Database Status: The paper notes that the central QUAREP-LiMi dashboard for sharing these results is no longer active, suggesting a need for a new sustainable infrastructure for community benchmarking.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future versions of the protocol could delve deeper into the impact of the "AOTF" (Acousto-Optic Tunable Filter) on beam shape and polarization, which are secondary factors in illumination quality.

Summary updated

Abstract

To obtain accurate, reproducible, and interpretable data when conducting imaging experiments, it is critical to consider external factors affecting data acquisition at various steps of the experimental workflow. Illumination power and stability represent two critical factors, especially when comparing fluorescence intensities between images during a time-lapse experiment or experiments performed at different times or on different microscopes. The fluorescence signal can be generated by different types of light sources. These light sources and their coupling elements (e.g., fibers) can display varying performances over time as they age, move, or as environmental conditions change. Unfortunately, microscope users can often only set illumination power as a percentage of its maximal output and may, therefore, not be aware of potential performance changes. It is important to recognize that a set percentage will not always yield the same illumination power in Watts at the objective over the course of an experiment, not to mention between days or systems. This means that selecting for example 10% output may lead to different experimental results over time or even between two microscopes of the same model. In addition to illumination stability, working within the linear range of the illumination power allows to adjust accurately the illumination power absolute value (in mW) using a fraction (or %) of its maximal value through the imaging software. If you are responsible for system maintenance, routinely measuring the illumination power, stability, and linearity over time can help you detect issues that affect the integrity of the system and thus the reproducibility of an experiment. This protocol describes how to measure the stability and linearity of the illumination power using calibrated external power sensors. This protocol is intended for confocal systems (raster scanning and spinning disks), Multi-photon systems (used for 2P- or 3P-imaging, SHG-imaging, etc.), and widefield systems. It represents the collective experience of over 50 imaging scientists.
BibTeX
@misc{gaudreault2024illumination,
  author = {Nathalie Gaudreault and Luis-Francisco Acevedo-Hueso and Rizwan Ali and Sergiy Avilov and Steve Bagley and Rodrigo Roberto Bammann and Fábio Barachati and L Barna and Valeria Berno and Cristina Bertocchi and Veronika Boczonadi and Ulrike Boehm and Manel Bosch and Craig Brideau and Mariana T. Carvalho and N. Chatterjee and Pina Colarusso and Richard Cole and N. Darwish and Suat Dervish and Ralf Dietzel and Sam Duwé and Frank Eismann and Orestis Faklaris and Andreas Felscher and Zannatul Ferdous and Thomas Guilbert and Manfred Gonnert and David Grünwald and Tingting Gu and Birgit Hoffmann and Marcel Kirchner and Ayse Aslihan Koksoy and Gabriel Krens and Alex Laude and Jeffrey LeDue and Penghuan Liu and Pascal Lorentz and Gabriel G. Martins and Valeria.MezzanoRobinson not provided and Mišo Mitkovski and Glyn Nelson and Michael S. Nelson and Roland Nitschke and Alex L. Payne-Dwyer and Jaime A. Pimentel and Santosh Podder and Britta Schroth‐Diez and Stanley Schwartz and Ronian Siew and Sathya Srinivasan and Roland Thuenauer and Kees van der Oord and Douglas J. Taatjes and Chloë van Oostende‐Triplet and Tse-Luen Wee and Kurt Weiss and Laurent Gelman},
  title = {{Illumination Power, Stability, and Linearity Measurements for Confocal, Widefield and Multiphoton Microscopes v1}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.17504/protocols.io.n2bvj3m45lk5/v1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure