Identification of Reference Genes for Reverse Transcription-Quantitative PCR Analysis of Ginger Under Abiotic Stress and for Postharvest Biology Studies

Gang Li, Jiawei Ma, Junliang Yin, Fengling Guo, Keyong Xi, Peihua Yang, Xiaodong Cai, Qie Jia, Lu Li, Yiqing Liu, Yongxing ZhuFrontiers in Plant Science 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies and validates three highly stable reference genes (RBP, ATPase, and 40S_S3) for RT-qPCR analysis in ginger, crucial for accurate gene expression studies under various abiotic stresses and post-harvest conditions. These findings address a critical need for reliable internal controls in ginger research, enabling more robust investigations into its complex biological processes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate gene expression analysis is fundamental to understanding plant biology, and Reverse Transcription-Quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) is a widely used technique for this purpose. A key requirement for reliable RT-qPCR is the use of stable "reference genes" (also known as housekeeping genes) that exhibit consistent expression levels across different experimental conditions, tissues, and developmental stages. These genes act as internal controls to normalize target gene expression, correcting for variations in sample preparation and PCR efficiency.

However, for ginger (Zingiber officinale), a globally important spice and medicinal crop, there has been a significant lack of validated reference genes. Previous studies have relied on genes that may not be universally stable, leading to potential inaccuracies in gene expression quantification. This deficiency hinders research into ginger's responses to environmental challenges like drought, heat, and salinity, as well as its post-harvest physiology, which is critical for improving storage and reducing spoilage. This paper aims to fill this gap by identifying and validating novel, stable reference genes specifically for ginger.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to identify and validate reference genes:

  1. RNA-Seq Data Mining: They leveraged existing RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq) data from various ginger tissues and conditions. This high-throughput data allowed them to initially screen a large number of genes for potential stability based on metrics like mean FPKM (Fragments Per Kilobase per Million reads), standard deviation (SD), maximum fold change (MFC), and coefficient of variation (CV).
  2. Candidate Gene Selection: Based on RNA-seq data, 29 candidate genes with promising stability were selected. Additionally, 13 commonly used reference genes from other plant species (orthologs) were included for comparison.
  3. Primer Design and Specificity Testing: RT-qPCR primers were designed for these selected genes. Primer specificity was rigorously tested using PCR amplification followed by agarose gel electrophoresis and melting curve analysis to ensure that only the intended gene was amplified.
  4. RT-qPCR Validation: The expression stability of the validated candidate genes was then assessed using RT-qPCR across various experimental conditions, including different abiotic stresses (NaCl, drought, heat, waterlogging, chilling) and different ginger tissues (roots, rhizomes, leaves) from multiple cultivars.
  5. Stability Analysis Algorithms: To quantitatively assess gene stability, four widely accepted algorithms were used: delta-CT, BestKeeper, geNorm, and NormFinder.
  6. Comprehensive Ranking (RefFinder): The results from the four algorithms were integrated using a tool called RefFinder to provide a final, comprehensive ranking of the reference genes based on their overall stability.
  7. Application Case Study: The identified top reference genes were then applied to normalize the expression of target genes (pathogenesis-related (PR) genes and MYB genes) involved in post-harvest deterioration and pathogen infection in ginger rhizomes. This served as a practical validation of their utility.
  8. Correlation Analysis: Pairwise correlation analyses were performed on the expression data normalized by different reference genes (single and double) to confirm the consistency and reliability of the chosen genes.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Ginger RNA-Seq Data: Previously generated RNA-seq data from various ginger tissues (red stem inner portion, green stem, young yellow rhizome, red stem surface section) with three biological replications. This data was crucial for the initial selection of candidate reference genes.
  • Ginger Samples under Abiotic Stress: Samples from multiple ginger cultivars ("Shandongdajiang," "Yunnanluopingxiaohuangjiang," and "Fengtoujiang") subjected to various abiotic stresses (NaCl, drought, heat, waterlogging, chilling) and collected from different organs (roots, rhizomes, leaves). This dataset was used for RT-qPCR validation.
  • Ginger Rhizomes during Post-Harvest Storage: Samples of ginger rhizomes collected at different time points (0, 7, 14, 21, and 28 days) during post-harvest storage under controlled conditions.
  • Fusarium solani-Inoculated Ginger Rhizomes: Ginger rhizome samples collected after inoculation with Fusarium solani and incubation for 7 days.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing RNA-seq and RT-qPCR datasets were used for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RNA-Seq is a Powerful Tool for Reference Gene Discovery: The study highlights how leveraging existing RNA-seq data can efficiently identify a broad range of candidate reference genes, moving beyond traditional, often less stable, housekeeping genes.
  • Traditional Reference Genes Aren't Always Stable: The research confirmed that commonly used reference genes like Actin and Tubulin, which are stable in some species, were not among the most stable in ginger, underscoring the species-specific nature of reference gene selection.
  • Multi-Algorithm Validation is Crucial: Relying on a single stability assessment algorithm can be misleading. The integration of four algorithms (delta-CT, BestKeeper, geNorm, NormFinder) via RefFinder provided a more robust and reliable ranking of gene stability.
  • RBP, ATPase, and 40S_S3 Emerge as Top Performers: These three genes consistently demonstrated superior stability across diverse abiotic stress conditions and in different ginger cultivars, making them ideal for normalization.
  • Double Reference Genes Offer Enhanced Reliability: The study reinforces the recommendation to use at least two reference genes for RT-qPCR, as this minimizes errors and improves the accuracy of gene expression quantification, particularly in complex biological studies.

Key Results

  • Identification of Top Reference Genes: The study identified RBP, ATPase, and 40S_S3 as the three most stable reference genes for ginger, with Dynamin also showing good stability.
  • High Correlation Between Top Genes: The expression patterns of RBP, ATPase, and 40S_S3 showed very high correlation coefficients (greater than 0.96) across different cultivars and stress treatments, indicating their consistent performance.
  • Validation in Post-Harvest Studies: The selected reference genes (RBP, ATPase, 40S_S3) were successfully used to normalize the expression of PR and MYB genes in ginger rhizomes during post-harvest storage and after pathogen infection. These genes were found to be induced by these conditions.
  • Double Reference Gene Stability: Using pairs of these top reference genes (e.g., RBP&ATPase, ATPase&40S-S3, RBP&40S-S3) for normalization also yielded highly consistent results, with correlation coefficients reaching up to 1.00.
  • Primer Efficiency: The primers designed for the top reference genes exhibited high amplification efficiency (E) and good regression coefficients (R²), essential for accurate RT-qPCR.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope of Abiotic Stresses: While several abiotic stresses were tested, the study did not cover all possible environmental conditions that ginger might encounter.
  • Specific Cultivar Focus: While multiple cultivars were used for validation, the initial RNA-seq data was from a specific cultivar ("Fengtoujiang"). Future studies could explore reference gene stability across an even wider range of ginger germplasm.
  • Further Validation in Other Applications: While the post-harvest study served as a good case, further validation of these reference genes in other specific research areas (e.g., developmental studies, different biotic stresses) would be beneficial.

The authors suggest that the identified reference genes will significantly facilitate future gene expression studies in ginger, particularly those focusing on functional genomics, abiotic stress responses, and post-harvest biology. Their work provides a robust foundation for more accurate and reliable RT-qPCR analyses in this important crop.

Summary updated

Abstract

Gene expression analysis largely improves our understanding of the molecular basis underpinning various plant biological processes. Stable reference genes play a foundational role during the normalization of gene expression levels. However, until now, there have been few reference genes suitable for ginger reverse transcription-quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) research. In this study, 29 candidate reference genes with stable expression patterns across multiple ginger tissues and 13 commonly used reference genes were selected to design RT-qPCR primers. After amplification specificity validation, 32 candidates were selected and further evaluated by RT-qPCR using samples from various organs subjected to NaCl, drought, heat, waterlogging, and chilling stress. Four strategies, including delta-CT, BestKeeper, geNorm, and NormFinder, were used to rank the stability of reference genes, and the ranks produced by these four strategies were comprehensively evaluated by RefFinder to determine the final rank. Overall, the top three stability reference genes indicated by RefFinder were <i>RBP</i> > <i>ATPase</i> > <i>40S_S3</i>. Their expression pattern correlation analysis showed that the coefficients among each pair of <i>RBP</i>, <i>ATPase</i>, and <i>40S_S3</i> were larger than 0.96, revealing consistent and stable expression patterns under various treatments. Then, the expression of three <i>pathogenesis-related</i> (<i>PR</i>) genes and seven <i>MYB</i> genes in rhizomes during postharvest storage and subjected to pathogen infection was normalized by <i>RBP</i>, <i>ATPase</i>, <i>40S_S3</i>, <i>RBP</i> and <i>ATPase</i>, <i>ATPase</i> and <i>40S-S3</i>, and <i>RBP</i> and <i>40S-S3</i>. The results showed that <i>PR</i> and <i>MYB</i> genes were induced by postharvest deterioration and pathogen infection. The correlation coefficients of <i>RBP</i>/<i>ATPase</i>, <i>RBP</i>/<i>40S_S3</i>, <i>ATPase</i>/<i>40S_S3</i>, <i>RBP</i> and <i>ATPase/ATPase</i> and <i>40S-S3</i>, <i>RBP</i> and <i>ATPase/RBP</i> and <i>40S-S3</i>, and <i>ATPase</i> and <i>40S-S3/RBP</i> and <i>40S-S3</i> were 0.99, 0.96, 0.99, 0.99, 1.00, and 1.00, respectively, which confirmed the stability of these three reference genes in postharvest biology studies of ginger. In summary, this study identified appropriate reference genes for RT-qPCR in ginger and facilitated gene expression studies under biotic and abiotic stress conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022identification,
  author = {Gang Li and Jiawei Ma and Junliang Yin and Fengling Guo and Keyong Xi and Peihua Yang and Xiaodong Cai and Qie Jia and Lu Li and Yiqing Liu and Yongxing Zhu},
  title = {{Identification of Reference Genes for Reverse Transcription-Quantitative PCR Analysis of Ginger Under Abiotic Stress and for Postharvest Biology Studies}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2022.893495},
}
Figure