ICONE19-44048 MULTI-SCALE ENTROPY ANALYSIS OF VR-BASED ANALOG-DIGITAL SYSTEM OF THE OPERATOR MENTAL WORKLOAD

Chun‐Yi Lee, Chih‐Wei Yang, Tsung-Chieh Cheng, Li-Chen Yang, Ta-Min Hung, Tien‐Lung SunThe Proceedings of the International Conference on Nuclear Engineering (ICONE) 2011 · DOI

Abstract

As nuclear power plants transition from traditional analog controls to digital interfaces, understanding the cognitive strain on operators is vital for safety. This paper proposes a framework using 3D Virtual Reality (VR) simulations and Multi-Scale Entropy (MSE) analysis of heart rate variability to objectively measure an operator's mental workload and adaptability during this high-stakes technological shift.

Introduction: The Human Factor in Nuclear Safety

The "human factor" is often the weakest link in nuclear safety; historical accidents are frequently traced back to operator negligence or poor decision-making under pressure. Currently, many nuclear plants are moving from analog systems (physical knobs and gauges) to all-digital control rooms. This transition fundamentally changes the operator's mental model. Digital interfaces can introduce new types of "noise," different information displays, and altered interaction methods that might inadvertently increase mental workload, especially during emergencies. There is a critical need for an objective, physiological way to measure this workload rather than relying solely on subjective questionnaires.

Methodology

1. The VR Simulation

To safely test operator reactions without risking a real plant, a virtual analog-digital control room was constructed. Using Cinema 4D for 3D modeling and Unity3D as the game engine, the researchers created a realistic, immersive environment that mimics the response of a real-world simulator. This allows operators to "trial run" new digital interfaces in a controlled setting.

The VR-based nuclear plant control room interface developed in Unity3D.

2. Physiological Analysis (MSE)

The core of the measurement framework is Multi-Scale Entropy (MSE) applied to heart rate variability (HRV). Electrocardiogram (ECG) sensors are used to collect "RR-interval" data—the time between successive heartbeats.

ECG waveform showing RR-intervals used for Multi-Scale Entropy analysis.

Unlike standard heart rate monitoring, MSE examines the complexity of the heart's rhythm across multiple time scales. By using Sample Entropy (SampEn) to quantify signal unpredictability and "coarse-graining" the data, researchers can determine if the heart's regulatory system is maintaining healthy complexity or becoming "rigid" under high mental stress.

Key Insights and Results

  • Complexity as Adaptability: In physiological terms, a "complex" signal indicates a healthy system capable of adapting to external changes. Measuring the complexity of an operator's heart rate reveals how well they are adapting to the digital environment.
  • VR as a Diagnostic Tool: Virtual Reality serves as more than a training platform; it is a diagnostic tool. By combining 3D environments with real-time physiological monitoring, designers can identify substandard interface layouts before they are implemented in physical plants.
  • Methodological Integration: The study successfully integrates 3D modeling, ECG data collection, and MSE mathematical pathways to create a robust pipeline for human factors research.

Conclusion and Future Work

This framework provides a more reliable, objective method for understanding operator mental models than traditional subjective surveys. While the current work establishes the technical pipeline, future research will focus on large-scale empirical validation and the development of real-time MSE processing to provide immediate feedback during training sessions.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the past, serious accidents of nuclear power plant usually had relation with the negligence, error handling and wrong decisions of operators. Therefore, to understand and be able to measure mental workload levels of operators are significant for safety issues in the nuclear power plant, especially when operators face emergency conditions. Therefore, this study is to determine the physiological indicators to measure the operator in the task of mental workload. This paper was to use electrocardiogram (ECG) measurements, to collect the RR-Interval data; heart rate variability (HRV) to analysis the complexity of the operator. After importing the data to calculate heart rate variability of complexity analysis, it can help us to understand the operator for the analog-digital platform adaptation. The virtual analog-digital nuclear plant control room is built using a 3D game development tool called Unity3D.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2011icone,
  author = {Chun‐Yi Lee and Chih‐Wei Yang and Tsung-Chieh Cheng and Li-Chen Yang and Ta-Min Hung and Tien‐Lung Sun},
  title = {{ICONE19-44048 MULTI-SCALE ENTROPY ANALYSIS OF VR-BASED ANALOG-DIGITAL SYSTEM OF THE OPERATOR MENTAL WORKLOAD}},
  booktitle = {The Proceedings of the International Conference on Nuclear Engineering (ICONE)},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1299/jsmeicone.2011.19.\_icone1944\_21},
}
Figure