Identifying Invariant Factors Across Multiple Environments with KL Regression

Jaime Roquero Gimenez, James ZouarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Many datasets are collected from multiple environments (e.g. different labs, perturbations, etc.), and it is often advantageous to learn models and relations that are invariant across environments. Invariance can improve robustness to unknown confounders and improve generalization to new domains. We develop a novel framework -- KL regression -- to reliably estimate regression coefficients in a challenging multi-environment setting, where latent confounders affect the data from each environment. KL regression is based on a new objective of simultaneously minimizing the KL- divergence between a parametric model and the observed data from each environment. We prove that KL regression recovers the true invariant factors under a flexible confounding setup. Moreover, it is computationally efficient as we derive an analytic solution for its global optimum. In systematic experiments, we validate the improved performance of KL regression compared to commonly used approaches.

Introduction

In fields ranging from genomics to social sciences, data is frequently aggregated from diverse "environments"—such as different laboratories, experimental batches, or distinct populations. A persistent challenge in analyzing such data is the presence of spurious correlations. A relationship observed in one environment may vanish or reverse in another due to the influence of latent confounders: unobserved variables that simultaneously affect both the features and the target variable.

Standard statistical methods like Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) often fail in these scenarios because they cannot distinguish between stable causal links and transient correlations driven by hidden factors. While meta-analysis techniques attempt to combine results across environments, they often produce biased estimates when confounding factors shift between domains. This paper introduces Kullback-Leibler (KL) regression, a framework designed to identify invariant factors—relationships that remain constant across environments—thereby uncovering the underlying causal structure.

Methodology: The KL Regression Framework

Unlike traditional regression, which focuses on the conditional distribution of a target given features, KL regression considers the joint distribution of features ($X$) and targets ($Y$) across all available environments. The core objective is to minimize the sum of KL divergences between a parametric Gaussian model and the empirical data observed in each environment.

Causal graph illustrating the relationship between features X, target Y, and latent confounder H.

As shown in Figure 1, the model assumes a structure where a latent confounder $H$ influences both $X$ and $Y$. The key innovation of KL regression lies in its reparametrization: it decomposes the regression coefficient into an invariant causal component ($\beta^*$) and an environment-specific confounding bias. By learning this bias across multiple environments, the model can effectively "subtract" the confounding effect to recover the true invariant signal.

Technical advantages of this approach include:

  • Analytic Solution: The authors derive a closed-form global optimum, ensuring computational efficiency.
  • Lasso Integration: An $L_1$-penalized version allows for high-dimensional feature selection, crucial for applications like gene regulatory network inference.

Experimental Evaluation

The authors evaluated KL regression against several state-of-the-art causal inference methods, including Invariant Causal Prediction (ICP), Anchor Regression, and Causal Dantzig.

Synthetic Benchmarks

Using Linear Structural Equation Models (SEMs), the researchers simulated data with varying levels of confounding and environment counts. As illustrated in Figure 2, KL regression (specifically the regularized version) consistently achieves significantly lower Mean Squared Error (MSE) than competing methods. Notably, the performance gap widens as the number of environments increases, supporting the idea that environmental diversity is an asset for identifying invariant signals.

MSE comparison between KL regression and state-of-the-art methods across varying sample sizes and environment counts.

Real-World Application: DREAM Challenges

The method was also applied to the DREAM4 and DREAM5 challenges, which are standard benchmarks for inferring Gene Regulatory Networks (GRNs). KL regression achieved the top score on the DREAM5 leaderboard, demonstrating its practical utility in complex biological systems where perturbations (e.g., gene knock-outs) create naturally diverse environments.

Discussion and Conclusion

KL regression shifts the perspective on "batch effects" from a nuisance to be corrected to a source of information for triangulation. The fundamental premise is that true causal mechanisms are universal; if a relationship is invariant across diverse conditions, it is likely causal.

While the current framework assumes linear relationships, its success on the non-linear DREAM5 dataset suggests inherent robustness. Future work may extend this to Generalized Linear Models (GLMs) to formally handle non-linearities. Additionally, while the method is robust to non-Gaussian data, exploring its performance in ultra-high-dimensional settings with extremely limited samples per environment remains an important direction for research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many datasets are collected from multiple environments (e.g. different labs, perturbations, etc.), and it is often advantageous to learn models and relations that are invariant across environments. Invariance can improve robustness to unknown confounders and improve generalization to new domains. We develop a novel framework -- KL regression -- to reliably estimate regression coefficients in a challenging multi-environment setting, where latent confounders affect the data from each environment. KL regression is based on a new objective of simultaneously minimizing the KL- divergence between a parametric model and the observed data from each environment. We prove that KL regression recovers the true invariant factors under a flexible confounding setup. Moreover, it is computationally efficient as we derive an analytic solution for its global optimum. In systematic experiments, we validate the improved performance of KL regression compared to commonly used approaches.
BibTeX
@misc{gimenez2020identifying,
  author = {Jaime Roquero Gimenez and James Zou},
  title = {{Identifying Invariant Factors Across Multiple Environments with KL Regression}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2002.08341},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2002.08341},
}
Figure