Identifying and addressing psychosocial determinants of adherence to physical distancing guidance during the COVID-19 pandemic – project protocol

Hannah Durand, Simon Bacon, Molly Byrne, Eanna Kenny, Kim Lavoie, Brian E. McGuire, Jenny McSharry, Oonagh Meade, Robert Mooney, Chris Noone, Laura O’Connor, Kate O'Flaherty, Gerard J. MolloyHRB 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper outlines a research protocol designed to understand why people struggle to adhere to physical distancing guidelines during the COVID-19 pandemic. By combining quantitative and qualitative methods, the study aims to identify key psychosocial factors influencing adherence and to inform more effective public health communication strategies in Ireland.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the critical importance of public adherence to physical distancing measures for controlling virus transmission. However, evidence suggests that adherence to these measures has been significantly lower than for other behaviors like handwashing. This discrepancy points to a complex interplay of psychological, social, and behavioral factors that deter people from consistently practicing physical distancing. The paper addresses the need to understand these "psychosocial determinants" to develop targeted and effective public health messaging, particularly in the Irish context.

Methods

The research employs a three-work package (WP) approach:

  • WP1: Quantitative Investigation: This phase leverages existing data from the international iCARE study, a large online survey on COVID-19 responses. The researchers will analyze Irish data to identify sociodemographic and psychological factors associated with physical distancing adherence. They will use general linear models for analysis and comparative analyses between sociodemographic groups.
  • WP2: Qualitative Exploration: This work package will conduct semi-structured interviews with a diverse sample of Irish participants. The goal is to gain a deeper understanding of the barriers and facilitators to physical distancing, exploring nuances not captured by the quantitative survey. Thematic analysis will be used to analyze the interview data.
  • WP3: Content Analysis of Government Communications: This phase involves analyzing current government messaging on physical distancing in Ireland. The researchers will map the content of these communications against the identified determinants of adherence from WP1 and WP2 to pinpoint gaps and inform the development of optimized, tailored messages.

The study also emphasizes the integration of Public and Patient Involvement (PPI) throughout all work packages to ensure the research remains relevant and impactful.

Datasets

  • iCARE International Study Data: This is a large, ongoing international longitudinal study that includes multi-wave cross-sectional web-based surveys on public responses to COVID-19 measures. The Irish data from this study will be used for WP1.
  • Government of Ireland Department of Health (DoH) and Health Service Executive (HSE) Communications: Written printed communications (e.g., posters) will be collected and analyzed in WP3.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complexity of Physical Distancing: Adherence to physical distancing is not a simple behavior but a "suite of unique distinct behaviours" (e.g., maintaining distance, limiting contacts, avoiding gatherings) that can be influenced by a wide range of factors.
  • Dual Theoretical Framework: The study grounds its approach in two established psychological models: the COM-B (Capability, Opportunity, Motivation-Behaviour) model and the Health Belief Model. These models provide a comprehensive lens for understanding behavior change.
  • Need for Tailored Communication: The research explicitly aims to move beyond generic public health messages by identifying specific determinants of adherence and recommending how communications can be optimized and tailored to different subgroups.
  • Importance of PPI: The protocol strongly emphasizes the inclusion of public and patient involvement throughout the research process, recognizing its crucial role in ensuring the relevance and impact of public health research.

Key Results

As this paper is a protocol, it does not present findings from the research itself. However, it outlines the expected outcomes:

  • WP1: Identification of key psychosocial determinants of physical distancing for the general public and specific sociodemographic subgroups in Ireland.
  • WP2: In-depth qualitative insights into the barriers and facilitators of physical distancing adherence, providing context and depth to the quantitative findings.
  • WP3: An evidence-based mapping of current government communications, identifying gaps and providing recommendations for optimizing future messaging to enhance adherence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exploratory Nature: The study acknowledges that it is exploratory, and hypotheses are not specified a priori due to the novelty and evolving nature of the pandemic and related behaviors. This is intended to provide a descriptive basis for future hypothesis generation.
  • iCARE Study Limitations: Using data from the iCARE study means the survey was not specifically piloted for the Irish population, and there are limitations in deviating from the international protocol.
  • Qualitative Sample Size: The sample size for WP2 (10-20 participants) is noted as potentially small, though the researchers will use data adequacy evaluations to determine when to stop data collection. Generalization to the entire population in a statistical sense is not the primary goal of this qualitative component.
  • Sequential vs. Parallel Design: While WPs are presented visually as sequential, the researchers acknowledge the potential for interactive effects, though temporal constraints of data collection may render them more sequential than parallel.
  • Future Work: The ultimate goal is to feed findings directly into policy and communication strategies, ensuring the research has a tangible impact on public health efforts in Ireland. The protocol also highlights the intention to publish findings in open-access journals and disseminate them widely to ensure accessibility.

Summary updated

Abstract

<ns4:p>Optimising public health physical distancing measures has been a critical part of the global response to the spread of COVID-19. Evidence collected during the current pandemic shows that the transmission rate of the virus is significantly reduced following implementation of intensive physical distancing measures. Adherence to these recommendations has been poorer than adherence to other key transmission reduction behaviours such as handwashing. There are a complex range of reasons that are likely to predict why people do not or only partially adhere to physical distancing recommendations. In the current project we aim to address the following research questions: (1) What are the psychosocial determinants of physical distancing for the general public and for key socio-demographic sub-groups (e.g., young adults, older adults, etc.)?; (2) Do current Government of Ireland COVID-19 physical distancing communications address the determinants of physical distancing?; and (3) How can communications be optimised and tailored to sub-groups to ensure maximum adherence to guidelines? These will be addressed by conducting three work packages (WPs). In WP1, we will work closely with the iCARE international study, which includes a large online survey of public responses to measures established to reduce and slow the spread of COVID-19, including physical distancing. We will analyse Irish data, comparing it to data from other countries, to identify the key psychosocial determinants of physical distancing behaviour. This will be followed by a qualitative study to explore in depth the barriers and facilitators of physical distancing behaviour among the Irish public (WP2). In WP3, we will conduct a content analysis and evidence mapping of current government messaging around physical distancing, to ensure the findings from this research feed into the development of ongoing communication and future messaging about physical distancing.</ns4:p>
BibTeX
@inproceedings{durand2020identifying,
  author = {Hannah Durand and Simon Bacon and Molly Byrne and Eanna Kenny and Kim Lavoie and Brian E. McGuire and Jenny McSharry and Oonagh Meade and Robert Mooney and Chris Noone and Laura O’Connor and Kate O'Flaherty and Gerard J. Molloy},
  title = {{Identifying and addressing psychosocial determinants of adherence to physical distancing guidance during the COVID-19 pandemic – project protocol}},
  booktitle = {HRB},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.12688/hrbopenres.13090.2},
}
Figure