I or We? How Self-Categorization Shapes Decision-Making in Team Sports

Alan Guyomarch, Benoit R. Cottereau, Simon Martin, Émilie Pété, Mickaël Campo2024 · DOI

Abstract

According to the Social Identity Approach, self-categorization influences how individuals define themselves, either as individuals or as members of a group, thereby affecting performance outcomes. To deepen our understanding of social identity's role, we conducted an experiment to examine its impact on a critical objective performance determinant: decision-making. Ten professional basketball players viewed 14 immersive video clips twice, under two conditions: (a) personal identity and (b) social identity, with randomized conditions and clip orders. Results revealed that players shot significantly more in the personal identity condition and passed more in the social identity condition. These findings suggest that social identity can shape athletes' choices, underscoring the importance of integrating social and psychological dimensions into models of decision-making.

Introduction

While the importance of team cohesion is widely recognized in sports, research on "social identity" has frequently relied on correlational data or subjective self-reports. There remains a significant gap in objective, experimental evidence demonstrating how social identity directly influences performance-related variables. This study addresses the "Social Identity Performance Hypothesis," investigating whether self-categorization—defining oneself as an individual ("I") or as part of a group ("We")—causally drives tactical choices in high-pressure scenarios.

Methods

The study employed a within-subjects design involving 10 professional basketball players from the French third division. Participants viewed 14 immersive, first-person video clips of 5-on-5 game scenarios under two experimental conditions:

  1. Personal Identity (PI): Primed to maximize individual performance. Players wore jerseys distinct from on-screen teammates, viewed personal images, and were told they were being ranked individually.
  2. Social Identity (SI): Primed to optimize team success. Players wore team-matching jerseys, viewed team photos, and were told their performance contributed to a collective team score.
Experimental setup showing the trial timeline (A), physical laboratory arrangement (B), and the immersive visual field (C).

To ensure "perception-action coupling," players mimed and verbalized their decisions (Shoot, Pass, or Drive) immediately upon the occlusion of the video clip. Data from 270 decisions were analyzed using Generalized Linear Mixed Models (GLMM) to account for individual variations.

Results

The experimental manipulation of identity led to distinct tactical shifts:

  • Shooting: Players were significantly more likely to shoot in the Personal Identity condition ($z = 3.890, p < .001$).
  • Passing: Players were significantly more likely to pass in the Social Identity condition ($z = -4.102, p < .001$).
  • Reaction Times: A significant difference was found only for the "drive" decision, where participants were slower in the Personal Identity condition ($p = .048$). Reaction times for shooting and passing remained stable across conditions.

Discussion

The results indicate that identity acts as a "tactical filter." When the personal "I" is salient, the basket is perceived as the primary target; when the collective "We" is salient, teammates are prioritized. Interestingly, the frequency of "driving" did not change, likely due to its hybrid nature as both a scoring and playmaking action.

The stability of reaction times for shooting and passing suggests that expert athletes maintain confidence in their choices regardless of social motive, simply adapting the type of action to the psychological context. However, individual differences were noted, with some players showing minimal behavioral shifts, suggesting varying levels of susceptibility to social priming or pre-existing alignment between personal and team goals.

Conclusion

This study provides objective evidence that psychosocial factors like self-categorization are causal drivers of decision-making in team sports. Coaches can leverage these insights by modulating a team's sense of belonging to reinforce specific tactical game plans, such as encouraging more unselfish play through enhanced social identity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Introduction: According to the Social Identity Approach, self-categorization influences how individuals define themselves, either as individuals or as members of a group, thereby affecting performance outcomes.To deepen our understanding of social identity's role, we conducted an experiment to examine its impact on a critical objective performance determinant: decisionmaking.Method: Ten professional basketball players viewed 14 immersive video clips twice, under two conditions: (a) personal identity and (b) social identity, with randomized conditions and clip orders.Upon each clip's conclusion, participants mimed and verbalized their decision as in a real game.In the personal identity condition, they were instructed to compete individually and make decisions that would maximize their own performance in this type of match situation.In the social identity condition, they were instructed to compete on behalf of their team and make decisions that would optimize team performance.To strengthen self-categorization, additional induction strategies were used, including image projections, team-specific jerseys, and tailored questionnaires.The data were analyzed using generalized linear models.Results: The analysis of 270 decisions revealed that players shot significantly more in the personal identity condition and passed more in the social identity condition.Reaction times also differed between conditions, but only for the drive decision.Discussion: These findings contribute to a growing body of research highlighting the influence of psychosocial factors on decision-making in team sports.They suggest that social identity can shape athletes' choices, underscoring the importance of integrating social and psychological dimensions into models of decision-making. HIGHLIGHTS Self-categorization influences decision-making in team sports. Players shoot more in the personal identity condition and pass more in the social identity condition. This study provides objective evidence that self-categorization impact performance factors. Individual differences exist, with some individuals exhibiting significantly reduced responsiveness to social identity effects.
BibTeX
@misc{guyomarch2024i,
  author = {Alan Guyomarch and Benoit R. Cottereau and Simon Martin and Émilie Pété and Mickaël Campo and Mickael Campo},
  title = {{I or We? How Self-Categorization Shapes Decision-Making in Team Sports}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.51224/srxiv.386},
}
Figure