Illegitimate Recombination Between Homeologous Genes in Wheat Genome

Chao Liu, Jinpeng Wang, Pengchuan Sun, Jigao Yu, Fanbo Meng, Zhikang Zhang, He Guo, Chendan Wei, Xinyu Li, Shaoqi Shen, Xiyin WangFrontiers in Plant Science 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Polyploidy events generate vast numbers of duplicated genes, driving long-term genetic innovation. In hexaploid wheat (Triticum aestivum), the high similarity between homeologous chromosomes from different subgenomes can lead to "illegitimate" DNA recombination. By aligning the genomes of common wheat and its relatives based on gene colinearity, researchers identified over 2,000 gene pairs affected by gene conversion. This process, where one gene sequence is overwritten by its counterpart from another subgenome, significantly impacts essential biological functions, including starch biosynthesis. These findings suggest that the wheat genome remains unstable millennia after its formation, with the D-subgenome frequently acting as a sequence donor.

Introduction: The Challenge of Genomic Redundancy

Common bread wheat is an allohexaploid, possessing three distinct subgenomes (A, B, and D) inherited from ancestral grass species. This complexity is compounded by an ancient whole-genome duplication (cWGD) shared by all grasses. When highly similar (homeologous) chromosomes coexist in a single nucleus, the cell's DNA repair machinery can occasionally mistake a sequence from one subgenome for its counterpart on another. This leads to illegitimate recombination and gene conversion, effectively "swapping" genetic identities between subgenomes. Quantifying this phenomenon is crucial for understanding how wheat evolves and how its key agricultural traits are maintained.

Methodology: Mapping Colinearity and Phylogenetic Shifts

To detect these conversion events, the study employed a comparative genomics approach centered on gene colinearity—the conserved order of genes along chromosomes. The researchers aligned the subgenomes of hexaploid wheat (AABBDD) against its closest relatives: Triticum urartu (AA), Aegilops tauschii (DD), and wild emmer wheat (AABB).

Circular representation of gene colinearity and homeologous relationships across the wheat subgenomes.

This alignment allowed for the identification of "homologous gene quartets," consisting of a gene from a diploid ancestor and its corresponding orthologs in the hexaploid subgenomes. Using tools like ColinearScan and OrthoMCL, phylogenetic trees were constructed for these quartets. Under standard vertical inheritance, a hexaploid gene should be most similar to its specific diploid ancestor. However, "aberrant topologies"—where a gene from one subgenome appears more closely related to a different subgenome's ancestor—serve as evidence of gene conversion.

Results: Widespread Genomic Reshuffling

The analysis revealed that gene conversion is a pervasive force in the wheat genome, affecting over 2,000 gene pairs.

Subgenome Dynamics and the "Newcomer" Advantage

The D-subgenome, which joined the wheat lineage most recently (approx. 10,000 years ago), was found to act as a sequence donor more frequently than an acceptor. In Ah-Dh conversions, the D-subgenome was the donor in ~62% of cases. This suggests that the "fresher" D-genome may provide a more stable template for repair compared to the older, more fractionated A and B genomes.

Phylogenetic models illustrating gene conversion events between subgenomes.

Impact on Starch Biosynthesis and Catalytic Functions

Gene conversion is not distributed randomly. Approximately 40% of catalytic genes involved in starch biosynthesis showed evidence of conversion. This indicates that concerted evolution—where multiple gene copies evolve in unison—may be a mechanism for maintaining high-demand metabolic pathways essential for grain quality and yield. Even genes duplicated during the ancient cWGD (100 million years ago) showed lingering evidence of conversion (0.83% to 1.71%), highlighting the long-term impact of these events.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study demonstrates that the wheat genome is in a state of "long-lasting lingering" instability. Illegitimate recombination continues to shape the genetic landscape of this global staple. While phylogenetic limitations exist, such as low bootstrap values for some catalytic genes, the scale of the findings is significant. Future work should explore how environmental stressors, such as climate change, might influence the frequency of these genomic "identity swaps," potentially accelerating the evolution of agricultural traits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Polyploidies produce a large number of duplicated regions and genes in genomes, which have a long-term impact and stimulate genetic innovation. The high similarity between homeologous chromosomes, forming different subgenomes, or homologous regions after genome repatterning, may permit illegitimate DNA recombination. Here, based on gene colinearity, we aligned the (sub)genomes of common wheat (<i>Triticum aestivum</i>, AABBDD genotype) and its relatives, including <i>Triticum urartu</i> (AA), <i>Aegilops tauschii</i> (DD), and <i>T. turgidum</i> ssp. dicoccoides (AABB) to detect the homeologous (paralogous or orthologous) colinear genes within and between (sub)genomes. Besides, we inferred more ancient paralogous regions produced by a much ancient grass-common tetraploidization. By comparing the sequence similarity between paralogous and orthologous genes, we assumed abnormality in the topology of constructed gene trees, which could be explained by gene conversion as a result of illegitimate recombination. We found large numbers of inferred converted genes (>2,000 gene pairs) suggested long-lasting genome instability of the hexaploid plant, and preferential donor roles by DD genes. Though illegitimate recombination was much restricted, duplicated genes produced by an ancient whole-genome duplication, which occurred millions of years ago, also showed evidence of likely gene conversion. As to biological function, we found that ~40% catalytic genes in colinearity, including those involved in starch biosynthesis, were likely affected by gene conversion. The present study will contribute to understanding the functional and structural innovation of the common wheat genome.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2020illegitimate,
  author = {Chao Liu and Jinpeng Wang and Pengchuan Sun and Jigao Yu and Fanbo Meng and Zhikang Zhang and He Guo and Chendan Wei and Xinyu Li and Shaoqi Shen and Xiyin Wang},
  title = {{Illegitimate Recombination Between Homeologous Genes in Wheat Genome}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2020.01076},
}
Figure