Identification, Characterization and Function of Orphan Genes Among the Current Cucurbitaceae Genomes

Dongna Ma, Zhengfeng Lai, Qiansu Ding, Kun Zhang, Kaizhen Chang, Shuhao Li, Zhizhu Zhao, Fenglin ZhongFrontiers in Plant Science 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study systematically identifies and characterizes "orphan genes" (OGs) – genes lacking clear evolutionary relatives – across eight Cucurbitaceae species. The research reveals that OGs are surprisingly common, exhibit distinct structural features, and play crucial roles in plant development, reproduction, and adaptation, offering new avenues for crop improvement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Orphan genes (OGs) are a fascinating class of genes that lack identifiable homologs in other species. While their unique nature suggests they could be key drivers of novel biological functions and evolutionary innovation, their origins and specific roles remain largely mysterious, especially in important crop families. The Cucurbitaceae family, which includes economically significant crops like watermelon, cucumber, and melon, has a rich diversity of fruit traits but a limited understanding of the genetic underpinnings of these variations, particularly concerning OGs. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by comprehensively identifying, characterizing, and predicting the functions of OGs within the Cucurbitaceae lineage.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Comparative Genomics for OG Identification: They used a rigorous pipeline involving BLAST searches against multiple databases (Cucurbitaceae genomes, Plant-PUTs, UniProtKB, NR) to identify genes in eight Cucurbitaceae species that lacked significant homology to known genes.
  • Genic Characterization: Standard bioinformatics tools were used to analyze structural features like protein length, exon number, exon length, GC content, and isoelectric point, comparing OGs to non-orphan genes (NOGs).
  • Subcellular Localization and Chromosome Distribution: Tools like BUSCA and custom scripts were used to predict where these proteins function within the cell and map their locations on chromosomes.
  • Origin of Orphan Genes: They investigated potential evolutionary origins of OGs, focusing on gene duplication events (using DupGen_finder.pl) and also considering gene overlap, transposable element (TE) exaptation, and de novo origin.
  • Gene Expression Analysis: RNA-seq data from various tissues and under different environmental stresses (osmotic, drought, nitrogen) were analyzed to understand where and when OGs are expressed. They used tools like Trimmomatic, RSEM, and DESeq2 for data processing and differential expression analysis, and PaGeFinder for identifying tissue-specific genes.
  • Weighted Gene Co-expression Network Analysis (WGCNA) and Functional Prediction: WGCNA was employed to identify modules of co-expressed genes, and KEGG pathway enrichment analysis was used to infer the potential functions of OGs based on their co-expression partners.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available genomic and transcriptomic data:

  • Genomic Data: Assembled genomes and annotation information for eight Cucurbitaceae species (watermelon, bottle gourd, chayote, cucumber, melon, pumpkin, snake gourd, wax gourd) were obtained from the CuGenDB database. Additional plant genome data was sourced from PlantGDB and Phytozome.
  • Transcriptomic Data: RNA-seq data for various tissues (root, leaf, male flower, female flower, fruit, stem, ovary) and under different abiotic stresses (osmotic stress, drought stress, nitrogen treatment) from melon, cucumber, and watermelon were downloaded from NCBI (accession numbers provided in the paper).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • OGs are Abundant and Variable: The proportion of OGs varies significantly across Cucurbitaceae species, suggesting dynamic evolutionary pressures. This highlights that OGs are not rare anomalies but a substantial component of plant genomes.
  • Distinct Structural Signatures: OGs tend to be shorter, with fewer exons, than NOGs. This suggests a different evolutionary trajectory, possibly involving rapid gene birth and simplification.
  • Flower-Centric Expression: A striking finding is that OGs are disproportionately expressed in flowers, particularly male flowers. This points to a crucial role in reproductive development and potentially in the evolution of sexual reproduction.
  • Adaptation and Domestication Roles: OGs are implicated in environmental adaptation (e.g., to osmotic and drought stress in watermelon) and may have played a role in the domestication of crops like wax gourd, contributing to traits like large fruit size.
  • Functional Link to Male Sterility: Several OGs were found to be associated with male sterility in watermelon and flower development in cucumber, suggesting their importance in reproductive fitness and crop breeding.

Key Results

  • OG Content: OGs ranged from 1.63% (chayote) to 16.55% (wax gourd) of the total genes across the eight Cucurbitaceae species.
  • Gene Structure: OGs had significantly shorter protein lengths and fewer exons compared to NOGs across all species.
  • Expression Patterns: OGs were generally less abundantly and more tissue-specifically expressed than NOGs. The largest proportion of OGs showed higher tissue-specific expression in flowers.
  • Functional Predictions:
    • 18 OGs were associated with male sterility in watermelon.
  • 182 OGs were linked to flower development in cucumber.
  • 51 OGs were associated with environmental adaptation in watermelon.
  • 520 OGs were identified as potentially contributing to the large fruit size in wax gourd.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Functional Validation: While the study provides strong functional predictions based on expression and co-expression analysis, direct experimental validation of the specific functions of these OGs is still needed.
  • Origin Mechanisms: While gene duplication was highlighted as a major origin mechanism, further detailed investigation into the relative contributions of other mechanisms (de novo, TE exaptation, gene overlap) across different species could be beneficial.
  • Broader Species Scope: While eight species were analyzed, expanding the study to a wider range of Cucurbitaceae species or other plant families could reveal broader evolutionary trends of OGs.

The authors suggest that future research should focus on experimentally determining the precise functions of these OGs to fully understand their roles in plant evolution and to leverage them for crop improvement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Orphan genes (OGs) that are missing identifiable homologs in other lineages may potentially make contributions to a variety of biological functions. The Cucurbitaceae family consists of a wide range of fruit crops of worldwide or local economic significance. To date, very few functional mechanisms of OGs in Cucurbitaceae are known. In this study, we systematically identified the OGs of eight Cucurbitaceae species using a comparative genomics approach. The content of OGs varied widely among the eight Cucurbitaceae species, ranging from 1.63% in chayote to 16.55% in wax gourd. Genetic structure analysis showed that OGs have significantly shorter protein lengths and fewer exons in Cucurbitaceae. The subcellular localizations of OGs were basically the same, with only subtle differences. Except for aggregation in some chromosomal regions, the distribution density of OGs was higher near the telomeres and relatively evenly distributed on the chromosomes. Gene expression analysis revealed that OGs had less abundantly and highly tissue-specific expression. Interestingly, the largest proportion of these OGs was significantly more tissue-specific expressed in the flower than in other tissues, and more detectable expression was found in the male flower. Functional prediction of OGs showed that (1) 18 OGs associated with male sterility in watermelon; (2) 182 OGs associated with flower development in cucumber; (3) 51 OGs associated with environmental adaptation in watermelon; (4) 520 OGs may help with the large fruit size in wax gourd. Our results provide the molecular basis and research direction for some important mechanisms in Cucurbitaceae species and domesticated crops.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2022identification,
  author = {Dongna Ma and Zhengfeng Lai and Qiansu Ding and Kun Zhang and Kaizhen Chang and Shuhao Li and Zhizhu Zhao and Fenglin Zhong},
  title = {{Identification, Characterization and Function of Orphan Genes Among the Current Cucurbitaceae Genomes}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2022.872137},
}
Figure