Abstract
Effective donor screening is critical for the safety and efficacy of Washed Microbiota Transplantation (WMT). This study established a rigorous three-stage screening program at Nanjing Medical University, evaluating 944 candidates between 2015 and 2021. The process resulted in a 3.4% qualification rate, identifying 32 eligible donors, with 10 becoming long-term contributors. Findings indicate that fecal weight is a poor predictor of microbiota yield and that long-term donors offer superior output and compliance.
Introduction
Fecal Microbiota Transplantation (FMT) has transitioned from an experimental treatment to a frontline therapy for conditions such as Clostridioides difficile infection and inflammatory bowel disease. However, the inherent variability of donor material poses a significant challenge to standardization. To address this, the China Microbiota Transplantation System (fmtBank) developed a protocol for Washed Microbiota Transplantation (WMT). WMT utilizes automated microfiltration to reduce pro-inflammatory metabolites and improve the safety profile of the transplant, necessitating even more stringent donor selection criteria than traditional FMT.
Methodology
The researchers implemented a step-by-step donor screening and management process from 2015 to 2021. The cohort primarily consisted of university students (average age 20.77 ± 1.45 years). The screening followed three distinct hurdles:
- Stage 1: Questionnaire Interview: Candidates were screened for age, BMI (18–24 $kg/m^2$), bowel habits, and extensive exclusion criteria including recent antibiotic use, infectious diseases, and high-risk behaviors.
- Stage 2: Face-to-Face Interview: Survivors of the questionnaire phase met with trained physicians to verify medical history and psychological stability.
- Stage 3: Laboratory Testing: Final candidates underwent comprehensive blood, urine, and fecal screening to rule out pathogens and underlying health issues.
Donors who actively contributed for more than six months were classified as "long-term donors."
Results and Screening Funnel
Out of 944 initial candidates, the screening process significantly narrowed the pool at each stage. Only 8.7% (82 candidates) passed the initial questionnaire. After physician interviews and laboratory testing, only 32 individuals (3.4%) were deemed qualified donors. This acceptance rate is consistent with high-standard stool banks globally, such as those in the United States and Canada.
These 32 donors provided a total of 2,009 fecal donations, highlighting the high throughput required to sustain a national rescue microbiota bank.
Key Insights
Fecal Weight vs. Microbiota Yield
A significant technical finding of this study is that fecal weight does not strongly correlate with the actual yield of enriched washed microbiota ($r = 0.64$; 95% CI, 0.62–0.67). This suggests that bulk weight is an unreliable proxy for the "active ingredient" dose in WMT, and yield cannot be predicted simply by visual or weight-based assessment of the raw donation.
The Importance of Long-Term Donors
Of the 32 qualified donors, only 10 (31%) transitioned into long-term donors (>6 months). These individuals demonstrated better compliance and more consistent microbiota output. The study suggests that donor retention is as vital as recruitment for maintaining a sustainable and high-quality microbiota bank.
Conclusion
The study demonstrates that a programmed, step-by-step screening process is a feasible and repeatable method for identifying high-quality donors from a large population. While the 3.4% qualification rate underscores the difficulty of finding ideal candidates, the identification of long-term donors provides a pathway toward more stable and effective microbiota transplantation systems.
Summary updated