Identification of a non-thermal X-ray burst with the Galactic magnetar SGR J1935+2154 and a fast radio burst using Insight-HXMT

Cheng-Kui Li, Lin Lın, S. L. Xiong, Mingyu Ge, X.b. Li, Ti-Pei Li, F. J. Lu, Shuang‐Nan Zhang, Y. L. Tuo, Y. Nang, B. Zhang, Shuo Xiao, Y. Chen, L. M. Song, Y. P. Xu, C.z. Liu, S. M. Jia, Xuejun Cao, Jin‐Lu Qu, Y. D. Gu, J. Y. Liao, Xiaofan Zhao, Y. H. Tan, J. Y. Nie, Haisheng Zhao, S. J. Zheng, Y. G. Zheng, Q. Luo, Ce Cai, Bing Li, W. C. Xue, Qingcui Bu, Zhi Chang, G. Chen, T.x. Chen, Yongwei Dong, Y. Y. Du, H. Gao, M. Gao, J. Huo, D. W. Han, Luhua Jiang, Yuxiang Huang, Weichun Jiang, Junjie Jin, Ling-Da Kong, Gang Li, Ju Guan, Min-Yu Li, W. Li, Xufang Li, Yuqiang Li, Zhenkun Li, X. H. Liang, B.s. Liu, Haibo Liu, Xu Liu, Bo Lü, X. F. Lu, T. Luo, Xiang Ma, Bin Meng, G. Ou, Na Sai, X. Y. Song, Xilei Sun, Lian Tao, Jingjing Wang, G.f. Wang, W.s. Wang, Yuqi Wang, Xing Wen, Boyu Wu, Bowen Wu, M. Wu, G. Xiao, Heng Xu, Yi-Jung Yang, S. Yang, Y.j. Yang, Q. B. Yi, Qian-Qing Yin, Yuan You, Chi Zhang, Anbiao Zhang, Fan Zhang, H.m. Zhang, Jujia Zhang, Tong Zhang, Wei Zhang, W.c. Zhang, Yong Zhang, Yue Zhang, Y.f. ZhangResearch Square 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports the first definitive association between a Fast Radio Burst (FRB) and a magnetar, SGR J1935+2154. Using the Insight-HXMT satellite, researchers detected a non-thermal X-ray burst that precisely coincided in time and characteristics with the previously observed FRB 200428, strongly suggesting they originate from the same explosive event. This discovery provides crucial evidence for magnetars as a source of FRBs and opens new avenues for studying these enigmatic cosmic phenomena.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) are incredibly brief, intense flashes of radio waves originating from distant galaxies. Their exact cause has been a major mystery in astrophysics, with various theories proposed, including those involving magnetars. Magnetars are a type of neutron star with extremely powerful magnetic fields, known to emit X-ray and gamma-ray bursts. While some FRBs have been observed from repeating sources, and some magnetars have shown radio bursts, a direct, simultaneous observation of an FRB and an X-ray burst from the same magnetar had been missing. This lack of direct evidence made it difficult to confirm or refute the magnetar origin of FRBs. The paper addresses this gap by presenting the first compelling observational link between a specific FRB (FRB 200428) and a simultaneous X-ray burst from a known Galactic magnetar (SGR J1935+2154).

Methods

The researchers utilized data from the Insight-HXMT satellite, a Chinese X-ray observatory equipped with three telescopes (HE, ME, and LE) covering a broad energy range from 1 to 250 keV. They employed a dedicated Target of Opportunity (ToO) observation triggered by the known activity of SGR J1935+2154.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Burst Search: A search for X-ray bursts was conducted using specific trigger conditions based on the count rates of HE detectors.
  • Data Analysis: Standard data analysis software (HXMTDAS) was used for calibration, event selection, and GTI extraction.
  • Saturation and Deadtime Correction: Due to the extreme brightness of the detected burst, the data suffered from significant saturation and deadtime effects. The paper details the specific procedures used to correct for these effects in the lightcurves and spectra, which is crucial for accurate analysis.
  • Spectral Fitting: The X-ray spectrum of the burst was fitted using four different models: single power-law (PL), cutoff power-law (CPL), two blackbody (BB+BB), and blackbody plus power-law (BB+PL). This allowed them to determine the spectral properties and the nature of the emission (thermal vs. non-thermal).
  • Localization: The distinct Field of Views (FOVs) of the three Insight-HXMT telescopes were used to pinpoint the burst's location using a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is from the Insight-HXMT satellite. Specifically, it includes data from a dedicated observation of the magnetar SGR J1935+2154. The study also references and compares its findings with data from other instruments and observations, including:

  • CHIME/FRB and STARE2 for the detection of FRB 200428.
  • INTEGRAL and Konus-Wind for previous observations of the burst.
  • Fermi/GBM for historical burst data from SGR J1935+2154.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Smoking Gun" for Magnetar FRBs: This is the most significant insight. The precise temporal and spectral correlation between the X-ray burst and FRB 200428 provides the strongest evidence to date that magnetars can indeed produce FRBs.
  • Shared Physical Origin: The near-simultaneous detection of both the X-ray and radio bursts, with a time lag consistent with dispersion delay, strongly suggests they originate from the same explosive event and likely the same emission region within the magnetar.
  • Non-Thermal Nature of the X-ray Burst: Spectral analysis indicates that the observed X-ray burst is primarily non-thermal, which is consistent with the expected emission mechanisms for FRBs.
  • Implications for FRB Research: This finding revolutionizes our understanding of FRBs, suggesting that at least some FRBs are produced by magnetars. This opens up new possibilities for using FRBs as probes of extragalactic magnetars, which are otherwise difficult to study.
  • Magnetospheric Models Supported: The results lend support to magnetospheric models for FRB emission, where the radio and X-ray emissions are generated within the magnetar's magnetosphere.

Key Results

  • Detection of a non-thermal X-ray burst: Insight-HXMT detected a significant X-ray burst from the direction of SGR J1935+2154.
  • Temporal Correlation: The X-ray burst exhibited two hard peaks separated by approximately 30 ms, matching the separation of the FRB 200428 bursts. The time delay between the radio and X-ray peaks was ~8.57 seconds, consistent with the calculated dispersion delay.
  • Localization: The burst was localized to within ~3.7 arcminutes of SGR J1935+2154, with a 1σ error of ~10 arcminutes, strongly associating it with the magnetar.
  • Spectral Properties: The time-integrated spectrum was best fit by a cutoff power-law model, indicating a non-thermal emission component. The unabsorbed fluence was calculated to be (7.14±0.4)×10⁻⁷ erg cm⁻² in the 1–250 keV band.
  • Brightness: The burst was significantly brighter than ~84% of previously observed bursts from SGR J1935+2154.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Saturation and Deadtime Effects: While corrections were applied, the extreme brightness of the burst led to significant saturation and deadtime effects, which can still introduce uncertainties in the analysis.
  • Model Comparison: While the cutoff power-law model provided the best fit, the blackbody plus power-law model was also marginally consistent, suggesting a possible contribution from thermal components. Further investigation into these spectral models is warranted.
  • Extragalactic FRBs: The paper notes that detecting X-ray counterparts to extragalactic FRBs is currently challenging due to sensitivity limitations of X-ray telescopes. Future missions with enhanced sensitivity, like eXTP, could be crucial for this endeavor.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that FRBs can now be used as effective tools to study extragalactic magnetars. Future research will likely focus on identifying more such associations and using FRBs to probe the physics of magnetars and their environments. The study of giant flares from magnetars and their potential association with FRBs is also highlighted as an area for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Fast radio bursts (FRBs) are short pulses observed in radio band from cosmological distances, some of which emit repeating bursts. The physical origins of these mysterious events have been subject to wide speculations and heated debates. One class of models invoke soft gamma-ray repeaters (SGRs), or magnetars, as the sources of FRBs. Magnetars are rotating neutron stars with extremely strong magnetic field and can sporadically emit bursts from X-ray (keV) to soft gamma-ray (sub-MeV) with duration from 10􀀀2 s to 102 s. However, even though some bright radio bursts have been observed from some magnetars, no FRB-like events had been detected to be associated with any magnetar burst, including one giant flare, and no radio burst has been associated with any X-ray event from any magnetar. Therefore, there is still no observational evidence for magnetar-FRB association up to today. Recently, a pair of FRB-like bursts (FRB~200428 hereafter) separated by 30 milliseconds (ms) were detected from the general direction of the Galactic magnetar SGR~J1935+2154. Here we report the detection of a non-thermal X-ray burst in the 1--250\,keV energy band with the Insight-HXMT satellite, which we identify as emitted from SGR~J1935+2154. The burst showed two hard peaks with a separation of ms, consistent with the separation between the two bursts in FRB~200428. The delay time between the double radio and X-ray peaks is 8:57s, fully consistent with the dispersion delay of FRB~200428. We thus identify the non-thermal X-ray burst is associated with FRB~200428 whose high energy counterpart is the two hard peaks in X-ray. Our results suggest that the non-thermal X-ray burst and FRB~200428 share the same physical origin in an explosive event from SGR~J1935+2154.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2020identification,
  author = {Cheng-Kui Li and Lin Lın and S. L. Xiong and Mingyu Ge and X.B. Li and Ti-Pei Li and F. J. Lu and Shuang‐Nan Zhang and Y. L. Tuo and Y. Nang and B. Zhang and Shuo Xiao and Y. Chen and L. M. Song and Y. P. Xu and C.Z. Liu and S. M. Jia and Xuejun Cao and Jin‐Lu Qu and Shu Zhang and Y. D. Gu and J. Y. Liao and Xiaofan Zhao and Y. H. Tan and J. Y. Nie and Haisheng Zhao and S. J. Zheng and Y. G. Zheng and Q. Luo and Ce Cai and Bing Li and W. C. Xue and Qingcui Bu and Zhi Chang and G. Chen and T.X. Chen and Yupeng Chen and Yongwei Dong and Y. Y. Du and H. Gao and G. H. Gao and M. Gao and Y. D. Gu and J. Huo and D. W. Han and Luhua Jiang and Yuxiang Huang and Weichun Jiang and Junjie Jin and Ling-Da Kong and Gang Li and Ju Guan and Min-Yu Li and W. Li and X. Li and Xufang Li and Yuqiang Li and Zhenkun Li and X. H. Liang and B.S. Liu and Haibo Liu and Xu Liu and Bo Lü and X. F. Lu and T. Luo and Xiang Ma and Bin Meng and G. Ou and Na Sai and X. Y. Song and Xilei Sun and Lian Tao and Jingjing Wang and G.F. Wang and W.S. Wang and Yuqi Wang and Xing Wen and Boyu Wu and Bowen Wu and M. Wu and G. Xiao and Heng Xu and Yi-Jung Yang and S. Yang and Yi-Jung Yang and Y.J. Yang and Q. B. Yi and Qian-Qing Yin and Yuan You and Chi Zhang and Anbiao Zhang and Fan Zhang and H.M. Zhang and Jujia Zhang and Tong Zhang and Wei Zhang and W.C. Zhang and Yong Zhang and Yue Zhang and Y.F. Zhang},
  title = {{Identification of a non-thermal X-ray burst with the Galactic magnetar SGR J1935+2154 and a fast radio burst using Insight-HXMT}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-62191/v1},
}
Figure