Ice sheet and precession controlled subarctic Pacific productivity and upwelling over the last 550,000 years

Zhengquan Yao, Xuefa Shi, Qiuzhen Yin, Samuel L. Jaccard, Yanguang Liu, Zhengtang Guo, Sergey A. Gorbarenko, Kunshan Wang, Tianyu Chen, Zhipeng Wu, Qingyun Nan, Jianjun Zou, Hongmin Wang, Jingjing Cui, Anqi Wang, Gongxu Yang, Aimei Zhu, Aleksandr A. Bosin, Yuriy P. Vasilenko, Yonggui YuNature Communications 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reconstructs the export productivity and upwelling history of the subarctic Pacific over the last 550,000 years, revealing a strong influence of ice sheets and orbital precession on this region's role in regulating atmospheric CO2. The findings highlight the subarctic Pacific as a key player in modulating glacial-interglacial CO2 cycles, particularly on shorter, ~20 kyr timescales.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Atmospheric CO2 concentrations have oscillated significantly between glacial and interglacial periods for hundreds of thousands of years. While the Southern Ocean has been a primary focus for understanding these CO2 fluctuations, the subarctic Pacific, despite being the largest reservoir of respired carbon, has remained poorly understood. This knowledge gap limits our comprehensive understanding of global carbon cycle dynamics during Earth's climate history. Specifically, the mechanisms driving upwelling and its impact on CO2 exchange in this region over multiple glacial cycles were unclear due to a scarcity of high-resolution paleoceanographic records.

Methods

The researchers utilized a multi-pronged approach:

  • Sediment Core Analysis: They analyzed a 7.6-meter sediment core (LV76-16-1) from the subarctic northwestern Pacific.
  • High-Resolution Proxies: They employed several proxies to reconstruct past conditions:
  • Export Productivity: Measured using biogenic barium (Ba/Ti), biogenic silica (opal content), and calcium carbonate (Ca/Ti). These proxies indicate the amount of organic matter sinking from the surface to the seafloor.
  • Upwelling Index: Developed by combining productivity proxies with sedimentary nitrogen isotopes (δ¹⁵N). This index quantifies the strength of nutrient-rich subsurface water rising to the surface.
  • 230Th Normalization: This standard geochronological technique was applied to the productivity proxies to obtain flux records, ensuring accurate comparisons over time by accounting for variations in sediment accumulation rates.
  • Transient Climate Modeling: They used the LOVECLIM1.3 Earth system model to simulate past climate conditions. Specifically, they ran experiments isolating the effects of orbital forcing (precession and obliquity), greenhouse gases (GHG), and Northern Hemisphere ice sheets on atmospheric circulation, particularly the strength and position of the northern westerlies.

Datasets

  • Sediment Core LV76-16-1: A new, high-resolution record from the subarctic Pacific spanning the last 550,000 years.
  • Existing Paleoclimate Records: The study compares its findings with established records, including:
  • Benthic δ¹⁸O stack (a proxy for global ice volume and temperature).
  • Atmospheric CO2 concentrations from Antarctic ice cores (e.g., EDC PCO2).
  • Upwelling indices from other regions (e.g., Southern Ocean, Bering Sea).
  • Model outputs from previous studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Subarctic Pacific's Dual Control: The subarctic Pacific's export productivity and upwelling are not solely driven by one factor but are significantly influenced by a combination of ice sheet dynamics and orbital precession.
  • Precession's Shorter-Term Influence: While glacial-interglacial cycles (driven by obliquity) are evident, the ~20 kyr precession cycle plays a surprisingly prominent role in modulating upwelling and productivity in the subarctic Pacific, a feature less pronounced in the Southern Ocean.
  • Westerlies as the Key Link: Changes in the strength and latitudinal position of the northern westerlies are identified as the crucial mechanism connecting orbital forcing and ice sheets to upwelling and productivity.
  • Seesaw Pattern with Subtropics: The study suggests a potential "seesaw" pattern in productivity between the subarctic and subtropical Pacific, with westerlies shifting meridionally, leading to contrasting responses during glacial and interglacial periods.
  • Ice Sheets Dominate Westerlies: Model simulations reveal that while orbital forcing (precession) influences the westerlies, the presence and extent of Northern Hemisphere ice sheets exert a much stronger control on their intensity and position.

Key Results

  • Glacial-Interglacial Cyclicity: The reconstructed export productivity records from core LV76-16-1 show clear glacial-interglacial cycles, with higher productivity during warmer interglacial periods and lower productivity during colder glacial periods.
  • Precessional Signal: Superimposed on the glacial-interglacial cycles is a distinct precessional signal (~20 kyr), particularly evident in the Ba/Ti and upwelling index records.
  • Model-Proxy Agreement: Transient climate model simulations align well with the proxy data, demonstrating that ice sheets and precession are the primary drivers of northern westerlies and, consequently, upwelling in the subarctic Pacific.
  • CO2 Modulation: The study provides strong evidence that the subarctic Pacific's upwelling dynamics significantly contribute to modulating atmospheric CO2 levels during glacial-interglacial cycles, especially on the ~20 kyr precession timescale.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Proxy Interpretation: While the authors argue that diagenetic processes did not significantly obscure their records, they acknowledge that productivity proxies can be subject to differential preservation.
  • Model Resolution: The model simulations, while providing valuable insights, are based on specific configurations and may have limitations in fully capturing all complex Earth system interactions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research should focus on refining the understanding of the subarctic Pacific's role in global CO2 regulation, particularly in the context of ongoing global warming and the potential poleward shift of northern westerly winds. They also highlight the need to integrate these findings with other regions to build a more complete picture of past climate dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The polar oceans play a vital role in regulating atmospheric CO<sub>2</sub> concentrations (pCO<sub>2</sub>) during the Pleistocene glacial cycles. However, despite being the largest modern reservoir of respired carbon, the impact of the subarctic Pacific remains poorly understood due to limited records. Here, we present high-resolution, <sup>230</sup>Th-normalized export productivity records from the subarctic northwestern Pacific covering the last five glacial cycles. Our records display pronounced, glacial-interglacial cyclicity superimposed with precessional-driven variability, with warm interglacial climate and high boreal summer insolation providing favorable conditions to sustain upwelling of nutrient-rich subsurface waters and hence increased export productivity. Our transient model simulations consistently show that ice sheets and to a lesser degree, precession are the main drivers that control the strength and latitudinal position of the westerlies. Enhanced upwelling of nutrient/carbon-rich water caused by the intensification and poleward migration of the northern westerlies during warmer climate intervals would have led to the release of previously sequestered CO<sub>2</sub> from the subarctic Pacific to the atmosphere. Our results also highlight the significant role of the subarctic Pacific in modulating pCO<sub>2</sub> changes during the Pleistocene climate cycles, especially on precession timescale ( ~ 20 kyr).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yao2024ice,
  author = {Zhengquan Yao and Xuefa Shi and Qiuzhen Yin and Samuel L. Jaccard and Yanguang Liu and Zhengtang Guo and Sergey A. Gorbarenko and Kunshan Wang and Tianyu Chen and Zhipeng Wu and Qingyun Nan and Jianjun Zou and Hongmin Wang and Jingjing Cui and Anqi Wang and Gongxu Yang and Aimei Zhu and Aleksandr A. Bosin and Yuriy P. Vasilenko and Yonggui Yu},
  title = {{Ice sheet and precession controlled subarctic Pacific productivity and upwelling over the last 550,000 years}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-47871-8},
}
Figure