Identification of Key Carbon Emission Industries and Emission Reduction Control Based on Complex Network of Embodied Carbon Emission Transfers: The Case of Hei-Ji-Liao, China

Shaonan Shan, Yulong Li, Zicheng Zhang, Wei Zhu, Tingting ZhangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a novel approach combining input-output models and complex network analysis to map and identify key carbon-emitting industries within China's Hei-Ji-Liao region. By analyzing the "embodied carbon emission transfer network" (ECETN), the study pinpoints critical sectors and pathways for targeted emission reduction strategies, offering a more nuanced understanding of regional industrial carbon footprints.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Global warming is a pressing issue, and industrial production is a major contributor to carbon emissions. While direct emissions are often monitored, the "embodied" carbon emissions – those embedded in the production and consumption of goods and services throughout supply chains – are harder to track and manage. This is particularly challenging in large, diverse economies like China, where regional industrial systems are complex and interdependent. Existing policies often focus on direct emissions or broad industrial restructuring, but a more granular understanding of how carbon emissions flow between specific industries within a region is needed. This paper aims to fill that gap by identifying the most influential carbon-emitting industries and the pathways of embodied carbon transfer within the Hei-Ji-Liao provinces of China, enabling more targeted and effective emission reduction policies.

Methods

The core methodology involves constructing an Embodied Carbon Emission Transfer Network (ECETN). This is achieved by:

  1. Input-Output (I-O) Model: This standard economic tool is used to quantify the interdependencies between different industrial sectors. It helps trace how the output of one sector is used as an input by another.
  2. Embodied Carbon Calculation: Using energy balance sheets, energy statistics, and IPCC guidelines, the researchers calculate the CO2 emissions associated with the energy consumption of each sector. This data is then integrated with the I-O model to determine the embodied carbon emissions flowing between sectors.
  3. Complex Network Analysis (SNA): The ECETN is then analyzed using complex network theory. Key metrics are employed to understand the network's structure and identify critical nodes (industries) and edges (carbon flows). These metrics include:
  4. Centrality Analysis: Degree, betweenness, and closeness centrality are used to identify industries that are highly connected, act as intermediaries, or are easily accessible within the network.
  5. Influence Analysis (KATZ Index): This measures the ability of an industry's emissions to influence other industries.
  6. Clustering Analysis (K-cores, Main Core Network, Clustering Coefficients): These methods identify highly aggregated groups of industries and the most central "core" industries within the network.
  7. Diffusivity Analysis: This assesses how easily carbon emissions spread through the network, both forward and backward along the supply chain.

This multi-faceted network analysis allows for a comprehensive understanding of carbon flow dynamics, moving beyond simple direct emissions to capture the systemic nature of industrial carbon footprints.

Datasets

The study utilizes the following datasets for the Hei-Ji-Liao provinces (Heilongjiang, Jilin, and Liaoning) for the year 2017 (with energy data from 2021):

  • Input-Output (I-O) Tables (2017): Provided by the statistical bureaus of each province.
  • Energy Balance Sheets (2021): Covering eight major fossil energy sources.
  • Energy Statistics Yearbooks (2021): For the respective provinces.
  • Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories (IPCC): Used for calculating CO2 emission factors.

The paper also merges the original 42 industrial sectors from the I-O tables into 30 to ensure consistency with energy consumption classifications.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Small-World Networks: The ECETNs in all three provinces exhibit "small-world" characteristics. This means that while industries are highly clustered (high clustering coefficient), it only takes a few steps (short average path length) for information (or carbon emissions) to travel between any two industries. This implies that changes in one sector can rapidly propagate throughout the entire industrial system.
  • Interdependence is Key: The study highlights that understanding the flow of embodied carbon is crucial. A sector's direct emissions are only part of the story; its role in supplying or consuming from other sectors significantly amplifies its overall carbon impact.
  • Targeted Intervention: Identifying "key" industries based on centrality, influence, and aggregation allows for more precise policy interventions. Instead of broad, potentially inefficient regulations, policymakers can focus on these critical nodes and their associated emission pathways.
  • Regional Specificity: While there are commonalities, the specific key industries and their importance vary across the three provinces, underscoring the need for tailored regional strategies rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.

Key Results

The study identified key carbon-emitting industries in each province:

  • Liaoning: Coal mining, chemical industry, metal products, machinery manufacturing, and transportation.
  • Jilin: Coal mining, non-metal mining, non-metal products, metal processing, and the electricity industry.
  • Heilongjiang: Agriculture, metal processing, and machinery manufacturing.

The analysis also revealed critical carbon emission pathways, often starting from traditional sectors like mining and energy and ending in construction and service sectors. For instance, in Liaoning, paths like C2-C14-C11-C13-C30 and C12-C27-C19-C18-C28-C30 were identified as significant contributors. The study found that the diffusion effect (how emissions spread) was strongest in Liaoning, followed by Heilongjiang, and weakest in Jilin, suggesting Jilin might face greater challenges in emission reduction control due to unidirectional and weak diffusion effects.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Inter-provincial vs. Intra-provincial Focus: The study primarily focused on embodied carbon flows within each province, neglecting inter-regional flows. Future work should explore these inter-provincial dynamics.
  • Service Sector Aggregation: Due to data limitations, many service industry sectors were grouped together. Future research should refine this classification to analyze sub-sector emissions more precisely.
  • Geographical Specificity: The findings are specific to Northeast China and may not be generalizable to other regions due to differences in geography and resource endowments. Multi-regional comparative studies are recommended.

The paper suggests that a carbon tax policy could be a valuable tool, building on existing international and Chinese efforts to implement such policies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Similar to the problems surrounding carbon transfers that exist in international trade, there are severe carbon emission headaches in regional industrial systems within countries. It is essential for emission reduction control and regional industrial restructuring to clarify the relationship of carbon emissions flows between industrial sectors and identify key carbon-emitting industrial sectors. Supported by the input-output model (I-O model) and social network analysis (SNA), this research adopts input-output tables (2017), energy balance sheets (2021) and the energy statistics yearbooks (2021) of the three Chinese provinces of Hei-Ji-Liao to construct an Embodied carbon emission transfer network (ECETN) and determine key carbon-emitting industrial sectors with a series of complex network measurement indicators and analysis methods. The key abatement control pathways are obtained based on the flow relationships between the chains in the industrial system. The results demonstrate that the ECETNs in all three provinces of Hei-Ji-Liao are small-world in nature with scale-free characteristics (varying according to the power function). The key carbon emission industry sectors in the three provinces are identified through centrality, influence, aggregation and diffusion, comprising coal mining, the chemical industry, metal products industry, machinery manufacturing and transportation in Liaoning Province; coal mining, non-metal mining, non-metal products, metal processing and the electricity industry in Jilin Province; and agriculture, metal processing and machinery manufacturing in Heilongjiang. Additionally, key emission reduction control pathways in the three provinces are also identified based on embodied carbon emission flow relationships between industry sectors. Following the above findings, corresponding policy recommendations are proposed to tackle the responsibility of carbon reduction among industrial sectors in the province. Moreover, these findings provide some theoretical support and policy considerations for policymakers.
BibTeX
@article{shan2023identification,
  author = {Shaonan Shan and Yulong Li and Zicheng Zhang and Wei Zhu and Tingting Zhang},
  title = {{Identification of Key Carbon Emission Industries and Emission Reduction Control Based on Complex Network of Embodied Carbon Emission Transfers: The Case of Hei-Ji-Liao, China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20032603},
}
Figure