Identification of models of heterogeneous cell populations from population snapshot data

Jan Hasenauer, Steffen Waldherr, Malgorzata Doszczak, Nicole Radde, Peter Scheurich, Frank AllgöwerBMC Bioinformatics 2011 · OpenReview

Abstract

Traditional systems biology models often focus on the "typical cell," yet clonal populations frequently exhibit significant heterogeneity. This paper introduces a novel Bayesian framework to infer the probability density of cellular parameters from population snapshot data, such as flow cytometry. By utilizing a pre-computation strategy and density parameterization, the method efficiently quantifies cell-to-cell variability and associated uncertainties, as demonstrated on a model of the tumor necrosis factor signaling network.

Introduction: The Challenge of Heterogeneity

In systems biology, researchers typically use ordinary differential equations (ODEs) to describe intracellular pathways. However, real cell populations—even genetically identical ones—are rarely uniform. Biochemical heterogeneity, driven by differences in protein levels or reaction rates, can lead to diverse responses across a population.

The primary challenge in modeling this variability lies in the data. Techniques like flow cytometry provide "population snapshots": they measure thousands of individual cells at specific time points but do not track the same cell over time. This lack of single-cell time series data makes it difficult to determine the underlying distribution of parameters across the population.

Illustration of population snapshot data showing measurements at discrete time points $t_j$.

Methodology: Bayesian Inference and Density Parameterization

The authors propose a Bayesian approach to infer the Probability Density Function (PDF) of model parameters. Instead of treating the parameter distribution as an unknown "black box," they model it as a weighted sum of "ansatz functions," specifically multivariate Gaussians.

To make the inference computationally tractable, the authors employ a pre-computation trick. They pre-calculate the conditional probability of observing specific data points given each ansatz function. This transforms the expensive task of simulating the ODE model during every inference step into a rapid matrix-vector multiplication.

Kernel density estimation where the total density (blue) is constructed from a superposition of individual kernels (reddish/yellowish lines).

Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling is then used to explore the posterior distribution of the weights. This provides not just a single "best fit" distribution, but a range of likely distributions, allowing for the calculation of Bayesian confidence intervals. This uncertainty quantification tells researchers exactly where the data is informative.

Evaluation and Results

The method was evaluated using artificial data generated from a model of the Tumor Necrosis Factor (TNF) signaling network, tracking species such as C3a and NF-κB. The framework successfully recovered complex, multi-modal parameter distributions even from sparse data (e.g., only four time points) and handled 15% measurement noise effectively.

Computationally, the approach is remarkably efficient. After an initial simulation of the ansatz functions (taking ~3 minutes), MCMC sampling of one million members took only 4 minutes. The results also highlighted the model's "sloppiness," where different parameter distributions could lead to the same observed output behavior, yet the resulting predictive distributions remained tight and accurate.

Conclusion

This Bayesian framework provides a powerful and efficient tool for quantifying cellular heterogeneity from standard experimental snapshots. While current limitations include the assumption of independent cells and scalability challenges in very high-dimensional parameter spaces, the ability to quantify uncertainty and handle sparse, noisy data represents a significant advancement for systems biology modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background Most of the modeling performed in the area of systems biology aims at achieving a quantitative description of the intracellular pathways within a "typical cell". However, in many biologically important situations even clonal cell populations can show a heterogeneous response. These situations require study of cell-to-cell variability and the development of models for heterogeneous cell populations. Results In this paper we consider cell populations in which the dynamics of every single cell is captured by a parameter dependent differential equation. Differences among cells are modeled by differences in parameters which are subject to a probability density. A novel Bayesian approach is presented to infer this probability density from population snapshot data, such as flow cytometric analysis, which do not provide single cell time series data. The presented approach can deal with sparse and noisy measurement data. Furthermore, it is appealing from an application point of view as in contrast to other methods the uncertainty of the resulting parameter distribution can directly be assessed. Conclusions The proposed method is evaluated using artificial experimental data from a model of the tumor necrosis factor signaling network. We demonstrate that the methods are computationally efficient and yield good estimation result even for sparse data sets.
BibTeX
@article{hasenauer2011identification,
  author = {Jan Hasenauer and Steffen Waldherr and Malgorzata Doszczak and Nicole Radde and Peter Scheurich and Frank Allgöwer},
  title = {{Identification of models of heterogeneous cell populations from population snapshot data}},
  journal = {BMC Bioinformatics},
  year = {2011},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=h-xHuFPKsW},
}
Figure