Identification of distinct genotypes in circulating RSV A strains based on variants in the virus replication-associated genes

Abdulafiz Musa, Sydney R. Faber, Kaitlyn Forrest, Kenny Smith, Shaon Sengupta, Carolina B. LópezJournal of Virology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel method for genotyping Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) strains by analyzing variations in replication-associated genes, particularly the polymerase L gene. This approach offers a more robust and informative way to track RSV strains compared to traditional methods, potentially leading to better understanding of genotype-phenotype correlations and improved clinical outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) is a major cause of respiratory illness, especially in young children and older adults. While RSV is classified into strains A and B, and further into subgroups or genotypes, there's a lack of a standardized and unified method for identifying these genotypes. Current methods often rely on variations in the G gene, which may not fully capture the virus's evolutionary dynamics or its replication capabilities. This makes it challenging to track circulating strains, understand their pathogenicity, and correlate specific genotypes with disease severity. The authors aim to address this by exploring whether variations in genes critical for viral replication can serve as a more reliable basis for genotyping RSV.

Methods

The researchers employed a de novo assembly approach to reconstruct full-length RSV A genomes from clinical samples. This method is advantageous as it doesn't rely on pre-existing reference sequences, thus avoiding potential biases. They then performed in-depth variant analysis on the replication-associated genes (N, P, M2, and L) of these assembled genomes. This involved identifying and annotating non-synonymous variations (changes in amino acids) and comparing them against a consensus sequence.

To identify patterns and associations, they used Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to visualize clusters of sequences based on their variant profiles. They also utilized the Nextclade web tool for clade assignment and compared their findings with established genotyping methods like Nextstrain and Goya clades. A key aspect of their methodology was the focus on co-variation – looking for patterns where variations in one replication-associated gene consistently occurred with variations in others, suggesting functional interactions. They also applied similar analyses to human metapneumovirus (HMPV) to assess the broader applicability of their findings.

Datasets

The study utilized two main sources of RSV A sequences:

  1. Newly sequenced samples: 31 full-length RSV A genomes were generated from de novo assembled sequences of samples obtained from hospitalized pediatric patients at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP).
  2. Publicly available sequences: 78 additional RSV A sequences were obtained from the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) and the Bacterial and Viral Bioinformatics Resource Center (BV-BRC). These sequences represented various geographic locations within the United States and spanned a range of years (2012-2023).

The study also analyzed 21 HMPV A full-length sequences from the US for comparative purposes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Polymerase L Gene as a Genotyping Target: The study strongly suggests that the polymerase L gene is a highly informative and robust target for genotyping RSV A strains, offering a more reliable alternative to the G gene.
  • Co-variation in Replication Machinery: A significant finding is the consistent association of non-synonymous variations in the L gene with conserved changes in its co-factors, P and M2-2. This points to coordinated evolution within the viral replication complex, likely driven by functional interactions between these proteins.
  • Domain-Specific Variations: The variations observed in the replication-associated genes tend to concentrate within specific protein domains, particularly those involved in protein-protein interactions and enzymatic activity (e.g., RdRp, CD, MT domains of L). This suggests that these variations are not random but are selected for their impact on viral function.
  • Broader Applicability to Pneumoviruses: The observed co-variation patterns were also present in human metapneumovirus (HMPV), indicating that this approach might be applicable to other pneumoviruses.
  • De Novo Assembly Advantage: The use of de novo assembly proved crucial in capturing a comprehensive picture of genomic variations, including those that might be missed by reference-guided approaches.

Key Results

  • The G and L genes exhibited the highest number of total and non-synonymous variations among the analyzed RSV A strains.
  • The M2-2 coding region showed the highest ratio of non-synonymous to total variation, indicating significant amino acid changes.
  • The researchers were able to define distinct genotypic clusters (R1-R6) based on specific patterns of non-synonymous variations in the replication-associated genes.
  • These predicted genotypic groups showed strong clustering in PCA plots, aligning well with genotypes assigned by established methods like Nextstrain clades.
  • The study identified specific amino acid substitutions in L (e.g., G1725E, V3351) that were consistently associated with variations in P (e.g., P34L) and M2-2 (e.g., N46S), forming the basis for their genotyping strategy.
  • The analysis of HMPV A sequences also revealed predictable genotype groups based on similar co-variation patterns.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Causality of Variations: While the study identifies associations and suggests functional interactions, it acknowledges that it cannot directly answer the question of the selection order of these coordinated variations due to the lack of evolutionary information in the dataset.
  • Functional Validation: The paper highlights the need for further in vitro and clinical studies to definitively determine how these specific variations impact viral fitness, polymerase efficiency, and pathogenicity.
  • HMPV Genotyping Validation: For HMPV, additional analyses are required to compare the proposed genotyping groups with existing HMPV genotyping methods.
  • Cost and Accessibility of Whole-Genome Sequencing: The authors mention that while whole-genome sequencing is invaluable, improvements are still needed to reduce its cost, increase efficiency, and enhance accessibility for widespread use.

The authors suggest that their findings provide a foundation for future investigations into the molecular interactions within the replication complex and can be incorporated into artificial intelligence tools for detecting complementary mutations, ultimately aiding in the fight against RSV.

Summary updated

Abstract

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is a common cause of respiratory infection that often leads to hospitalization of infected younger children and older adults. RSV is classified into two strains, A and B, each with several subgroups or genotypes. One issue with the definition of these subgroups is the lack of a unified method of identification or genotyping. We propose that genotyping strategies based on the genes coding for replication-associated proteins could provide critical information on the replication capacity of the distinct subgroups, while clearly distinguishing genotypes. Here, we analyzed the virus replication-associated genes N, P, M2, and L from <i>de novo</i> assembled RSV A sequences obtained from 31 newly sequenced samples from hospitalized patients in Philadelphia and 78 additional publicly available sequences from different geographic locations within the United States. In-depth analysis and annotation of variants in the replication-associated proteins identified the polymerase protein L as a robust target for genotyping RSV subgroups. Importantly, our analysis revealed non-synonymous variations in L that were consistently accompanied by conserved changes in its co-factor P or the M2-2 protein, suggesting associations and interactions between specific domains of these proteins. Similar associations were seen among sequences of the related human metapneumovirus. These results highlight L as an alternative to other RSV genotyping targets and demonstrate the value of in-depth analyses and annotations of RSV sequences as it can serve as a foundation for subsequent <i>in vitro</i> and clinical studies on the efficiency of the polymerase and fitness of different virus isolates.IMPORTANCEGiven the historical heterogeneity of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) and the disease it causes, there is a need to understand the properties of the circulating RSV strains each season. This information would benefit from an informative and consensus method of genotyping the virus. Here, we carried out a variant analysis that shows a pattern of specific variations among the replication-associated genes of RSV A across different seasons. Interestingly, these variation patterns, which were also seen in human metapneumovirus sequences, point to previously defined interactions of domains within these genes, suggesting co-variation in the replication-associated genes. Our results also suggest a genotyping strategy that can prove to be particularly important in understanding the genotype-phenotype correlation in the era of RSV vaccination, where selective pressure on the virus to evolve is anticipated. More importantly, the categorization of pneumoviruses based on these patterns may be of prognostic value.
BibTeX
@article{musa2024identification,
  author = {Abdulafiz Musa and Sydney R. Faber and Kaitlyn Forrest and Kenny Smith and Shaon Sengupta and Carolina B. López},
  title = {{Identification of distinct genotypes in circulating RSV A strains based on variants in the virus replication-associated genes}},
  journal = {Journal of Virology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1128/jvi.00990-24},
}
Figure