Identification of Metropolitan Area Boundaries Based on Comprehensive Spatial Linkages of Cities: A Case Study of the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei Region

Xiaoyuan Zhang, Hao Wang, Xiaogang Ning, Ruowen Liu, Huibing WangISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "bottom-up" approach to delineate metropolitan area boundaries by analyzing comprehensive urban spatial linkages. By constructing a weighted network of these linkages and applying community detection algorithms, the study provides a more objective and accurate method for defining metropolitan regions, moving beyond traditional administrative or single-perspective approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Defining metropolitan area boundaries is crucial for effective regional planning and management, especially in the face of rapid urbanization and its associated "urban diseases." Existing methods often suffer from high data acquisition costs, subjectivity in defining thresholds, and a limited focus on only one type of urban linkage (e.g., commuting or economic ties). This can lead to inaccurate delineations that don't reflect the true functional connectivity of cities. The authors aim to address this by developing a method that considers a broader spectrum of urban linkages to create more objective and comprehensive metropolitan area boundaries.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a three-step process:

  1. Construction of Urban Spatial Linkages Networks (USLNs): The authors first evaluate the "urban quality" of each district and county using a comprehensive indicator system (covering economic, population, social, and environmental capabilities). This urban quality data, along with geographic information and remote sensing data, is then used to construct a weighted, directed network of urban spatial linkages. An improved gravity model is employed to quantify these linkages, incorporating urban quality, driving time, and road distance.
  2. Delineation of Metropolitan Areas: The Infomap algorithm, a community detection method based on information entropy and random walks, is applied to the USLN. This algorithm identifies clusters of nodes (districts/counties) that are most strongly connected, effectively delineating metropolitan area boundaries.
  3. Assessment of Delineated Results: The validity of the identified boundaries is assessed through two main approaches:
  4. Isochrone Map Evaluation: Transportation accessibility is analyzed using isochrone maps (areas reachable within a certain travel time) to compare with the delineated boundaries. Overlap accuracy is calculated.
  5. Spatial Structure Validation: Centrality measures (Weighted Degree, Closeness, Betweenness, Eigenvector, and PageRank) are calculated for each urban node. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) is used to derive a comprehensive centrality score, which helps identify core cities and analyze the "central-peripheral" structure within each metropolitan area.

Datasets

The study utilizes publicly available data for the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (BTH) region:

  • Statistical Data: Socioeconomic and demographic data from 2019, including GDP, population density, and data from regional statistical yearbooks and bulletins.
  • Geographic Information Data: "Basic Geographic Country Monitoring Data" for surface cover (forest, grass, buildings, roads, waterways).
  • Remote Sensing Data: Nighttime lighting data (version 2 of the 2019 annual product) for socio-economic conditions and CHAP dataset for atmospheric environment (PM2.5 data at 1 km scale for 2019).
  • Transportation Data: Road network data, with driving time and distance between district/county government points obtained via Baidu Map API.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing publicly available data was integrated.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Bottom-Up" Approach: The study champions a "bottom-up" approach, deriving boundaries from actual urban growth and linkages rather than imposing administrative divisions. This is crucial for understanding functional regions.
  • Comprehensive Linkages Matter: The research highlights that relying on a single type of linkage (e.g., commuting) is insufficient. Integrating economic, social, transportation, and infrastructure data provides a more robust picture of inter-city connections.
  • Infomap Algorithm's Efficacy: The Infomap algorithm proves effective in identifying distinct clusters within complex networks, translating urban linkages into clear metropolitan area delineations.
  • "Central-Peripheral" Structure: The analysis reveals that most identified metropolitan areas exhibit a "central-peripheral" structure, with only the JingJinLang area showing signs of a more mature, polycentric development. This offers insights into the developmental stages of different regions.
  • Subjectivity Reduction: By using objective network analysis and community detection, the method aims to reduce the subjectivity inherent in traditional threshold-based approaches.

Key Results

  • Eight Metropolitan Areas Identified: The study delineated eight metropolitan areas within the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region: JingJinLang, Xingtai-Handan (XingHan), Baoding, Cangzhou-Hengshui (CangHeng), Shijiazhuang, Tangshan-Qinhuangdao (TangQin), Zhangjiakou, and Chengde.
  • Accuracy: The overall accuracy of the delineation results reached 83.41%, showing high consistency with isochrone maps. Specific accuracies for individual areas ranged from 66.27% to 98.62%.
  • Developmental Stages: The JingJinLang metropolitan area is identified as a mature, polycentric region. The other metropolitan areas are considered to be in the initial stages of development, with Zhangjiakou and Chengde not yet having fully formed metropolitan areas.
  • Spatial Structure: Most metropolitan areas exhibit a "central-peripheral" structure. The JingJinLang area has a dual-center structure (Beijing and Tianjin), while others tend to be monocentric.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity: The study acknowledges that while county-level data was used, future research could benefit from even finer-grained data (town or grid scale) as urbanization refines research units.
  • Validation Methods: While isochrone map superposition and centrality analysis were used for validation, the authors suggest that more quantitative methods are needed to fully capture the complexity of metropolitan area boundaries.
  • Cross-Provincial Boundaries: The current study focused on metropolitan areas within a single province. Future work should explore how to delineate cross-provincial metropolitan areas, as economic and transportation factors transcend administrative borders.
  • Dynamic vs. Static: The method primarily reflects static spatial linkages. Incorporating dynamic aspects of urban growth could further refine boundary delineation.
  • Developmental Status: The authors note that Zhangjiakou and Chengde are not yet considered "metropolitan areas" due to their limited development, suggesting a need for targeted policy interventions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2022identification,
  author = {Xiaoyuan Zhang and Hao Wang and Xiaogang Ning and Xiaoyu Zhang and Ruowen Liu and Huibing Wang},
  title = {{Identification of Metropolitan Area Boundaries Based on Comprehensive Spatial Linkages of Cities: A Case Study of the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei Region}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi11070396},
}
Figure