Identifying Long-Term Effects of SARS-CoV-2 and Their Association with Social Determinants of Health in a Cohort of Over One Million COVID-19 Survivors

Sumit Mukherjee, Meghana Kshirsagar, Nicholas Becker, Yixi Xu, William B. Weeks, Shwetak Patel, Juan Lavista Ferres, Michael L. JacksonResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Despite an abundance of information on the risk factors of SARS-CoV-2, large-scale studies of long-term effects are lacking. This study analyzed a large medical claims database of US-based individuals to identify common long-term effects and their associations with various social and medical risk factors. Using a self-controlled cohort design (SCCD) on over 1.37 million COVID-19 survivors, 36 ICD-10 codes were found to be significantly increased in the post-COVID period. While age and gender were strongly associated with multiple long-term effects, other social determinants of health (SDOH) such as race, income, and education level showed rare or no significant associations.

Introduction

While the acute phase of COVID-19 is well-characterized, the phenomenon of "Long COVID"—the persistence or emergence of symptoms months after infection—remains a complex challenge for public health. Existing research has often been limited by small sample sizes or a lack of socio-economic diversity. This study addresses these gaps by systematically identifying long-term medical complications and evaluating how social determinants of health (SDOH) influence their manifestation.

Methods

The researchers utilized a Self-Controlled Cohort Design (SCCD), where each patient serves as their own control. This approach inherently adjusts for baseline health and lifestyle factors.

  • Comparison Periods: The "outcome period" began two months after COVID-19 diagnosis, while the "control period" was set 10 to 7 months prior to diagnosis.
  • Seasonality: By aligning the control period exactly one year before the end of the outcome period, the study accounted for seasonal disease variations.
  • Statistical Analysis: Over 1,700 ICD-10 code groups were analyzed using a 2-proportion z-test with Bonferroni correction. Logistic regression was then used to assess associations with SDOH variables, adjusting for pre-existing comorbidities.

Data Overview

The study analyzed de-identified medical claims from Change Healthcare, covering 1.37 million COVID-19 positive patients diagnosed between March and September 2020. A subset of 602,025 patients included detailed SDOH data, including race, income, education, and veteran status.

Demographic distribution of the study cohort across various social determinants of health, including age, gender, and income.

Key Results

The analysis identified 36 ICD-10 code groups that were statistically significantly increased in the post-infection period. These complications primarily clustered into pulmonary, cardiac, and metabolic categories.

A selection of the 36 ICD-10 codes showing significant increases in the post-COVID period for both SDOH and non-SDOH cohorts.

Significant Findings:

  • Pulmonary and Cardiac: Notable increases were seen in viral pneumonia (J12), acute respiratory distress syndrome (J80), and pulmonary embolism (I26).
  • Metabolic Toll: A significant rise in protein-calorie malnutrition (E43-E46) suggests a severe metabolic impact from the virus.
  • Neurological/Fatigue: Postviral fatigue syndrome (G93.3) was 4.4 times more prevalent post-infection, validating patient reports of "brain fog."
  • SDOH Associations: Age and gender were the most consistent predictors of long-term effects. In contrast, race was only significantly associated with 'other sepsis' (A41), and income was only associated with 'Alopecia areata' (L63).

Conclusion

This large-scale study confirms that SARS-CoV-2 has a broad spectrum of long-term health impacts. Interestingly, while SDOH factors like race and income are critical in acute COVID-19 outcomes, they appear to have a much narrower influence on the specific types of long-term complications that develop. Future research should focus on distinguishing between transient symptoms and permanent sequelae to better inform long-term care strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: Despite an abundance of information on the risk factors of SARS-CoV-2, large scale studies of long-term effects are lacking. In this paper we analyzed a large medical claims database of US based individuals to identify common long-term effects as well as their associations with various social and medical risk factors. Methods: The medical claims database was obtained from a prominent US based claims data processing company, namely Change Healthcare. In addition to the claims data, the dataset also consisted of various social determinants of health such as race, income, education level and veteran status of the individuals. A self-controlled cohort design (SCCD) observational study was performed to identify ICD-10 codes whose proportion was significantly increased in the outcome period compared to the control period to identify significant long-term effects. A logistic regression-based association analysis was then performed between identified long-term effects and social determinants of health. Results: Among the over 1.37 million COVID patients in our datasets we found 36 out of 1,724 3-digit ICD-10 codes to be statistically significantly increased in the post-COVID period (p-value <0.05). We also found one combination of ICD-10 codes, corresponding to ‘other anemias’ and ‘hypertension’, that was statistically significantly increased in the post-COVID period (p-value <0.05). Our logistic regression-based association analysis with social determinants of health variables, after adjusting for comorbidities and prior conditions, showed that age and gender were significantly associated with the multiple long-term effects. Race was only associated with ‘other sepsis’, income was only associated with ‘Alopecia areata’, while education level was only associated with ‘Maternal infectious and parasitic diseases’ (p-value <0.05). Conclusion: We identified several long-term effects of SARS-CoV-2 through a self-controlled study on a cohort of over one million patients. Furthermore, we found that while age and gender are commonly associated with the long-term effects, other social determinants of health such as race, income and education levels have rare or no significant associations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mukherjee2021identifying,
  author = {Sumit Mukherjee and Meghana Kshirsagar and Nicholas Becker and Yixi Xu and William B. Weeks and Shwetak Patel and Juan Lavista Ferres and Michael L. Jackson},
  title = {{Identifying Long-Term Effects of SARS-CoV-2 and Their Association with Social Determinants of Health in a Cohort of Over One Million COVID-19 Survivors}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-1032897/v1},
}
Figure