Identification of Damage on Sluice Hoist Beams Using Local Mode Evoked by Swept Frequency Excitation

Qingyang Wei, Hao Xu, Yifei Li, Li Chen, Drahomír Novák, Li Cui, Maosen CaoSensors 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for detecting damage in large, complex structures like sluice hoist beams by focusing on "local modes" and their associated "local primary frequencies" (LPFs). By using swept frequency excitation (SFE) and identifying a specific resonance band (LRRB), the method can pinpoint damage with higher sensitivity than traditional global vibration analysis, even in noisy conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining the structural integrity of critical infrastructure like sluice gates is paramount for water management and flood control. Sluice hoist beams, which operate these gates, are susceptible to damage from environmental factors and heavy loads. Traditional damage detection methods, such as visual inspection, are subjective and time-consuming. While vibration-based methods offer objectivity, relying on global natural frequencies can be problematic for large, complex systems. Damage in one part of a large structure might cause only subtle shifts in its overall natural frequencies, making it difficult to detect and localize. This paper addresses this challenge by proposing a method that focuses on local vibration characteristics of specific components (substructures) within the larger system, aiming for higher sensitivity to localized damage.

Methods

The core of this paper's contribution lies in its novel approach to damage detection:

  • Local Primary Frequency (LPF): Instead of global natural frequencies, the method focuses on the LPF, which is the natural frequency associated with a "local mode." A local mode occurs when a specific substructure (like a hoist beam) vibrates significantly while other parts of the system remain relatively still. This concentration of vibration energy makes the LPF highly sensitive to damage within that substructure.
  • Swept Frequency Excitation (SFE): To effectively excite these local modes, the authors employ SFE. This technique involves applying a sinusoidal excitation signal whose frequency is continuously varied over a specific range. SFE is advantageous over traditional methods like hammer impact because it provides more controlled and distributed excitation energy across a frequency band, making it easier to capture the desired resonance responses and suppress interference from other parts of the structure.
  • Local Resonance Response Band (LRRB) Selection: After SFE, the time-domain responses are analyzed. The LRRB is identified as the time segment where the response amplitude is above half of its maximum. This band is crucial because it captures the dominant local mode response.
  • Frequency Domain Analysis (FFT): The LRRB segment is then transformed into the frequency domain using Fast Fourier Transform (FFT). This allows for the precise identification of the LPF.
  • Damage Index (DI): A damage index is formulated based on the relative shift of the LPF between an undamaged (healthy) and a damaged state. This index quantifies the severity of the damage.

Datasets

The study utilizes a three-dimensional finite element (FE) model of a five-hole sluice system for its simulations and evaluations. This model was constructed using solid and tetrahedral elements and included components like the foundation, baseplate, gate piers, and hoist beams. Various damage scenarios were simulated by reducing the elastic modulus of specific elements within the hoist beams to mimic different degrees of stiffness reduction. No real-world experimental data was used for validation in this paper; all results are based on FE simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Local Modes are Key: The fundamental insight is that focusing on the localized vibration behavior of individual components (substructures) within a complex system offers a more sensitive indicator of damage than global vibration characteristics.
  • LPF Sensitivity: The LPF is significantly more sensitive to localized damage in a substructure than global natural frequencies. This means even minor damage can cause a noticeable shift in the LPF.
  • SFE for Targeted Excitation: Swept frequency excitation is an effective tool for selectively exciting local modes, suppressing the vibrations of other structural components, and thus isolating the response of the component of interest.
  • LRRB for Robustness: Identifying the LRRB in the time domain helps to isolate the relevant response segment for accurate LPF extraction, even in the presence of noise.
  • Noise Immunity: The proposed method demonstrates improved noise resistance compared to hammer impact methods, making it more practical for real-world applications where environmental noise is a factor.

Key Results

  • The proposed method successfully identified damage in simulated sluice hoist beams with a damage index (DI) that increased linearly with stiffness reduction.
  • The identification results showed satisfactory accuracy, with averaged and maximum errors between identified and true damage severities of 1.59% and 4.17%, respectively.
  • The method proved effective even for relatively small damage cases (around 10% stiffness reduction).
  • The SFE method exhibited superior noise robustness compared to hammer excitation, with the ability to identify LPFs even at noise intensity levels up to $\sigma = 0.20$.
  • Sensor placement at the middle span of the hoist beams yielded the highest amplitude responses, which were deemed most suitable for damage identification.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation-Based: The study relies entirely on finite element simulations. While the FE model is detailed, real-world validation with experimental data from actual sluice structures is needed to confirm the method's efficacy in practice.
  • Damage Index Simplicity: The damage index is based on a simple relative shift of the LPF. The authors suggest that combining this with other damage indicators could provide a more comprehensive assessment.
  • Arbitrary Damage Identification: While the method can identify damage degree, the arbitrary damage degree was identified using reference data. Further work could explore more sophisticated algorithms for direct damage quantification without relying on pre-constructed reference datasets.
  • Other Substructures: The study focused on hoist beams. Extending the application to other substructures within the sluice system and investigating their interdependencies would be a valuable next step.
  • Excitation and Sensor Optimization: While sensor position and excitation form were discussed, further optimization studies could refine these parameters for maximum effectiveness across various damage scenarios and structural configurations.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a global vibration characteristic, natural frequency often suffers from insufficient sensitivity to structural damage, which is associated with local variations of structural material or geometric properties. Such a drawback is particularly significant when dealing with the large scale and complexity of sluice structural systems. To this end, a damage detection method in sluice hoist beams is proposed that relies on the utilization of the local primary frequency (LPF), which is obtained based on the swept frequency excitation (SFE) technique and local resonance response band (LRRB) selection. Using this method, the local mode of the target sluice hoist beam can be effectively excited, while the vibrations of other components in the system are suppressed. As a result, the damage will cause a significant shift in the LPF of the sluice hoist beam at the local mode. A damage index was constructed to quantitatively reflect the damage degree of the sluice hoist beam. The accuracy and reliability of the proposed method were verified on a three-dimensional finite element model of a sluice system, with the noise resistance increased from 0.05 to 0.2 based on the hammer impact method. The proposed method exhibits promising potential for damage detection in complex structural systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wei2021identification,
  author = {Qingyang Wei and Hao Xu and Yifei Li and Li Chen and Drahomír Novák and Li Cui and Maosen Cao},
  title = {{Identification of Damage on Sluice Hoist Beams Using Local Mode Evoked by Swept Frequency Excitation}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21196357},
}
Figure