TL;DR
This paper introduces DeLIR, a neuro-symbolic approach that combines grammatical parsing with fine-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) to translate natural language text into first-order logic (FOL) for ontology learning. DeLIR achieves high syntactic accuracy in translation and shows promising results in logical reasoning, even outperforming larger models in some cases.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Building ontologies, which are structured representations of knowledge, is crucial for automated reasoning and understanding digital content. Traditionally, ontologies are built manually, a tedious and time-consuming process. Ontology Learning (OL) aims to automate this by extracting knowledge from text. While identifying concepts and relations is well-studied, a significant challenge remains in automatically extracting complex logical patterns and axioms from text and translating them into a formal logic representation (like FOL) that can be used for deductive reasoning. Existing approaches often struggle with the ambiguity of natural language and the consistency of logical translations, especially when dealing with a wide range of axioms.
Methods
DeLIR employs a two-pronged neuro-symbolic approach:
- Grammatical Translation: This component leverages Universal Dependencies (UD) to parse sentences into dependency trees. It recursively traverses these trees to identify syntactic patterns (like Subject-Verb-Object) and translates them into FOL formulas. This method is designed to ensure high syntactic accuracy and control over the generated logic. It also incorporates a coreference resolution algorithm to correctly associate pronouns and variables.
- LLM Fine-tuning: The paper fine-tunes various Large Language Models (LLMs), including T5, TinyLlama, Llama-7B, and Mistral-7B, using a technique called LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation). This fine-tuning is performed in different configurations:
- Text-only: LLMs are trained on natural language text.
- Grammar-only: LLMs are trained on the output of the grammatical approach.
- Text + Grammar: LLMs are trained on both natural language text and the grammatically translated FOL formulas.
The goal is to combine the syntactic rigor of the grammatical approach with the pattern flexibility and broader knowledge of LLMs.
Datasets
The primary dataset used for both training and evaluation is FOLIO. This dataset is designed to benchmark natural language systems in deductive reasoning. It consists of natural language sentences (premises and conclusions) paired with their corresponding first-order logic representations. FOLIO includes both an inference task (predicting True/False/Uncertain) and a translation task (converting natural language to FOL).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Grammar as a Controller: Using grammatical parsing as an input or guide for LLMs helps control the learning process and prevent LLMs from "hallucinating" or generating syntactically incorrect logic.
- Neuro-Symbolic Synergy: Combining a rule-based grammatical approach with data-driven LLMs yields better results than either method alone for both translation and reasoning tasks. The grammatical approach provides a strong foundation for syntactic correctness, while LLMs offer flexibility in capturing a wider range of patterns.
- Smaller Models Can Be Powerful: Fine-tuned smaller LLMs (like Mistral-7B) can achieve accuracy comparable to much larger models (like GPT-4) on specific tasks, especially when guided by a structured approach.
- Consistency is Key: LLMs can struggle with consistent translation of natural language to FOL. The proposed approach aims to mitigate this by leveraging grammatical structure.
Key Results
- Translation Accuracy: The pure grammatical approach achieved the highest parsing accuracy (97.88%). When combining T5 with the grammatical approach (Text + Grammar), it achieved the best BLEU (44.45%) and ROUGE (64.11%) scores for translation. For decoder LLMs (TinyLlama, Llama-7B, Mistral-7B), integrating the grammatical approach improved BLEU scores by up to +5% and ROUGE by +4%.
- Reasoning Performance: In zero-shot learning, larger models generally performed better, with GPT-4 achieving 61.3% accuracy. However, fine-tuned smaller models showed significant improvements. Notably, TinyLlama (1B parameters) with the DeLIR approach achieved 63.1% accuracy, outperforming zero-shot GPT-4. Mistral-7B, when fine-tuned for inference, achieved 77.3% accuracy, close to Logic-LM (based on GPT-4) but with significantly fewer parameters.
Limitations and Future Work
- Grammatical Coverage: The grammatical approach has a limited coverage of syntactic and logical patterns, particularly for complex cases like cardinality restrictions. This limits its flexibility.
- Syntactic Accuracy vs. Flexibility: While the grammatical approach ensures syntactic correctness, it may not capture all logical nuances. Conversely, LLMs offer flexibility but can lack syntactic precision. The combined approach aims to balance these, but the syntactic accuracy of the combined method doesn't reach that of the pure grammatical approach.
- Future Work: The authors plan to design a joint loss function to perform text-to-FOL translation and FOL reasoning simultaneously. They also intend to explore other logical patterns within dependency parsing trees, such as cardinality restrictions.
Summary updated