Identifying overcontrol and undercontrol personality types among young people using the five factor model, and the relationship with disordered eating behaviour, anxiety and depression

Tanya Gilmartin, Joanna F. Dipnall, Caroline Gurvich, Gemma SharpJournal of Eating Disorders 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies three distinct personality types—overcontrol (OC), undercontrol (UC), and resilient—in young adults using a detailed, facet-level analysis of the Five Factor Model (FFM). The research reveals that OC and UC personality types are significantly associated with higher levels of disordered eating, depression, and anxiety compared to resilient individuals, suggesting a more nuanced understanding of personality's role in mental health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of understanding the complex relationship between personality traits and mental health issues, particularly disordered eating, anxiety, and depression. While previous research has linked broad personality types (overcontrol, undercontrol, resilient) to these conditions, there's been a lack of consensus on how to precisely define and measure these types. This ambiguity hinders the translation of research findings into clinical practice. The authors aim to refine this understanding by using a more granular approach, examining individual facets of the FFM rather than just the broad domains, and applying this to a non-clinical sample of young adults to identify distinct personality clusters and their association with clinical symptoms.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage cluster analysis approach to identify personality types. This involved:

  • Hierarchical, k-means, and random forest cluster analyses: These methods were used to explore different cluster solutions.
  • Model Selection: The Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) and Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) were used to determine the optimal number of clusters, with a three-cluster solution being selected as the best fit.
  • Facet-Level Analysis: Crucially, the study focused on the 30 facets of the Five Factor Model (FFM) rather than just the five broad domains. This allowed for a more detailed examination of how specific personality traits contribute to each cluster.
  • Statistical Analysis: One-way ANOVAs and Bonferroni adjusted post-hoc analyses were used to identify significant differences in FFM facets, eating pathology symptoms (EPSI), disordered eating severity (EDE-QS), and depression, anxiety, and stress (DASS-21) scores across the identified clusters. Linear regression was used to predict clinical outcomes based on cluster membership, controlling for age and gender.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a sample of 561 Australian young adults (aged 16-30 years). Participants completed a survey that included:

  • IPIP-NEO-120: A 120-item measure assessing the five domains and 30 facets of the FFM.
  • Eating Pathology Symptoms Inventory (EPSI): A 45-item scale measuring various disordered eating behaviors.
  • Eating Disorder Examination Questionnaire-Short (EDE-QS): A 12-item scale assessing the frequency of disordered eating behaviors, with scores of 15 or above indicative of a potential eating disorder.
  • Depression Anxiety Stress Scale-21 (DASS-21): A 21-item scale measuring negative mood states across depression, anxiety, and stress subscales.

The study did not introduce new benchmarks but rather used established measures to analyze a non-clinical, mixed-gender sample.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Facet-Level Granularity is Key: The study strongly suggests that examining individual facets of personality, rather than just broad FFM domains, provides a more nuanced and meaningful way to identify distinct personality types. This is a significant departure from much previous research.
  • Three Distinct Personality Types Emerge: The cluster analysis successfully identified three groups that align with theoretical constructs: overcontrol (OC), undercontrol (UC), and resilient. This provides empirical support for these typologies.
  • OC and UC are Risk Factors: Both OC and UC personality types are significantly associated with higher levels of disordered eating, depression, and anxiety compared to the resilient group. This highlights their vulnerability to clinical symptoms.
  • Overlapping Clinical Presentations: Despite differences in underlying personality facets, the OC and UC groups exhibited similar levels of clinical pathology, suggesting that different personality structures can manifest in comparable behavioral expressions of distress.
  • Gender Matters for Clinical Outcomes: Being female was found to be a significant predictor of higher EDE-QS and stress scores, underscoring the importance of considering gender in understanding disordered eating and stress.

Key Results

  • Cluster Identification: A three-cluster solution was identified, representing Overcontrol (OC), Undercontrol (UC), and Resilient personality types.
  • Personality Facet Differences: The OC cluster was characterized by high anxiety, depression, self-consciousness, and vulnerability, while the UC cluster showed high anger, immoderation, and excitement seeking. The resilient cluster displayed low Neuroticism and high Extraversion and Agreeableness.
  • Clinical Symptom Association: Individuals in the OC and UC clusters were significantly more likely to achieve clinical scores on the EDE-QS (indicating potential eating disorders) compared to the resilient cluster (44% and 52.4% vs. 21%).
  • Predictive Power: Membership in the OC or UC cluster significantly predicted higher scores on the EDE-QS and all DASS-21 subscales (depression, anxiety, stress) compared to the resilient cluster, even after controlling for age and gender.
  • Specific Eating Behaviors: The UC type scored higher on negative attitudes towards obesity, binge eating, purging, and chewing/spitting compared to OC and resilient types. The OC type scored higher than the resilient type on body dissatisfaction and dietary restriction.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Demographics: The majority of participants identified as White, which may limit the generalizability of findings to other ethnic groups, given known variability in eating disorder presentations.
  • Self-Report Measures: The reliance on self-report data is a standard limitation, though the measures used were validated.
  • Non-Clinical Sample: While a strength for identifying normative personality types, the use of a non-clinical sample may limit direct clinical translation. Future research could explore these personality types in clinical samples.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature prevents causal inferences and understanding how personality and eating behaviors predict each other over time. Longitudinal studies are recommended.
  • Measure Limitations: Some FFM subscales had questionable internal consistency and were removed, and the use of a normative personality measure might not fully capture maladaptive variants. Future work could explore clinical versions of FFM measures or those specifically designed for maladaptive traits.

Future research directions include:

  • Investigating these personality types in clinical samples.
  • Exploring how FFM facets associated with OC and UC relate to clinical conceptualizations of these types and their treatment suitability (e.g., RO-DBT for OC, DBT for UC).
  • Conducting longitudinal studies to understand the predictive relationships between personality and eating behaviors.
  • Examining how adaptive versus maladaptive representations of FFM traits influence psychopathology.

Summary updated

Abstract

It was concluded that FFM facets may potentially be more meaningful than broad domains in identifying personality types, and that both overcontrol and undercontrol personality types are likely associated with increased clinical symptoms.
BibTeX
@article{gilmartin2024identifying,
  author = {Tanya Gilmartin and Joanna F. Dipnall and Caroline Gurvich and Gemma Sharp},
  title = {{Identifying overcontrol and undercontrol personality types among young people using the five factor model, and the relationship with disordered eating behaviour, anxiety and depression}},
  journal = {Journal of Eating Disorders},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s40337-024-00967-4},
}
Figure