iBitter-Fuse: A Novel Sequence-Based Bitter Peptide Predictor by Fusing Multi-View Features

Phasit Charoenkwan, Chanin Nantasenamat, Md Mehedi Hasan, Mohammad Ali Moni, Píetro Lió, Watshara ShoombuatongInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces iBitter-Fuse, a novel machine learning model that significantly improves the accuracy of predicting bitter peptides by combining multiple feature representations. The developed tool offers a more efficient and cost-effective way to identify bitter peptides, aiding in drug development and food science.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mammalian species have an innate aversion to bitter tastes, which is mediated by bitter taste receptors (T2Rs) interacting with bitter peptides. Understanding and accurately identifying these bitter peptides is crucial for various applications, including drug development (e.g., masking bitter tastes in medications) and nutritional research. While experimental methods exist, they are time-consuming and expensive. Existing computational methods, though promising, have limitations in their prediction accuracy and generalization capabilities, often due to insufficient feature representation or the inclusion of irrelevant features. This paper aims to address these shortcomings by developing a more accurate and robust predictor for bitter peptides.

Methods

The core of iBitter-Fuse lies in its multi-view feature fusion strategy combined with an optimized feature selection process.

  • Feature Extraction: The researchers explored several established methods to represent peptide sequences:
  • Amino Acid Composition (AAC): Captures the frequency of each of the 20 amino acids.
  • Dipeptide Composition (DPC): Captures the frequency of all possible pairs of adjacent amino acids (400 combinations).
  • Pseudo Amino Acid Composition (PAAC): Incorporates sequence order information beyond simple composition by considering physicochemical properties.
  • Amphiphilic Pseudo Amino Acid Composition (APAAC): Similar to PAAC but specifically emphasizes amphiphilic properties.
  • Physicochemical Properties (AAI): Utilizes a large database of amino acid indices (AAindex) that represent various biophysical and biochemical properties.
  • Fusion: These diverse features were combined to create a comprehensive representation of each peptide.
  • Feature Selection: To avoid information redundancy and potential overfitting from the large fused feature set, a customized Genetic Algorithm utilizing Self-Assessment-Report (GA-SAR) was employed. GA-SAR is designed to automatically identify the most informative features while simultaneously optimizing the parameters of the classifier.
  • Classification: The selected optimal features were then fed into a Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifier, a well-established algorithm for binary classification, to build the final iBitter-Fuse model. The SVM used a radial basis function (RBF) kernel for non-linear transformations.

Datasets

The study utilized a single benchmark dataset called BTP640, which contains 640 peptide sequences (320 bitter and 320 non-bitter). This dataset was randomly split into a training set (80%, 512 sequences) and an independent test set (20%, 128 sequences) to ensure a fair evaluation of the model's generalization ability. This dataset appears to be the same one used in previous studies ([17], [18]), ensuring comparability.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The power of feature fusion: Combining diverse feature representations (compositional, sequential, and physicochemical) significantly boosts predictive performance compared to using any single feature type. This highlights that different aspects of a peptide's sequence contribute uniquely to its bitterness.
  • Intelligent feature selection is crucial: Even with powerful feature fusion, a large number of features can lead to overfitting. The GA-SAR approach effectively reduced the feature space to a small, highly informative subset (36 features), leading to a more robust and generalizable model.
  • SVM remains a strong contender: Despite the rise of deep learning, SVM, when combined with carefully selected features, can achieve state-of-the-art performance in this domain.
  • Web server for accessibility: Making the predictor available as a web server significantly lowers the barrier to entry for researchers, facilitating broader adoption and application.

Key Results

The iBitter-Fuse model demonstrated superior performance compared to existing state-of-the-art methods and conventional machine learning classifiers.

  • Overall Performance: On the independent test set, iBitter-Fuse achieved an Accuracy (ACC) of 0.930, Sensitivity (Sn) of 0.938, Specificity (Sp) of 0.922, and Matthews Correlation Coefficient (MCC) of 0.859.
  • Comparison with Feature Encodings: The fused feature set outperformed individual encodings like AAC, DPC, PAAC, APAAC, and AAI in both 10-fold cross-validation and independent tests. For instance, on the independent test set, the fused feature achieved an ACC of 0.906, while the best individual feature (AAI) reached 0.891.
  • Comparison with State-of-the-Art: iBitter-Fuse significantly outperformed previous predictors like iBitter-SCM and BERT4Bitter. On the independent test set, it achieved higher ACC, Sn, Sp, and MCC values compared to both, with improvements of up to 8.6% in ACC and 17.1% in MCC over iBitter-SCM, and slightly better performance than BERT4Bitter.
  • Feature Reduction: The GA-SAR successfully identified an optimal set of 36 informative features from the initial 994 fused features, which were sufficient to achieve high performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dataset Size: While the benchmark dataset is standard, a larger and more diverse dataset could further improve the model's robustness and generalization.
  • Feature Engineering: Although multiple feature types were explored, there might be other novel feature representations that could further enhance performance.
  • Experimental Validation: The paper focuses on computational prediction. Future work could involve experimental validation of the predicted bitter peptides.
  • De Novo Design: The authors suggest that iBitter-Fuse can be a useful tool for aiding the "de novo design" of bitter peptides, implying future work could focus on generative models or optimization algorithms for designing novel bitter peptides with desired properties.
  • Web Server Enhancement: The web server is a valuable resource, and future work could involve expanding its functionality or integrating it with other bioinformatics tools.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accurate identification of bitter peptides is of great importance for better understanding their biochemical and biophysical properties. To date, machine learning-based methods have become effective approaches for providing a good avenue for identifying potential bitter peptides from large-scale protein datasets. Although few machine learning-based predictors have been developed for identifying the bitterness of peptides, their prediction performances could be improved. In this study, we developed a new predictor (named iBitter-Fuse) for achieving more accurate identification of bitter peptides. In the proposed iBitter-Fuse, we have integrated a variety of feature encoding schemes for providing sufficient information from different aspects, namely consisting of compositional information and physicochemical properties. To enhance the predictive performance, the customized genetic algorithm utilizing self-assessment-report (GA-SAR) was employed for identifying informative features followed by inputting optimal ones into a support vector machine (SVM)-based classifier for developing the final model (iBitter-Fuse). Benchmarking experiments based on both 10-fold cross-validation and independent tests indicated that the iBitter-Fuse was able to achieve more accurate performance as compared to state-of-the-art methods. To facilitate the high-throughput identification of bitter peptides, the iBitter-Fuse web server was established and made freely available online. It is anticipated that the iBitter-Fuse will be a useful tool for aiding the discovery and de novo design of bitter peptides.
BibTeX
@article{charoenkwan2021ibitter,
  author = {Phasit Charoenkwan and Chanin Nantasenamat and Md Mehedi Hasan and Mohammad Ali Moni and Píetro Lió and Watshara Shoombuatong},
  title = {{iBitter-Fuse: A Novel Sequence-Based Bitter Peptide Predictor by Fusing Multi-View Features}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms22168958},
}
Figure