Abstract: Environment specific substitution tables have been used effectively for distinguishing structural and functional constraints on proteins and thereby identify their active sites (Chelliah et al. (2004)). This work explores whether a similar approach can be used to identify specificity determining residues (SDRs) responsible for cofactor dependence, substrate specificity or subtle catalytic variations. We combine structure-sequence information and functional annotation from various data sources to create structural alignments for homologous enzymes and functional partitions therein. We develop a scoring procedure to predict SDRs and assess their accuracy using information from bound specific ligands and published literature.
Introduction
Enzymes often belong to large "superfamilies" that share a nearly identical 3D fold but perform distinct tasks. Through evolution and gene duplication, one enzyme might evolve to process substrate A, while its homolog evolves to process substrate B. Identifying the Specificity Determining Residues (SDRs)—the handful of amino acids responsible for these functional shifts—is a significant challenge. While catalytic residues essential for basic chemistry are often well-conserved across families, SDRs are often "hidden" within the structural framework. Experimental methods like site-directed mutagenesis are resource-intensive, necessitating reliable computational approaches to pinpoint these functional sites.
Methodology
The proposed method integrates structural biology with evolutionary statistics to identify SDRs. The workflow combines data from SCOP for structural classification and the ENZYME database for functional partitioning.
Key components include:
- Environment-Specific Substitution Tables (ESSTs): These model the likelihood of amino acid replacements based on local structural contexts, such as solvent accessibility and secondary structure.
- Functional Restraint Mapping: By comparing Multiple Sequence Alignments (MSAs) against ESSTs, the authors identify "unexpected conservation"—residues conserved beyond what is required for structural stability alone.
- Differential Conservation: SDRs are identified as residues highly conserved within a functional sub-group (defined by EC numbers) but variable across the broader SCOP family.
- The SDR Score: A composite metric combining functional constraint ($ecF$), entropy differences between the family and sub-group ($famE - ecE$), and internal sub-group entropy ($ecE$).
Datasets and Evaluation
The study utilized a benchmark set of 97 examples from 68 protein families. "Ground truth" SDRs were defined as residues in close physical proximity to specific ligands in PDB crystal structures. Performance was measured using Mean Relative Proximity (MRP), comparing predicted SDRs against random residues and general family-wide conserved residues.
Key Results
The method demonstrates that accounting for the "structural cost" of mutations allows for clearer identification of functional conservation. A critical finding was the dependence on "evolutionary information" depth; accuracy improved significantly when sub-groups contained more than 10 distinct homologs.
As shown in the results table, for datasets with >10 homologs, the SDR-specific method outperformed the baseline family-wide conservation method in 85% of cases (47/55). The Mean Relative Proximity reached 0.57 in these high-information sets, indicating high precision in locating residues near specific ligands. Case studies on Aminotransferases and tRNA synthetases further validated the method, successfully identifying known specificity-determining clusters documented in literature.
Discussion and Future Work
While effective, the method currently depends on high-quality functional annotations (EC numbers) to partition sequences. Future work aims to implement "unsupervised" partitioning to group enzymes into functional clusters based solely on sequence and structural data. Additionally, the authors plan to apply this framework to classify Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) as either neutral or functionally deleterious.
Summary updated