Ideal mean-field transition in a modulated cold atom system

Myoung-Sun Heo, Yong Hee Kim, Kihwan Kim, Geol Moon, Junhyun Lee, Heung-Ryoul Noh, M. I. Dykman, Wonho JhePhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We show that an atomic system in a periodically modulated optical trap displays an ideal mean-field symmetry-breaking transition. The symmetry is broken with respect to time translation by the modulation period. We describe experimental observations and develop a full microscopic theory of the observed critical phenomena. The transition is explained as resulting from the interplay of the long-range interatomic interaction and nonequilibrium fluctuations in the strongly modulated system. The observations, including anomalous fluctuations in the symmetry broken phase, are fully described by the theory.

Introduction

Mean-field theory is a cornerstone of statistical mechanics, providing a simplified framework to understand how individual components in a system cooperate to create a phase transition. While highly successful for systems in thermal equilibrium, mean-field theory often breaks down near the "critical point" where fluctuations dominate, or in systems far from equilibrium.

This research investigates whether a many-body system driven far from equilibrium can exhibit "ideal" mean-field behavior. The authors focus on spontaneous symmetry breaking regarding time. In a periodically driven system, the output typically matches the period of the drive. However, under specific conditions, the system can "choose" to respond at a different frequency (period doubling), breaking the discrete time-translation symmetry. This study utilizes a controlled cold-atom environment to bridge the gap between theoretical models and complex non-equilibrium reality.

Experimental Observations

The experimental setup involved a cloud of approximately $10^7$ $^{85}$Rb atoms trapped in a Magneto-Optical Trap (MOT) and cooled to roughly 0.4 mK. Using acousto-optic modulators, the team periodically varied the laser beam intensity at a frequency ($\omega_F$) nearly double the natural vibration frequency of the trap ($\omega_0$).

Figure 1: (a) Absorption images showing the atomic cloud splitting into two populations (Cloud 1 and Cloud 2) as the total atom number $N_{tot}$ exceeds the critical value $N_c$. (b) Measured population and amplitude changes as a function of atom number.

When the modulation amplitude crossed a threshold, the cloud spontaneously split into two separate populations vibrating in counter-phase at half the drive frequency ($\omega_F/2$). This phenomenon is a textbook example of discrete time-translation symmetry breaking. The researchers used high-speed imaging to track the population and vibration amplitude of these clouds as the total number of trapped atoms ($N_{tot}$) was varied.

Theoretical Framework: The Shadow Effect

The transition is driven by a subtle "kinetic" bias. While the physical interatomic forces are too weak to push atoms between vibrational states directly, they are strong enough to change the probability (the rate) of an atom switching states due to random noise.

The authors developed a microscopic theory based on a Master Equation to describe this switching. A key component is the "shadow effect"—a long-range interatomic force where atoms shield each other from laser light. This creates a collective interaction that biases switching rates. Because atoms move rapidly within a cloud but switch slowly between clouds, the system behaves as if it has no spatial dimensions (zero-dimensionality). This lack of long-range spatial correlations is precisely why the mean-field approximation remains "ideal" and accurate even at the critical point.

Critical Phenomena and Results

The system exhibited classic critical exponents that perfectly matched mean-field predictions, confirming the "ideal" nature of the transition. The researchers measured the relative population difference ($\eta$) as the order parameter and observed the following scaling laws:

  • Order Parameter ($\beta$): The population difference scaled as $|\eta| \propto \theta^{1/2}$, with a measured value of $\beta \approx 0.51 \pm 0.01$.
  • Susceptibility ($\delta$): At the critical point, the response to an external field scaled as $|\eta| \propto h^{1/3}$, with $\delta \approx 3.0 \pm 0.8$.
  • Variance ($\gamma$): Fluctuations scaled inversely with the distance from the critical point, $|\theta|^{-1}$.
Figure 3: (a) The order parameter $\eta$ vs. reduced control parameter $\theta$ showing the square-root scaling. (b) Variance $\tilde{\sigma}^2$ showing the divergence at the critical point. (c) Scaling of $\eta$ with external field $h$. (d) 3D plot of the phase transition boundary.

Notably, the researchers found that fluctuations were higher in the broken-symmetry phase than in the symmetric phase for the same distance from the critical point. This "anomalous fluctuation" behavior was fully captured by their non-equilibrium theory.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that even in systems far from equilibrium, ideal mean-field behavior can emerge through the interplay of long-range interactions and fluctuations. While the current model uses a 1D simplification of the MOT dynamics, it provides a robust platform for studying more complex non-equilibrium phenomena, including the potential effects of quantum fluctuations or transitions in systems with lower symmetry.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that an atomic system in a periodically modulated optical trap displays an ideal mean-field symmetry-breaking transition. The symmetry is broken with respect to time translation by the modulation period. We describe experimental observations and develop a full microscopic theory of the observed critical phenomena. The transition is explained as resulting from the interplay of the long-range interatomic interaction and nonequilibrium fluctuations in the strongly modulated system. The observations, including anomalous fluctuations in the symmetry broken phase, are fully described by the theory.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{heo2010ideal,
  author = {Myoung-Sun Heo and Yong Hee Kim and Kihwan Kim and Geol Moon and Junhyun Lee and Heung-Ryoul Noh and M. I. Dykman and Wonho Jhe},
  title = {{Ideal mean-field transition in a modulated cold atom system}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.82.031134},
}

Loading related content...

Figure