Illuminating the dark universe with a very high density galaxy redshift survey over a wide area

Yun Wang, Rachel Bean, Peter Behroozi, Chia-Hsun Chuang, Ian Dell’Antonio, Mark Dickinson, Olivier Doré, Daniel J. Eisenstein, R. J. Foley, Karl Glazebrook, L. Guzzo, Christopher M. Hirata, Shirley Ho, Michael J. Hudson, Bhuvnesh Jain, Priyamvada Natarajan, Jeff Newman, Álvaro Orsi, Nikhil Padmanabhan, J. A. Peacock, Will J. Percival, Jason Rhodes, Eduardo Rozo, Lado Samushia, D. Scolnic, Hee‐Jong Seo, David N. Spergel, Michael A. Strauss, Risa H. Wechsler, David H. WeinbergCaltechAUTHORS 2019 · DOI

Abstract: The nature of dark energy remains a profound mystery 20 years after the discovery of cosmic acceleration. A very high number density galaxy redshift survey over a wide area (HD GRS Wide) spanning the redshift range of $0.5 < z < 4$ is proposed to solve this mystery. By mapping 183 million galaxies, this survey aims to provide definitive measurements of cosmic expansion and the growth of large-scale structures, effectively distinguishing between new energy components and modifications to General Relativity.

1. Introduction: The Dark Energy Challenge

For over two decades, the accelerated expansion of the universe has stood as one of the most significant challenges in modern physics. This phenomenon, attributed to "dark energy," could be explained by a cosmological constant (vacuum energy), a dynamic scalar field, or a fundamental breakdown of Einstein’s General Relativity on cosmological scales. While upcoming missions like the Vera C. Rubin Observatory (LSST), Euclid, and the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope (WFIRST) will provide critical data, they face inherent limitations in redshift depth, galaxy density, and observational systematics. To definitively distinguish between a new energy component and modified gravity, we require simultaneous, high-precision measurements of both the expansion history ($H(z)$) and the growth rate of cosmic structures ($f_g(z)$).

2. The HD GRS Wide Mission Concept

The proposed High Density Galaxy Redshift Survey (HD GRS Wide) utilizes a space-based platform—such as the ATLAS Probe concept—to perform massively parallel, wide-field multi-object slit spectroscopy. Unlike the "slitless" spectroscopy planned for Euclid and WFIRST, which suffers from spectral overlap and high background noise, HD GRS Wide would employ Digital Micro-mirror Devices (DMDs) to act as slit selectors. This technology isolates individual galaxies, drastically reducing systematic errors and enhancing sensitivity.

The mission aims for a multiplex factor exceeding 5,000, allowing for the capture of thousands of spectra in a single exposure. This high efficiency enables a survey of unprecedented scale: 183 million galaxy spectra over 2,000 square degrees.

3. Unprecedented Galaxy Density and the Cosmic Web

The primary differentiator of HD GRS Wide is its sheer galaxy density—approximately 12 times that of WFIRST and 50 times that of Euclid. This density allows for a much more granular mapping of the "cosmic web," the large-scale structure of dark matter filaments that connect galaxy clusters.

Figure 3: A side-by-side comparison of the simulated galaxy distribution at redshift $z=2$. The HD GRS Wide (left) reveals a significantly denser sampling of the underlying cosmic web (green filaments) compared to the WFIRST GRS (right).

The high density is not just visually striking; it enables the use of higher-order statistics, specifically the 3-point correlation function (bispectrum). While standard 2-point statistics measure pairs of galaxies, the 3-point function captures the "shape" of the cosmic web, helping to break degeneracies between galaxy bias and cosmological parameters that limit current surveys.

4. Precision Cosmology and Growth of Structure

The scientific impact of HD GRS Wide is most evident in its projected precision for $H(z)$ and $f_g(z)$. By extending definitive measurements to $z=4$, the survey probes a regime currently inaccessible to Euclid and WFIRST, which is essential for testing "early dark energy" models.

Figure 6: Projected fractional errors for the Hubble parameter $H(z)$ (left) and the growth rate $f_g(z)/b(z)$ (right). HD GRS Wide (red and pink lines) demonstrates superior precision across a wide redshift range, particularly when utilizing 3-point statistics (pink).

As shown in Figure 6, HD GRS Wide is projected to improve constraints on the growth of structure by a factor of three or more compared to WFIRST in the $z=2-3$ range. The inclusion of 3-point statistics (HD GRS Wide 3pt) further drives down uncertainties, providing a robust test of General Relativity.

5. Synergies and Systematics Mitigation

Beyond direct clustering measurements, the survey offers transformative advantages for other cosmological probes:

  • Weak Lensing: By providing spectroscopic redshifts for 70% of the galaxies used in weak lensing samples, the survey eliminates the "photo-z calibration ladder"—a major source of error in photometric surveys like LSST.
  • Multi-Tracer Synergy: Observing different galaxy populations (e.g., red galaxies and emission-line galaxies) within the same volume allows for the cancellation of "cosmic variance," the statistical uncertainty inherent in observing a single universe.
  • Weighing Filaments: The survey's precision enables the detection of the mass of dark matter filaments by stacking lensing signals from galaxy pairs with known spectroscopic positions.

6. Conclusion and Future Outlook

The HD GRS Wide represents a "Probe-class" mission that could settle the dark energy debate. While it presents significant data management challenges—requiring advanced server-side analysis facilities—the potential for a "smoking gun" discovery in modified gravity justifies the investment. By providing a high-fidelity map of the universe's expansion and structural growth up to $z=4$, HD GRS Wide will illuminate the dark sectors of our cosmos.

Summary updated

Abstract

The nature of dark energy remains a profound mystery 20 years after the discovery of cosmic acceleration. A very high number density galaxy redshift survey over a wide area (HD GRS Wide) spanning the redshift range of 0.5
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019illuminating,
  author = {Yun Wang and Rachel Bean and Peter Behroozi and Chia-Hsun Chuang and Ian Dell’Antonio and Mark Dickinson and Olivier Doré and Daniel J. Eisenstein and R. J. Foley and Karl Glazebrook and L. Guzzo and Christopher M. Hirata and Shirley Ho and Michael J. Hudson and Bhuvnesh Jain and Priyamvada Natarajan and Jeff Newman and Álvaro Orsi and Nikhil Padmanabhan and J. A. Peacock and Will J. Percival and Jason Rhodes and Eduardo Rozo and Lado Samushia and D. Scolnic and Hee‐Jong Seo and David N. Spergel and Michael A. Strauss and Risa H. Wechsler and David H. Weinberg},
  title = {{Illuminating the dark universe with a very high density galaxy redshift survey over a wide area}},
  booktitle = {CaltechAUTHORS},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.48550/arxiv.1903.06034},
}
Figure