Identification of cis-regulatory modules for adeno-associated virus-based cell-type-specific targeting in the retina and brain

Cheng‐Hui Lin, Yue Sun, Candace S. Y. Chan, Man-Ru Wu, Lei Gu, Alexander E. Davis, Baokun Gu, Wenlin Zhang, Bogdan Tanasă, Lei Zhong, Mark M. Emerson, Lu Chen, Jun Ding, Sui WangJournal of Biological Chemistry 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces two novel strategies to efficiently identify and create cell-type-specific targeting tools using adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) for the central nervous system (CNS). By leveraging existing genomic data, they developed methods to improve the accuracy of AAV-based gene delivery, enabling more precise research into neural circuits and diseases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Studying the intricate workings of the central nervous system (CNS) requires precise tools to target specific cell types. Adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) are excellent candidates for this, but their effectiveness hinges on incorporating cell-type-specific regulatory elements, known as cis-regulatory modules (CRMs). While chromatin accessibility data (like ATAC-seq) has been a common starting point for identifying potential CRMs, it's not always accurate. Many "open" chromatin regions don't actually drive gene expression in vivo, leading to inefficient and unreliable AAV tools. This paper tackles the challenge of improving the efficiency and accuracy of identifying active CRMs for cell-type-specific AAV targeting, especially for less abundant cell types.

Methods

The researchers developed and tested two primary strategies:

  1. Prescreening based on Transcription Factor Binding Site (TFBS) density: They hypothesized that active CRMs would likely be enriched for binding sites of transcription factors specific to a particular cell type. They used existing datasets of transcription factor binding motifs (from JASPAR) and chromatin accessibility data (from ENCODE and other sources) to scan putative CRMs. By calculating the density of cell-type-specific TFBSs within these regions, they found that a higher density correlated with actual CRM activity. This acts as a powerful filter to prioritize promising CRMs.
  2. Synthetic CRM "stitching": For cell types where specific TFBS data might be scarce, they employed a "stitching" approach. This involves identifying chromatin-accessible regions (using DNase-seq data) that flank genes known to be specifically expressed in the target cell type. These regions are then pieced together to create a synthetic CRM. This strategy leverages the idea that regulatory elements surrounding a gene are likely to control its expression.

They also developed a modified Cre recombinase (gCre) by fusing it with human geminin protein. This gCre is designed to be less prone to non-specific activation, improving the precision of genetic manipulation when used in conjunction with their AAV tools.

Datasets

The study heavily relies on publicly available large-scale genomic datasets:

  • ENCODE Project: Provided DNase-seq data for whole brain and other tissues, crucial for identifying chromatin-accessible regions.
  • Single-cell RNA-sequencing (scRNA-seq) data: Used to identify cell-type-enriched genes and transcription factors in the retina (e.g., from Macosko et al., 2015) and brain.
  • ATAC-seq data: Specifically, ATAC-seq data on purified mouse Müller glial cells (MG) was used to identify putative CRMs.
  • JASPAR database: Provided transcription factor binding motifs (TFBS matrices) for scanning putative CRMs.

The researchers did not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather demonstrated the utility of their strategies on existing data and experimental models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TFBS density is a strong predictor of CRM activity: The simple act of counting cell-type-specific TFBSs within a chromatin-accessible region significantly boosts the chances of finding an active CRM, moving beyond just identifying "open" regions.
  • "Stitching" accessible regions is a practical way to build CRMs: When specific TFBS data is limited, combining accessible regions around known cell-type-specific genes can effectively create functional CRMs. This is a powerful approach for less-studied cell types.
  • MG CRMs are applicable to brain astrocytes: The MG1s CRM, identified in retinal Müller glial cells, also showed high specificity for astrocytes in the adult brain, suggesting conserved regulatory mechanisms or shared cell identities.
  • AAV tools can be made more precise: The development of gCre addresses a key limitation in using Cre-lox systems for cell-type-specific genetic manipulation, reducing off-target recombination.

Key Results

The study successfully generated AAVs that specifically target:

  • Retinal Müller glial cells (MGs): Using the MG1s CRM, they achieved ~99% specificity and ~60% efficiency in driving GFP expression. This CRM also showed robustness against NMDA-induced retinal injury.
  • Retinal amacrine cells (ACs): Synthetic CRMs derived from stitching accessible regions flanking AC-enriched genes (Ndrg4, Chat, Gad1) successfully targeted Gad1+ GABAergic ACs.
  • Brain astrocytes: The MG1s CRM demonstrated high specificity (>90%) for astrocytes in the mouse striatum and motor cortex.
  • Brain Parvalbumin (PV)-positive neurons: Synthetic CRMs stitched from DNase-seq data near the Pvalb gene showed varying degrees of specificity (up to ~79% in motor cortex) for PV+ neurons in different brain regions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Stitching" may not perfectly recapitulate endogenous expression: While effective, the synthetic CRMs might not fully capture the nuanced regulatory landscape of endogenous promoters, potentially including or excluding certain regulatory elements.
  • Potential for silencer elements: The stitching strategy might inadvertently include chromatin-accessible regions that act as silencers, leading to incomplete labeling or unexpected expression patterns.
  • Weighting TFBSs: The current TFBS density calculation treats all TFBSs equally. Future work could explore differential weighting based on TF affinity and activity for even better prediction.
  • Broader application: The authors suggest applying these strategies to other retinal and brain cell types, especially those with limited existing tools. Further investigation into the role of specific CRMs in gene regulation and disease is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) targeting specific cell types are powerful tools for studying distinct cell types in the central nervous system (CNS). Cis-regulatory modules (CRMs), e.g., enhancers, are highly cell-type-specific and can be integrated into AAVs to render cell type specificity. Chromatin accessibility has been commonly used to nominate CRMs, which have then been incorporated into AAVs and tested for cell type specificity in the CNS. However, chromatin accessibility data alone cannot accurately annotate active CRMs, as many chromatin-accessible CRMs are not active and fail to drive gene expression in vivo. Using available large-scale datasets on chromatin accessibility, such as those published by the ENCODE project, here we explored strategies to increase efficiency in identifying active CRMs for AAV-based cell-type-specific labeling and manipulation. We found that prescreening of chromatin-accessible putative CRMs based on the density of cell-type-specific transcription factor binding sites (TFBSs) can significantly increase efficiency in identifying active CRMs. In addition, generation of synthetic CRMs by stitching chromatin-accessible regions flanking cell-type-specific genes can render cell type specificity in many cases. Using these straightforward strategies, we generated AAVs that can target the extensively studied interneuron and glial cell types in the retina and brain. Both strategies utilize available genomic datasets and can be employed to generate AAVs targeting specific cell types in CNS without conducting comprehensive screening and sequencing experiments, making a step forward in cell-type-specific research.
BibTeX
@article{lin2022identification,
  author = {Cheng‐Hui Lin and Yue Sun and Candace S. Y. Chan and Man-Ru Wu and Lei Gu and Alexander E. Davis and Baokun Gu and Wenlin Zhang and Bogdan Tanasă and Lei Zhong and Mark M. Emerson and Lu Chen and Jun Ding and Sui Wang},
  title = {{Identification of cis-regulatory modules for adeno-associated virus-based cell-type-specific targeting in the retina and brain}},
  journal = {Journal of Biological Chemistry},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jbc.2022.101674},
}
Figure