Identity Construction in a Misogynist Incels Forum

Michael Yoder, Chloe Perry, David Brown, Kathleen Carley, Meredith PrudenACL 2023

TL;DR

This paper analyzes identity construction within the misogynistic "incel" online community, revealing a pervasive ideology where physical appearance dictates human value. By using quantitative text and network analysis on the incels.is forum, the researchers identify novel identity terms and track the increasing mentions of marginalized groups, suggesting a consolidation with broader far-right discourse.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Online communities of "involuntary celibates" (incels) are notorious for generating misogynistic hate speech and inspiring real-world violence. While existing Natural Language Processing (NLP) research has begun to address misogynistic language, incel communities are characterized by significant lexical innovation, creating unique jargon that can be missed by standard hate speech detection models. This paper aims to provide researchers with a quantitative understanding of the language used in these forums, specifically focusing on how identities are constructed and discussed, which is crucial for developing more effective automated hate speech detection systems that can account for this evolving lexicon and ideology.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach combining quantitative text analysis and network analysis. They started with a large, generic lexicon of identity terms and expanded it by identifying community-specific neologisms through word embedding techniques. This expanded lexicon was used to measure the frequency of identity mentions and analyze their immediate textual contexts. Network analysis was used to identify "central users" within the forum based on their posting activity and connections, allowing for an examination of how these influential users discuss identities differently. Pointwise Mutual Information (PMI) was used to identify distinctive associations between identity terms and the actions or attributes attributed to them.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study consists of 6,248,234 English-language public comments from the incels.is forum, collected between November 2017 and April 2021. To provide a comparative analysis, the researchers also utilized a white supremacist dataset containing 3,410,623 posts from forums like Stormfront, Iron March, and 4chan /pol/, collected between 2015 and 2019.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pervasive Essentialism: The incel ideology strongly emphasizes an essentialist worldview where physical appearance, gender, and race are seen as determining an individual's inherent value.
  • Lexical Innovation: Incels are highly creative in coining new identity terms, particularly derogatory ones for women (e.g., "foids"), which are crucial for understanding and detecting their specific brand of hate speech.
  • Shifting Focus: While women and men are the most frequently mentioned identities, there's a notable increase in mentions of other marginalized groups like LGBTQ+, Black, and Jewish people, indicating a potential convergence with broader far-right discourses.
  • Central Users as Trendsetters: Influential users within the incel network disproportionately mention these other marginalized identities, suggesting they play a role in shaping the community's ideological focus.
  • Victimhood and Gatekeeping: The community exhibits strong themes of victimhood and "gatekeeping" around who can legitimately claim the "incel" identity, often based on perceived authenticity and adherence to specific ideological tenets.

Key Results

  • Mentions of women constitute nearly a quarter of all identity mentions, with a significant portion being derogatory neologisms.
  • Mentions of LGBTQ+, Black, and Jewish people have shown a steady rise over time, particularly in 2020 and 2021.
  • Central users are less likely to mention women but more likely to mention Black, LGBTQ+, and Jewish people, and also show increased use of terms like "truecels" and "fakecels."
  • Physical appearance is the most frequent attribute associated with most identity groups, reinforcing hierarchies of desirability.
  • The study identified 84 new community-specific identity terms, with many being derogatory.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their approach primarily focuses on explicit mentions of identity terms and may not fully capture implicit hate speech or attitudes towards specific individuals or groups. They also note that their analysis is limited to the incels.is forum, and the findings may not generalize to more moderate incel discourse or other manosphere communities. Future work could involve systematically evaluating existing hate speech classifiers' ability to handle incel jargon, comparing different incel forums, and investigating the role of platform affordances in user behavior. Further research could also explore the negotiation of race within inceldom and the intersection of racism and misogyny.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{yoder2023identity,
  author = {Michael Yoder and Chloe Perry and David Brown and Kathleen Carley and Meredith Pruden},
  title = {{Identity Construction in a Misogynist Incels Forum}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure