Identifying Ecological Restoration Zones Based on Ecological Security Patterns: A Case Study of a Resource-Transitioning District

Yun Ma, Ran Wang, Yahua Wang, Hui Ci, Hui Yang, Jiakun Teng, Bin Zhu, Yuqing Gu, Yuan Yuan, Yingying Zhu, Jianhua ChenResearch Square 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an integrated "assessment–pattern–zoning" framework to guide ecological restoration in resource-transitioning cities, specifically those scarred by intensive mining. By combining ecosystem service modeling with circuit theory, the authors successfully mapped critical ecological corridors and identified four distinct restoration zones in China's Tongshan District to balance urban expansion with environmental resilience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Resource-based cities—those built around industries like coal mining—face a unique "double whammy" of ecological degradation: the historical damage from extraction (like land subsidence) and the modern pressure of rapid urbanization.

Traditional ecological restoration often fails in these areas because it typically focuses on single factors (like just planting trees) or relies on subjective zoning that ignores how species actually move through a fragmented landscape. There is a lack of integrated frameworks that can translate complex spatial data into actionable planning zones that account for both natural health and human-induced stressors.

Methods

The researchers proposed a three-stage framework:

  1. Assessment: They used the InVEST (Integrated Valuation of Ecosystem Services and Tradeoffs) model to quantify five key ecosystem services: water yield, habitat quality, carbon fixation/oxygen release, soil conservation, and carbon sequestration. They then calculated a Comprehensive Ecosystem Service Index (CESI) and used Sen’s slope estimation to track trends from 2005 to 2022.
  2. Pattern Construction: To move beyond simple mapping, they applied Circuit Theory (via the Linkage Mapper tool). This treats the landscape like a giant circuit board where "ecological sources" are power nodes and the rest of the land provides "resistance" to movement. This allowed them to identify not just corridors, but also "pinch points" (bottlenecks for wildlife) and "barriers" (areas where restoration would most improve connectivity).
  3. Zoning: Finally, they developed a novel Zoning Index ($I$). This index combines the current ecosystem service level ($CESI_{2022}$), the resistance to movement ($R'$), and the historical trend ($\beta$). This quantitative approach allowed them to divide the district into four zones: Restoration, Warning, Buffer, and Conservation.

Datasets

The study utilized a multi-source dataset spanning 2005 to 2022:

  • Environmental Data: Precipitation and evaporation (National Earth System Science Data Center), soil data (FAO), and MODIS NPP for carbon modeling.
  • Land Use & Infrastructure: 30m resolution land-use maps, Digital Elevation Models (DEM), and road networks.
  • Anthropogenic Stressors: Nighttime lights (as a proxy for human activity) and specific vector data for coal mining subsidence areas provided by the local Natural Resources and Planning Bureau.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "N-Shaped" Trend: Ecosystem services didn't just decline; they followed an "N" shape. A sharp dip occurred around 2010, coinciding with Tongshan's administrative upgrade from a "County" to a "District," which triggered a massive construction boom. Services began to recover by 2015 due to targeted restoration policies.
  • Mining as a Unique Resistance: Unlike many studies that only look at slope or land cover, this paper explicitly integrates mining subsidence as a major barrier to ecological flow. This makes the model far more accurate for industrial regions.
  • Circuitry of Nature: By identifying 57 "pinch points," the authors highlight that ecological health isn't just about the total area of forest, but about the specific "fuses" in the system that, if broken, could collapse the entire regional network.
  • Validation through Overlap: The model's "Conservation Zones" showed a high degree of overlap with existing "Ecological Protection Red Lines," providing a strong sanity check for the framework's accuracy.

Key Results

  • The ESP Map: The Ecological Security Pattern (ESP) identified 126.6 $km^2$ of sources (mostly water and forest) and 592.31 km of corridors.
  • Fragmentation Identified: The team located 222 ecological breakpoints, primarily where road networks intersected with corridors, signaling exactly where "green bridges" or underpasses are needed.
  • Zoning Breakdown:
    • Buffer Zone (53.91%): The largest area, representing a massive opportunity for managed development that maintains connectivity.
  • Warning & Restoration Zones: These were heavily concentrated in the northern regions near Weishan Lake and historical mining sites, where "urgent measures" are required to prevent further deterioration.
  • Conservation Zone (10.80%): High-quality areas that require strict protection from any construction.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge two primary limitations:

  1. Static Resistance: The resistance surface used for circuit theory is a "snapshot." In reality, land use changes dynamically, and a static model might miss shifting ecological pressures.
  2. Missing Socio-Economics: The framework is purely ecological. It does not yet account for the economic cost of restoration or the specific preferences of local stakeholders, which are crucial for real-world implementation.

Future research aims to incorporate dynamic simulations and socio-economic trade-off analysis to further refine these restoration strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Resource-based cities frequently encounter ecological problems such as landscape fragmentation and environmental degradation and need ecological restoration. Previous studies often focused on single-factor restoration or ecological security patterns (ESPs) construction, lacking integrated frameworks that couple spatial patterns with restoration zoning in mining-affected urban areas. This study proposes an integrated framework of "assessment–pattern–zoning" and applies it to Tongshan District, Xuzhou City—a typical resource-transitioning city in China. The ecosystem services in 2005, 2010, 2015, and 2022 were assessed by the Integrated Valuation of Ecosystem Services and Tradeoffs (InVEST) model. Following the "source–resistance–corridor" paradigm, this study constructed the ESP and developed a zoning index to delineate ecological zones. The results indicate that: (1) The ecosystem service of Tongshan District displayed strong spatial heterogeneity, with the mean value exhibiting an "N"-shaped trend and a marked decline in 2010; (2) The ESP comprised 126.6 km² of ecological sources, 592.31 km of ecological corridors, 57 ecological pinch points, 21 ecological barrier areas, and 222 ecological breakpoints, mainly concentrated in the northeast and central regions; (3) Tongshan District was divided into ecological restoration zone, warning zone, buffer zone, and conservation zone. The buffer zone covered the largest area (1,001.44 km², 53.91%), while most conservation zone (31.08%) overlapped with the ecological protection red line. Warning and restoration zones were concentrated in subsidence-affected areas. These findings offer practical insights for spatial planning and restoration in resource-based cities undergoing industrial transformation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2025identifying,
  author = {Yun Ma and Ran Wang and Yahua Wang and Hui Ci and Hui Yang and Jiakun Teng and Bin Zhu and Yuqing Gu and Yuan Yuan and Yingying Zhu and Jianhua Chen},
  title = {{Identifying Ecological Restoration Zones Based on Ecological Security Patterns: A Case Study of a Resource-Transitioning District}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-7072536/v1},
}
Figure