Identification and reconstruction of low-energy electrons in the ProtoDUNE-SP detector
A. Abed Abud, B. Abi, R. Acciarri, M. A. Acero, M. R. Adames, G. Adamov, M. Adamowski, D. L. Adams, M. Adinolfi, C. Adriano, A. Aduszkiewicz, J. A. Aguilar, Zahid Ahmad, J. Ahmed, B. Aimard, F. Akbar, K. K. Allison, S. Alonso Monsalve, M. Alrashed, C. Alt, T. Alexander, R. Alvarez, P. Amedo, J. Anderson, D. A. Andrade, C. Andreopoulos, M. Andreotti, M.p. Andrews, F. Andrianala, S. Andringa, Н. Анфимов, Wallison Campanelli, Artur M. Ankowski, M. Antoniassi, M. Antonova, A. Antoshkin, Stefan Antusch, Alfredo Aranda, L. Arellano, L. Arnold, M. A. Arroyave, J. Asaadi, L. Asquith, A. Aurisano, V. Aushev, D. Autiero, M. Ayala-Torres, F. Azfar, H.o. Back, J. J. Back, I. Bagaturia, L. Bagby, N. Balashov, S. Balasubramanian, Pierre Baldi, B. Baller, Bindu A. Bambah, F. Barão, Gabriela Barenboim, Gareth J. Barker, W. Barkhouse, C. Barnes, G. Barr, J. Barranco Monarca, A. Barros, N. Barros, J. Barrow, A. Basharina-Freshville, A. Bashyal, V. Basque, C. Batchelor, James Battat, Francesca De Battisti, F. Bay, M. C. Q. Bazetto, J. L. L. Bazo Alba, J. F. Beacom, E. Bechetoille, B. Behera, E. Belchior Batista Das Chagas, L. Bellantoni, G. Bellettini, Vincenzo Bellini, O. Beltramello, N. Benekos, C. Benitez Montiel, D. Benjamin, F. Neves, J. Berger, S. Berkman, P. Bernardini, R. M. Berner, A. Bersani, S. Bertolucci, M. Betancourt, A. Betancur Rodríguez, A. J. Bevan, Y. Bezawada, Anibal BezerraarXiv2022 · DOI · arXiv
Researchers from the DUNE Collaboration have successfully demonstrated a high-purity (95%) method for identifying and reconstructing low-energy "Michel" electrons within the ProtoDUNE-SP detector. By leveraging the well-understood physics of cosmic muon decays, they established a robust energy calibration that improves energy resolution from 40% to 25% at 50 MeV—a critical milestone for DUNE’s ability to detect supernova and solar neutrinos.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) aims to solve some of the biggest mysteries in physics, from the origin of matter to the internal workings of supernovae. To do this, its Liquid Argon Time Projection Chambers (LArTPCs) must be able to detect electrons across a massive energy range.
While GeV-scale neutrinos are the primary focus for oscillation studies, "low-energy" electrons (in the tens of MeV range) are the signatures of supernova neutrino bursts and solar neutrinos. However, reconstructing these low-energy events is difficult. Small signals can be lost below electronics thresholds, "smeared" by detector noise, or partially missed by reconstruction algorithms. This paper addresses the need for a reliable way to identify these tiny signals and calibrate the detector's energy scale using a "standard candle": the Michel electron.
Methods
The team used ProtoDUNE-SP, a massive 700-ton prototype located at CERN, to study electrons produced by the decay of cosmic ray muons ($\mu \to e \nu \bar{\nu}$).
Selection Algorithm: They developed a dedicated workflow to find "stopping muons"—muons that come to a rest inside the detector. They then looked for a secondary cluster of ionization (the Michel electron) at the muon's endpoint.
Cone Cut: To separate electron hits from background noise or unrelated cosmic tracks, they applied a "cone" selection around the muon endpoint, optimized to maximize hit purity.
Two-Pronged Calibration:
Muon-based: Used standard calibration constants derived from through-going cosmic muons.
Michel-based: A novel approach that "anchors" the reconstructed charge directly to the theoretically known energy spectrum of Michel electrons.
Recombination Correction: They applied a data-driven correction using the "Modified Box model" to account for ionization electrons that recombine with argon ions before they can be drifted to the readout wires.
Datasets
Experimental Data: High-quality beam and cosmic ray data collected by the ProtoDUNE-SP detector at the CERN Neutrino Platform between 2018 and 2020.
Simulation: Large-scale Monte Carlo (MC) samples generated using CORSIKA (for cosmic ray flux) and Geant4 (for particle interactions and detector response).
Key Insights and Ideas
The "Standard Candle" works: The Michel electron spectrum is theoretically fixed. By matching the observed charge distribution to this theoretical shape, the researchers could calibrate the detector even without a test beam of known-energy electrons.
Accounting for the "Invisible": The study found that standard selection only captures about 75% of an electron's deposited energy. The remaining 25% is lost to hits falling below the readout threshold or landing outside the reconstruction cone.
Resolution is Energy-Dependent: The "aha moment" was quantifying how much the energy resolution improves when you account for these losses. By using simulations to "add back" the missing energy, the resolution at 50 MeV sharpened significantly.
Key Results
Purity: The selection process achieved a 95% purity for Michel electrons in both data and simulation.
Energy Scale: The muon-based and Michel-based calibration techniques agreed to within 1.8%, validating the detector’s linear response at low energies.
Resolution Improvement: The nominal energy resolution was approximately 40%. After correcting for lost energy using Monte Carlo simulations, the resolution improved to 25% at 50 MeV.
Recombination: The mean recombination factor ($R$) was measured at 0.625, consistent with the Modified Box model predictions for the detector's 500 V/cm electric field.
Limitations and Future Work
The primary limitation is that ProtoDUNE-SP is a surface-level detector. The actual DUNE far detector will be 1.5 km underground, where the cosmic muon flux (and thus the number of Michel electrons for calibration) will be much lower.
Future work will focus on:
Optimizing for Neutrino Events: Transitioning from "muon-adjacent" electrons to isolated electrons produced by actual electron-neutrino ($\nu_e$) interactions.
Hit Association: Improving the efficiency of associating small, isolated "blips" of ionization to the primary electron track to reduce the 4% systematic uncertainty currently associated with hit association.
Threshold Tuning: Further refining the electronics threshold models to minimize the 11% energy loss currently attributed to readout limits.
Summary updated
Abstract
Measurements of electrons from $ν_e$ interactions are crucial for the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) neutrino oscillation program, as well as searches for physics beyond the standard model, supernova neutrino detection, and solar neutrino measurements. This article describes the selection and reconstruction of low-energy (Michel) electrons in the ProtoDUNE-SP detector. ProtoDUNE-SP is one of the prototypes for the DUNE far detector, built and operated at CERN as a charged particle test beam experiment. A sample of low-energy electrons produced by the decay of cosmic muons is selected with a purity of 95%. This sample is used to calibrate the low-energy electron energy scale with two techniques. An electron energy calibration based on a cosmic ray muon sample uses calibration constants derived from measured and simulated cosmic ray muon events. Another calibration technique makes use of the theoretically well-understood Michel electron energy spectrum to convert reconstructed charge to electron energy. In addition, the effects of detector response to low-energy electron energy scale and its resolution including readout electronics threshold effects are quantified. Finally, the relation between the theoretical and reconstructed low-energy electron energy spectrum is derived and the energy resolution is characterized. The low-energy electron selection presented here accounts for about 75% of the total electron deposited energy. After the addition of lost energy using a Monte Carlo simulation, the energy resolution improves from about 40% to 25% at 50~MeV. These results are used to validate the expected capabilities of the DUNE far detector to reconstruct low-energy electrons.
BibTeX
@misc{abud2022identification,
author = {A. Abed Abud and B. Abi and R. Acciarri and M. A. Acero and M. R. Adames and G. Adamov and M. Adamowski and D. L. Adams and M. Adinolfi and C. Adriano and A. Aduszkiewicz and J. A. Aguilar and Zahid Ahmad and J. Ahmed and B. Aimard and F. Akbar and K. K. Allison and S. Alonso Monsalve and M. Alrashed and C. Alt and T. Alexander and R. Alvarez and P. Amedo and J. Anderson and D. A. Andrade and C. Andreopoulos and M. Andreotti and M.P. Andrews and F. Andrianala and S. Andringa and Н. Анфимов and Wallison Campanelli and Artur M. Ankowski and M. Antoniassi and M. Antonova and A. Antoshkin and Stefan Antusch and Alfredo Aranda and L. Arellano and L. Arnold and M. A. Arroyave and J. Asaadi and L. Asquith and A. Aurisano and V. Aushev and D. Autiero and M. Ayala-Torres and F. Azfar and H.O. Back and H. Back and J. J. Back and I. Bagaturia and L. Bagby and N. Balashov and S. Balasubramanian and Pierre Baldi and B. Baller and Bindu A. Bambah and F. Barão and Gabriela Barenboim and Gareth J. Barker and W. Barkhouse and C. Barnes and G. Barr and J. Barranco Monarca and A. Barros and N. Barros and J. Barrow and A. Basharina-Freshville and A. Bashyal and V. Basque and C. Batchelor and James Battat and Francesca De Battisti and F. Bay and M. C. Q. Bazetto and J. L. L. Bazo Alba and J. F. Beacom and E. Bechetoille and B. Behera and E. Belchior Batista Das Chagas and L. Bellantoni and G. Bellettini and Vincenzo Bellini and O. Beltramello and N. Benekos and C. Benitez Montiel and D. Benjamin and F. Neves and J. Berger and S. Berkman and P. Bernardini and R. M. Berner and A. Bersani and S. Bertolucci and M. Betancourt and A. Betancur Rodríguez and A. J. Bevan and Y. Bezawada and Anibal Bezerra},
title = {{Identification and reconstruction of low-energy electrons in the ProtoDUNE-SP detector}},
year = {2022},
eprint = {2211.01166},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.01166},
}