Ice-VII-like molecular structure of ambient water nanomeniscus

Dongha Shin, Jonggeun Hwang, Wonho JheNature Communications 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have discovered that water confined in tiny gaps between nanoparticles, forming a "nanomeniscus," adopts a molecular structure similar to high-pressure ice-VII, even at room temperature and pressure. This finding, achieved using advanced Raman spectroscopy, challenges our understanding of water's behavior at the nanoscale and has implications for fields ranging from geology to biology.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Water, a ubiquitous substance, exhibits a bewildering array of phases and structures depending on temperature and pressure. While many of these phases, like common ice (ice-Ih), have been extensively studied at the molecular level, the structure of water confined in extremely small spaces – specifically, the "nanomeniscus" formed by capillary condensation between nanoparticles – has remained largely unknown. This nanomeniscus is a common feature in natural phenomena, from wet sand to biological systems, and its unusual mechanical properties suggest a unique molecular organization. Understanding this structure is crucial for explaining water's behavior in these confined environments.

Methods

The core technique employed is Surface-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy (SERS). SERS is a powerful method for detecting trace amounts of molecules by amplifying their Raman signals when they are adsorbed onto or in close proximity to nanostructured metal surfaces (in this case, silver nanoparticles). The authors developed a crucial purification strategy for their silver nanoparticle solution, reducing impurities to extremely low levels. This ultra-purification was essential to ensure that the observed SERS signal originated from the water itself, not from contaminants.

They also utilized:

  • Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations: To model the electromagnetic field enhancement in the "hot spots" between nanoparticles, where the nanomeniscus forms.
  • Temperature-dependent Raman spectroscopy: To investigate how the structure of the nanomeniscus changes with temperature.
  • Comparison with known ice phases: Raman spectra of various ice phases (ice-Ih, ice-VII, ice-VIII) were used as benchmarks for comparison.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements of water nanomenisci formed in situ and comparisons with existing spectroscopic data for known ice phases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ambient Ice-VII: The most striking finding is that water nanomenisci, formed under normal ambient conditions, exhibit a molecular structure remarkably similar to ice-VII, a phase typically associated with extremely high pressures.
  • Ubiquitous Nanomeniscus Structure: The ice-VII-like structure is not limited to specific surface materials or nanoparticle sizes. The researchers demonstrated this generality by using different surface coatings (gold, platinum, organic self-assembled monolayers) and varying nanoparticle sizes, all yielding similar spectral signatures.
  • Weakened Hydrogen Bonding: The observed spectral features, particularly the narrowed and blue-shifted OH-stretching bands, indicate a more ordered but also potentially strained hydrogen bonding network compared to bulk water.
  • Lattice Vibrations: The detection of a distinct lattice-vibrational mode at 230 cm⁻¹ further supports the crystalline, ice-like nature of the nanomeniscus.
  • Impurities are Key: The success of this study hinges on the meticulous purification of the silver nanoparticles. This highlights how even trace impurities can significantly alter the observed behavior of confined water.

Key Results

  • Spectral Signatures: The SERS spectra of water nanomenisci showed a narrowed tetrahedral peak (DDAA) at 3340 cm⁻¹ and a lattice-vibrational mode at 230 cm⁻¹, characteristic of ice-VII.
  • Temperature Independence: The spectral features of the nanomeniscus remained largely invariant across a temperature range from 110 K to 393 K, reinforcing its stable, ice-VII-like structure.
  • Surface Independence: Similar ice-VII-like spectral features were observed regardless of whether the nanoparticles were bare silver, coated with gold or platinum, or functionalized with an organic self-assembled monolayer.
  • Size Independence: The nanomeniscus structure was also found to be independent of nanoparticle size, ranging from tens to hundreds of nanometers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Structural vs. Spectroscopic Similarity: While the Raman spectra strongly suggest an ice-VII-like structure, the authors acknowledge that this doesn't definitively prove identical structural properties (e.g., molecular density distribution) and calls for further investigation.
  • Isotopic Dilution: Experiments with isotopically diluted HDO in D₂O to probe OH stretching were not stably observed, suggesting a need for further systematic investigation in this area.
  • Detailed Phase Transition Mechanisms: The observed low-temperature spectral changes in the DA peak and potential phase transitions to ice-VIII warrant further detailed examination, especially given their occurrence in highly confined spaces.
  • Biological and Chemical Implications: The authors suggest that understanding this nanoconfined water structure is crucial for comprehending chemical and biochemical reactions in nanoscale environments, including biological systems. Future work could explore these specific applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Structural transformations originating from diverse rearrangements of the hydrogen bonding in water create various phases. Although most phases have been well investigated down to the molecular level, the molecular structure of the nanomeniscus, a ubiquitous form of nanoscale water in nature, still remains unexplored. Here, we demonstrate that the water nanomeniscus exhibits the stable, ice-VII-like molecular structure in ambient condition. Surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy on trace amounts of water, confined in inter-nanoparticle gaps, shows a narrowed tetrahedral peak at 3340 cm -1 in the OH-stretching band as well as a lattice-vibrational mode at 230 cm -1 . In particular, the ice-VII-like characteristics are evidenced by the spectral independence with respect to temperature variations and differing surface types including the material, size and shape of nanoparticles. Our results provide un unambiguous identification of the molecular structure of nanoconfined water, which is useful for understanding the molecular aspects of water in various nanoscale, including biological, environments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shin2019ice,
  author = {Dongha Shin and Jonggeun Hwang and Wonho Jhe},
  title = {{Ice-VII-like molecular structure of ambient water nanomeniscus}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-08292-0},
}
Figure