Identification of Chilling Accumulation-Associated Genes for Litchi Flowering by Transcriptome-Based Genome-Wide Association Studies

Xingyu Lu, Peitao Lü, Hao Liu, Houbin Chen, Xifen Pan, Pengxu Liu, Lei Feng, Silin Zhong, Biyan ZhouFrontiers in Plant Science 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages transcriptome-based Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS) to identify genes crucial for litchi flowering, which is triggered by winter chilling. By analyzing RNA sequencing data from 87 litchi accessions and conducting controlled chilling experiments, researchers pinpointed candidate genes involved in flowering, hormone synthesis, and signal transduction, offering a foundation for manipulating flowering time in this important fruit crop.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Litchi (Sapindaceae) flowering is a complex process heavily influenced by winter chilling temperatures. Different litchi varieties exhibit distinct flowering times, requiring varying levels of chilling accumulation for floral induction. This variability poses challenges for consistent fruit production, especially in the face of climate change leading to warmer winters. Understanding the genetic basis of this chilling requirement is crucial for developing strategies to regulate flowering time, ensuring stable yields and potentially adapting to changing environmental conditions. While some flowering genes are known in model plants, their specific roles and interactions in litchi, particularly concerning chilling response, remain largely uncharacterized.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Transcriptome-based GWAS: This is the core methodology. Instead of relying solely on genomic DNA, they used RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) data from 87 litchi accessions to identify single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). This transcriptome-based approach allows for the direct association of gene expression variations with phenotypic traits.
  • Phenotypic Data Collection: Detailed records of flowering time (panicle primordium emergence), days to floral induction, and chilling accumulation (degree hours below 20°C) were collected for each accession.
  • SNP Calling and Genotyping: Standard bioinformatics pipelines (GATK, ANNOVAR) were used to identify high-quality SNPs from the RNA-Seq data. Population structure and kinship matrices were also generated.
  • Association Analysis: The TASSEL software was utilized to perform GWAS, specifically focusing on the relationship between chilling accumulation (Symbol C) and SNP data. This identified "associated genes" (AGs).
  • Gene Expression Analysis: RNA-Seq data was also used to analyze gene expression patterns. They compared expression levels of AGs between early- and late-flowering accessions, and between flowering and non-flowering trees under controlled temperature conditions.
  • Controlled Temperature Experiments: Litchi trees were subjected to different temperature regimes (low vs. high) to induce or inhibit flowering. RNA-Seq was performed on leaf samples from these trees to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs).
  • Candidate Gene Screening: By integrating GWAS results with DEG analysis, they narrowed down the AGs to "candidate associated genes" (CAGs) that were both associated with chilling and differentially expressed under temperature treatments.
  • Quantitative Real-Time PCR (qRT-PCR): This technique was used to validate the expression patterns of selected CAGs, confirming the RNA-Seq findings.
  • Gradient Chilling Treatment: 'Guiwei' litchi trees were exposed to varying durations of chilling to assess the impact on flowering rates and CAG expression.

Datasets

  • Litchi Accession RNA-Seq Data: RNA-Seq data was generated from 87 litchi accessions. This data is publicly available in the Sequence Read Archive (SRA) of NCBI under accession numbers PRJNA766599 and PRJNA766549.
  • Litchi Genome Data: Cleaned RNA-Seq reads were mapped to the litchi genome for gene expression quantification.
  • Controlled Temperature Experiment Data: RNA-Seq data was also generated from leaf samples of 'Nuomici' litchi trees subjected to controlled low and high temperature treatments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Transcriptome-based GWAS is effective for non-model plants: This study demonstrates the power of using RNA-Seq data for GWAS in litchi, a species with a complex genome and limited genomic resources compared to model plants. This approach bypasses the need for extensive genomic DNA sequencing and can directly link gene expression to traits.
  • Chilling accumulation is a key driver, but its genetic basis is complex: The study confirms that chilling is essential for litchi flowering but reveals a sophisticated genetic network underlying this response, involving flowering regulators and hormone signaling pathways.
  • Hormonal regulation plays a significant role: A substantial number of identified candidate genes are involved in plant hormone synthesis and signal transduction (e.g., IAA, ABA, ETH, JA, BR). This highlights the intricate interplay between environmental cues and hormonal signaling in floral induction.
  • Early vs. Late flowering accessions have distinct gene expression profiles: The study found significant differences in the expression of candidate genes between early-flowering and late-flowering litchi varieties, suggesting distinct genetic mechanisms driving their flowering times.
  • Candidate genes show differential expression under chilling: The controlled temperature experiments revealed that the expression of many candidate genes is directly influenced by chilling, with distinct patterns observed in flowering vs. non-flowering trees.

Key Results

  • Identification of Associated Genes (AGs): 1,411 significantly associated SNPs and 1,115 AGs were identified through transcriptome-based GWAS.
  • Categorization of AGs: Among these, 31 were identified as flowering-related, 23 as hormone synthesis-related, and 27 as hormone signal transduction-related.
  • Identification of Candidate Associated Genes (CAGs): After further screening, 15 flowering-related, 13 hormone synthesis-related, and 11 hormone signal transduction-related CAGs were identified.
  • Differential Expression: Expression levels of these CAGs differed significantly between early- and late-flowering accessions, and between flowering and non-flowering trees.
  • Chilling Treatment Effects: In a gradient chilling experiment, flowering rates and CAG expression were demonstrably affected by the duration of chilling.
  • Validation: qRT-PCR confirmed the accuracy of the RNA-Seq expression data for selected genes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Population Size for GWAS: While 87 accessions is a reasonable number for litchi, larger populations could potentially uncover more genetic associations.
  • Focus on Leaves: The study primarily focused on leaf tissue for RNA-Seq and gene expression analysis. While leaves are known to produce flowering signals, investigating other tissues (e.g., buds) could provide a more complete picture.
  • Functional Validation: The study identified candidate genes, but further functional validation (e.g., through gene editing or overexpression studies) is needed to definitively confirm their roles in litchi flowering.
  • Understanding Dormancy: The paper notes that litchi bud dormancy mechanisms are not fully understood and differ from deciduous trees, suggesting this as an area for future research.
  • Integration with other pathways: While hormone signaling is highlighted, further research could explore the integration of chilling response with other known flowering pathways in litchi.

The authors propose that the identified candidate genes could be valuable for genetic regulation of flowering in litchi, potentially aiding in crop improvement and adaptation to climate change.

Summary updated

Abstract

Litchi is an important Sapindaceae fruit tree. Flowering in litchi is triggered by low temperatures in autumn and winter. It can be divided into early-, medium-, and late-flowering phenotypes according to the time for floral induction. Early-flowering varieties need low chilling accumulation level for floral induction, whereas the late-flowering varieties require high chilling accumulation level. In the present study, RNA-Seq of 87 accessions was performed and transcriptome-based genome-wide association studies (GWAS) was used to identify candidate genes involved in chilling accumulation underlying the time for floral induction. A total of 98,155 high-quality single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) sites were obtained. A total of 1,411 significantly associated SNPs and 1,115 associated genes (AGs) were identified, of which 31 were flowering-related, 23 were hormone synthesis-related, and 27 were hormone signal transduction-related. Association analysis between the gene expression of the AGs and the flowering phenotypic data was carried out, and differentially expressed genes (DEGs) in a temperature-controlled experiment were obtained. As a result, 15 flowering-related candidate AGs (CAGs), 13 hormone synthesis-related CAGs, and 11 hormone signal transduction-related CAGs were further screened. The expression levels of the CAGs in the early-flowering accessions were different from those in the late-flowering ones, and also between the flowering trees and non-flowering trees. In a gradient chilling treatment, flowering rates of the trees and the CAGs expression were affected by the treatment. Our present work for the first time provided candidate genes for genetic regulation of flowering in litchi using transcriptome-based GWAS.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2022identification,
  author = {Xingyu Lu and Peitao Lü and Hao Liu and Houbin Chen and Xifen Pan and Pengxu Liu and Lei Feng and Silin Zhong and Biyan Zhou},
  title = {{Identification of Chilling Accumulation-Associated Genes for Litchi Flowering by Transcriptome-Based Genome-Wide Association Studies}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2022.819188},
}
Figure