Identification of antimalarial targets of chloroquine by a combined deconvolution strategy of ABPP and MS-CETSA

Peng Gao, Yanqing Liu, Wei Xiao, Fei Xia, Jiayun Chen, Liwei Gu, Fan Yang, Liuhai Zheng, Junzhe Zhang, Qian Zhang, Zhijie Li, Yuqing Meng, Yongping Zhu, Chengchao Xu, Lingyun Dai, Jigang WangResearch Square 2021 · DOI

Introduction

Malaria remains a devastating global health crisis, threatening hundreds of millions of people. For decades, chloroquine (CQ) has been a cornerstone of antimalarial treatment. However, despite its long history, our understanding of its mechanism of action (MoA) remains incomplete. The traditional "textbook" explanation focuses on CQ's ability to prevent the parasite from detoxifying heme. Yet, this model fails to fully explain the drug's efficacy or the nuances of resistance. This study sought to map the complete "interactome" of chloroquine within Plasmodium falciparum to uncover additional protein targets.

Experimental Strategy: A Dual-Deconvolution Approach

To identify CQ's targets in an unbiased manner, researchers employed a powerful "double-check" strategy combining labeled and label-free proteomics.

Overview of the combined ABPP and MS-CETSA strategy for identifying chloroquine targets.

The team first synthesized a novel photo-affinity chloroquine analog probe (CQP). This probe retains nanomolar antimalarial activity and features a photo-reactive group for covalent bonding and an alkyne handle for "click chemistry" enrichment. This Activity-Based Protein Profiling (ABPP) approach identified 40 proteins that specifically cross-linked with the probe.

Parallel to this, the researchers used Mass Spectrometry-coupled Cellular Thermal Shift Assay (MS-CETSA). This label-free method identifies drug-binding targets based on changes in protein thermal stability upon ligand binding. Out of 3,375 measured parasite proteins, 83 showed significant thermal shifts in the presence of CQ. By focusing on the 8 high-confidence proteins identified by both methods, the researchers significantly reduced the "noise" typical of large-scale proteomics.

Results: Uncovering Metabolic Interference

The study focused on the Plasmodium falciparum 3D7 strain. Validation of the top hits revealed a surprising new dimension to CQ's activity: it acts as a metabolic disruptor.

Key findings include:

  • Target Validation: Five enzymes were confirmed as direct targets: PfLDH (lactate dehydrogenase), PfOAT (ornithine aminotransferase), PfPyrK (pyruvate kinase), PfPGK (phosphoglycerate kinase), and PfTPI (triosephosphate isomerase).
  • Binding Affinity: Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) analysis demonstrated that CQ binds to these enzymes with dissociation constants ($K_D$) in the low micromolar range (0.32 μM to 1.95 μM), consistent with therapeutic concentrations.
  • Functional Inhibition: In vitro assays confirmed that CQ inhibits the catalytic activity of these enzymes in a dose-dependent manner.
  • Cellular Localization: Fluorescence imaging indicated that the CQ probe accumulates not only in the digestive vacuole (the site of heme processing) but also near the mitochondria, supporting the hypothesis of interference with energy metabolism.

Discussion and Future Directions

The most significant insight from this work is that chloroquine is a multi-target drug. By hitting several enzymes within the glycolysis pathway—the parasite's "engine room"—CQ effectively starves the parasite of energy. This "poly-pharmacology" likely contributes to the drug's historical effectiveness, as it is harder for a parasite to bypass multiple blocked metabolic steps simultaneously.

While these results provide a compelling new mechanism, the study primarily utilized the chloroquine-sensitive 3D7 strain. Future research should investigate these interactions in resistant strains to determine if metabolic bypasses or altered binding sites contribute to drug resistance. This discovery opens new avenues for designing multi-target antimalarials that could overcome current resistance challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background Malaria is a devastating infectious disease that disproportionally threatens hundreds of millions of people in developing countries. In the history of anti-malaria campaign, chloroquine (CQ) has played an indispensable role, however, its mechanism of action (MoA) is not fully understood. Methods We used the approach of photo-affinity labeling (PAL) in the design of a chloroquine probe and developed a combined deconvolution strategy – activity-based protein profiling (ABPP) and mass spectrometry-coupled cellular thermal shift assay (MS-CESTA) – that identified the protein targets of chloroquine in an unbiased manner in this study. Results We developed a novel photo-affinity chloroquine analog probe (CQP), which retains the antimalarial activity in the nanomole range, and identified a total of 40 proteins that specifically interacted and photo-crosslinked with CQP, which was inhibited in the presence of excess CQ. Using MS-CETSA, we identified 83 candidate interacting proteins out of a total of 3375 measured parasite proteins. Together, we identified 8 proteins as the most potential hits which were commonly identified by both methods. Conclusions We found that CQ could disrupt glycolysis and energy metabolism of malarial parasites through direct binding with some of the key enzymes, a new mechanism that is different from its known inhibitory effect of hemozoin formation. This is the first report of identifying chloroquine antimalarial targets by a parallel usage of labeled (ABPP) and label-free (MS-CETSA) methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2021identification,
  author = {Peng Gao and Yanqing Liu and Wei Xiao and Fei Xia and Jiayun Chen and Liwei Gu and Fan Yang and Liuhai Zheng and Junzhe Zhang and Qian Zhang and Zhijie Li and Yuqing Meng and Yongping Zhu and Chengchao Xu and Lingyun Dai and Jigang Wang},
  title = {{Identification of antimalarial targets of chloroquine by a combined deconvolution strategy of ABPP and MS-CETSA}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-958967/v1},
}
Figure