Illuminating Dark Matter Admixed in Neutron Stars with Simultaneous Mass-Radius Constraints

Naibo Zhang, Bao-An Li, Jiayu Zhang, Weina Shen, Hui ZhangSymmetry 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how simultaneous measurements of neutron star mass and radius can significantly improve constraints on the properties of dark matter admixed within these extreme objects. By analyzing data from PSR J0740+6620, the authors demonstrate that combining mass and radius information reduces uncertainties in dark matter energy density by over 50%, suggesting that dark matter fractions in neutron stars are likely very small.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dark matter, a dominant component of the universe, remains elusive in its fundamental nature. While direct detection experiments have yet to yield conclusive results, indirect methods offer alternative avenues for exploration. Neutron stars, with their incredibly dense cores, provide a unique laboratory to probe the behavior of dark matter under extreme conditions. The presence of dark matter within neutron stars, forming "dark matter admixed neutron stars" (DANSS), can alter their observable properties. However, constraining the specific properties of this admixed dark matter, such as its mass and interaction strength, has been challenging due to the inherent uncertainties in both nuclear matter equations of state and the limited observational data available. This paper aims to leverage precise, simultaneous mass and radius measurements of a specific neutron star to tighten these constraints and shed light on the nature of dark matter.

Methods

The study employs a theoretical framework that models fermionic dark matter interacting solely through gravity. The nuclear matter equation of state (EOS) is taken from a well-constrained model (PEOS) that aligns with current astrophysical observations. The dark matter EOS is described using a relativistic mean-field approximation, incorporating both vector and scalar meson interactions. The core of the methodology involves solving the two-fluid Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkov (TOV) equations to determine the structure and properties of DANSS.

Crucially, the authors utilize a "3D parameter space" approach to analyze the constraints. This involves systematically varying four dark matter parameters: the dark matter particle mass ($m_D$), the coupling constants for the vector ($g_V$) and scalar ($g_S$) mesons, and the ratio of dark matter to nuclear matter energy densities ($\epsilon_D/\epsilon_N$). They then compare these theoretical predictions with observational data, specifically the mass and radius of the neutron star PSR J0740+6620, to identify parameter regions consistent with observations. This method allows for a direct visualization of how different parameter combinations affect observable quantities.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study consists of observational data for the neutron star PSR J0740+6620. Specifically, the paper utilizes:

  • Mass: $M = 2.08 \pm 0.08 M_\odot$
  • Radius: Two independent measurements are considered: $R = 13.7 \pm 2.0$ km and $R = 12.39 \pm 0.38$ km.

The authors emphasize that the simultaneous measurement of both mass and radius provides significantly tighter constraints than using either observable alone.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Mass and Radius: The most striking insight is that combining mass and radius measurements for a neutron star offers a far more powerful constraint on dark matter properties than using either measurement in isolation. This is because these two observables probe different aspects of the star's internal structure and composition.
  • Dark Matter Fraction is Small: The analysis strongly suggests that the fraction of dark matter within neutron stars is very small. The paper finds that the dark matter fraction ($f_D$) is likely less than 2% when constrained by the maximum mass alone, and can be as low as 0.3% when simultaneous mass-radius constraints are applied. This implies that neutron stars are predominantly composed of nuclear matter.
  • Constraining Energy Density, Not Interactions: While the simultaneous mass-radius constraint significantly narrows down the possible range for the dark matter's central energy density, it does not effectively constrain the interaction parameters (CDS and CDV) of the dark matter model. This suggests that the overall presence and density of dark matter are more readily detectable than the specific ways it interacts with nuclear matter.
  • Dark Matter Core Formation: The study focuses on scenarios where dark matter forms a "core" within the neutron star, which is consistent with the dark matter particle masses considered ($m_D \ge 500$ MeV).

Key Results

  • Simultaneous mass and radius measurements of PSR J0740+6620 reduce the uncertainty in the dark matter central energy density by more than 50% compared to using these observables independently.
  • The dark matter fraction ($f_D$) in neutron stars is constrained to be less than 2% based on the maximum mass constraint ($M_{max} = 2.08 M_\odot$).
  • Applying the simultaneous mass-radius constraint ($R_{2.08} = 12.2$ km) further reduces the upper limit on the dark matter fraction to approximately 0.3%.
  • The parameters related to dark matter interaction strengths (CDS and CDV) remain largely unconstrained by the current observations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their analysis relies on a specific model for fermionic dark matter and a particular nuclear matter equation of state. While this EOS is well-constrained, other nuclear matter models (e.g., those including hyperons or phase transitions) could lead to different constraints. The study also did not explore scenarios with dark matter halos, focusing instead on dark matter cores, which are more likely for the particle masses considered.

Future work could involve:

  • Investigating the impact of different nuclear matter equations of state on dark matter constraints.
  • Exploring the effects of dark matter halos and other dark matter models (e.g., bosonic dark matter).
  • Leveraging future, more precise measurements of neutron star masses and radii from observatories like NICER and upcoming gravitational wave detectors to further tighten constraints.
  • Developing more sophisticated Bayesian analysis techniques to explore the parameter space more comprehensively and quantify uncertainties more rigorously.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2025illuminating,
  author = {Naibo Zhang and Bao-An Li and Jiayu Zhang and Weina Shen and Hui Zhang},
  title = {{Illuminating Dark Matter Admixed in Neutron Stars with Simultaneous Mass-Radius Constraints}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/sym17101669},
}
Figure