Identification of Gyromitra infula: A Rapid and Visual Method Based on Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification

Xiaomei Xie, Bu Li, Yu-Guang Fan, Renhe Duan, Chonghua Gao, Zheng Yuan, Enjing TianFrontiers in Microbiology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a rapid, low-cost, and visual DNA-based test to identify the poisonous mushroom Gyromitra infula. Using Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification (LAMP), the method identifies the fungus in under 90 minutes via a simple color change, remaining effective even after the mushrooms have been cooked or partially digested.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mushroom poisoning is a significant global food safety challenge, often resulting from the misidentification of toxic species. Gyromitra infula is particularly dangerous because it closely resembles edible "saddle mushrooms" like Helvella macropus. It contains gyromitrin, a toxin that converts into monomethylhydrazine (a component of rocket fuel) in the human body, leading to severe neurotoxicity, hemolysis, and potentially fatal kidney failure.

Current identification methods fall into two camps, both with flaws:

  1. Morphological Analysis: Requires professional mycologists and is often impossible once mushrooms are chopped, cooked, or ingested.
  2. Molecular/Chemical Methods (PCR, HPLC, LC-MS): Highly accurate but require expensive equipment, stable electricity, and hours of lab time—resources rarely available at "grassroots" clinical sites or in the field during an emergency.

Methods

The authors utilized Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification (LAMP), a technique that amplifies DNA at a constant temperature (65°C), eliminating the need for a thermal cycler.

  • Primer Design: The team targeted the Internal Transcribed Spacer (ITS) region, the universal DNA barcode for fungi. They designed two sets of primers using six specific binding sites to ensure the test wouldn't accidentally trigger for closely related species.
  • Visual Detection: Instead of using complex gel electrophoresis, they added a pH indicator (phenol red) to the reaction. As the Bst DNA polymerase builds new DNA strands, it releases protons, lowering the pH. This causes a clear color shift from pink (negative) to yellow (positive), readable by the naked eye.
  • Real-world Simulation: To test the method's "field readiness," the researchers boiled mushroom samples and treated them with artificial gastric juice (pepsin and hydrochloric acid) to simulate the state of evidence found in a patient's stomach.

Datasets

The study relied on:

  • Genomic Reference: 10 G. infula ITS sequences retrieved from NCBI GenBank for initial primer design.
  • Experimental Samples: 12 mushroom species collected from the field and deposited in the Herbarium Mycology of Jilin Agriculture University (HMJAU). These included G. infula, closely related species (G. gigas, G. esculenta), and morphologically similar edible species (Morchella esculenta, Helvella macropus).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Goldilocks" Primer Challenge: The study highlights the difficulty of designing primers for the Gyromitra genus. While "Primer Set II" was effective at amplification, it lacked specificity, triggering for other Gyromitra species. "Primer Set I" was the breakthrough, providing 100% specificity for G. infula by utilizing specific mismatch sites at the 3' and 5' ends of the primers.
  • DNA Resilience: A major "aha" moment was the discovery that fungal DNA remains stable enough for LAMP detection even after 10 minutes of boiling and 4 hours of acid digestion. This makes the test viable for forensic and clinical use where the "sample" is often a half-eaten meal or vomit.
  • Democratizing Diagnostics: By requiring only a simple thermostatic water bath, this method moves molecular diagnostics out of the high-tech lab and into resource-poor rural areas where mushroom foraging (and poisoning) is most common.

Key Results

  • Sensitivity: The limit of detection was 1 ng/µl of genomic DNA, which is roughly 10 times more sensitive than standard PCR.
  • Speed: The entire process, from sample to visual result, can be completed within 90 minutes.
  • Detection Floor: The test successfully identified G. infula even when it made up only 1% of a mixed mushroom sample.
  • Specificity: In a head-to-head test against 11 other species, only G. infula produced a positive yellow result with the optimized primer set.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Template Inhibition: The authors noted that a very high concentration of DNA template can actually inhibit the LAMP reaction, likely due to the presence of polysaccharides and polyphenols common in mushrooms. Precise sample titration is necessary.
  • Single-Target Scope: This specific test only identifies G. infula. While a great proof-of-concept, a clinical "onsite kit" would ideally need a multiplexed version to screen for several common toxic species simultaneously.
  • Binary Output: The method is qualitative (yes/no). It does not quantify the amount of toxin present, which could be relevant for determining the severity of a poisoning case.

Summary updated

Abstract

With mushroom poisoning emerging as one of the most serious food safety problems worldwide, a rapid identification method of poisonous mushrooms is urgently required to investigate the source of poisoning. <i>Gyromitra infula</i>, a kind of poisonous mushroom, contains gyromitrin toxin, which causes epileptogenic neurotoxicity and hemolytic disease. This study aimed to establish a rapid and visual method of <i>G. infula</i> identification based on loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP). A set of specific LAMP primers was designed, and its specificity in <i>G. infula</i> was confirmed against various mushroom species, including its closely related species and other macrofungi. The sensitivity assay showed that the minimum concentration of genomic DNA detected by LAMP was 1 ng/μl. The method's applicability was conducted by preparing mushroom samples that were boiled and digested in artificial gastric juice. The results showed that the content as low as 1% <i>G. infula</i> can be successfully detected. This method can be completed within 90 min, and the reaction results can be directly observed by the naked eyes. Hence, the identification method of <i>G. infula</i> established based on LAMP in this study is accurate, rapid, sensitive, and low-cost, which is required for clinical treatment or forensic analysis when mushroom poisoning occurs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xie2022identification,
  author = {Xiaomei Xie and Bu Li and Yu-Guang Fan and Renhe Duan and Chonghua Gao and Zheng Yuan and Enjing Tian},
  title = {{Identification of Gyromitra infula: A Rapid and Visual Method Based on Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2022.842178},
}
Figure