MYB5a/NEGAN activates petal anthocyanin pigmentation and shapes the MBW regulatory network in Mimulus luteus var. variegatus

Xingyu Zheng, Kuenzang Om, Kimmy A Stanton, Daniel Thomas, Philip A. Cheng, Allison Eggert, Yao‐Wu Yuan, Joshua R. Puzey, Arielle M. CooleybioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies MYB5a/NEGAN as the key gene responsible for the recent evolution of purple petal pigmentation in Mimulus luteus var. variegatus. By manipulating its expression, the researchers demonstrate that MYB5a is both sufficient and necessary for this trait, and its altered deployment significantly reshapes the entire anthocyanin regulatory network.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The evolution of novel traits, like flower color, is a cornerstone of understanding biodiversity. Anthocyanin pigmentation in flowers is a well-studied model for this, with a known regulatory network involving MYB, bHLH, and WD40 transcription factors (collectively known as the MBW complex). However, how a single genetic change can lead to a significant phenotypic innovation, like the gain of petal lobe pigmentation, and how this impacts the broader regulatory network, remains an active area of research. Specifically, in the monkeyflower genus Mimulus, the gain of petal lobe anthocyanin in M. luteus var. variegatus was previously mapped to a specific genomic region, but the precise gene and the extent of its network-wide effects were unclear. This paper aims to pinpoint the causative gene and elucidate its role in shaping the MBW regulatory network.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Sequence Analysis: They sequenced and analyzed candidate genes within the mapped genomic region, specifically focusing on MYB transcription factors.
  • Gene Expression Analysis: Quantitative RT-PCR was used to examine the spatial and temporal expression patterns of candidate genes in different tissues (leaf, nectar guide, petal) and developmental stages of both pigmented (M. l. variegatus) and non-pigmented (M. l. luteus) varieties.
  • Transgenic Manipulation:
    • Overexpression: The NEGAN gene from a related species (M. lewisii) was overexpressed in the yellow-flowered M. l. luteus to test its sufficiency for inducing pigmentation.
  • RNAi Knockdown: RNA interference (RNAi) was used to specifically reduce the expression of MYB5a in M. l. variegatus to assess its necessity for petal lobe pigmentation.
  • Transcriptome Sequencing (RNA-seq): RNA-seq was performed on MYB5a RNAi lines and wild-type controls to comprehensively analyze global gene expression changes and identify downstream targets and affected regulatory partners.
  • Bioinformatics and Statistical Analysis: Standard bioinformatics tools were used for sequence alignment, differential gene expression analysis (DESeq2), principal component analysis (PCA), and GO/KEGG enrichment analysis to interpret the transcriptome data.

Datasets

The study utilized plant material from two Mimulus varieties: M. luteus var. luteus (yellow-flowered) and M. luteus var. variegatus (purple-petaled). For transcriptome analysis, RNA was extracted from petal tissue of both wild-type M. l. variegatus and the MYB5a RNAi line (Vrnail), as well as from M. naiandinus as an outgroup. The study also references publicly available whole-genome sequences and transcriptome data for M. luteus.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Single Gene, Big Impact: The discovery that a single gene, MYB5a, is sufficient and necessary for a major phenotypic innovation (petal lobe pigmentation) is a powerful illustration of how simple genetic changes can drive evolutionary novelty.
  • Deployment, Not Just Mutation: The study highlights that the location and level of gene expression (cis-regulatory changes) can be as crucial as mutations within the coding sequence itself for driving evolutionary change. MYB5a's expression pattern directly correlates with pigmentation.
  • Network Rewiring: The most striking insight is how knocking down MYB5a doesn't just affect the direct downstream genes of the anthocyanin pathway but also significantly impacts other regulatory components of the MBW complex, including repressors. This suggests MYB5a acts as a central hub, influencing the entire regulatory ecosystem.
  • Conservation and Divergence: While MYB5a/NEGAN's role in nectar guide pigmentation appears conserved across Mimulus, its deployment to petal lobes in M. l. variegatus represents a novel evolutionary step, contrasting with the use of ancient paralogs for this trait in other species.

Key Results

  • MYB5a Identified: MYB5a, a homolog of NEGAN, was identified as the candidate gene within the pla2 locus responsible for petal lobe pigmentation.
  • Expression Patterns: MYB5a is strongly and specifically expressed in the pigmented petal lobes of M. l. variegatus, with much lower expression in the nectar guides and undetectable expression in non-pigmented tissues or in M. l. luteus.
  • Sufficiency: Overexpression of NEGAN (from M. lewisii) in yellow-flowered M. l. luteus induced anthocyanin pigmentation in leaves and petals.
  • Necessity: RNAi knockdown of MYB5a in M. l. variegatus completely abolished petal lobe and nectar guide pigmentation.
  • Network Effects: Transcriptome analysis revealed that knocking down MYB5a led to the coordinated downregulation of Late Biosynthetic Genes (LBGs) like DFR, ANS, and UF3GT. Crucially, it also significantly downregulated other anthocyanin regulatory genes, including bHLH and WD40 co-activators, and notably, R3 MYB repressors (RTO).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Coding vs. Cis-regulatory Evolution: While the study strongly suggests cis-regulatory changes in MYB5a expression are key, the authors acknowledge that further experiments, such as promoter swaps, would be beneficial to definitively test the impact of coding versus cis-regulatory evolution on functional divergence.
  • Functional Diversification of bHLHs: The study notes that the identified M. l. variegatus bHLH co-factors show high similarity to M. lewisii ANbHLH3, which is not expressed in petal lobes, suggesting potential functional diversification in these co-factors as well.
  • Off-Target Effects: While the authors attempted to rule out off-target effects by checking other MYB genes, the complexity of allotetraploid genomes in Mimulus means that subtle off-target effects are always a consideration.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that further investigation into the precise cis-regulatory mutations and the detailed mechanisms by which MYB5a influences its regulatory partners will be valuable. Understanding how this simple genetic change leads to such widespread network effects is a key area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Much of the visual diversity of angiosperms is due to the frequent evolution of novel pigmentation patterns in flowers. The gene network responsible for anthocyanin pigmentation, in particular, has become a model for investigating how genetic changes give rise to phenotypic innovation. In the monkeyflower genus Mimulus , an evolutionarily recent gain of petal lobe anthocyanin pigmentation in M. luteus var. variegatus was previously mapped to genomic region pla2 . Here, we use DNA sequence analysis and spatiotemporal patterns of gene expression to identify MYB5a - homologous to the NEGAN transcriptional activator from M. lewisii - as a likely candidate gene within the pla2 region. Transgenic manipulation of gene expression confirms that MYB5a is both necessary and sufficient for petal lobe anthocyanin pigmentation. The deployment of MYB5a/NEGAN to the petal lobe stands in contrast to its more restricted role as a nectar guide anthocyanin activator in other Mimulus species. Transcriptome sequencing of a MYB5a RNAi line reveals the degree to which other regulators of the anthocyanin pathway - including R3 MYB repressors and bHLH and WD40 co-activators - are responsive to the level of expression of MYB5a . Overall, this work reveals that a genetically simple change, which we hypothesize to be a regulatory mutation in cis to MYB5a , has cascading effects on gene expression, not only on the genes downstream of MYB5a but also on all of its known partners in the anthocyanin regulatory network. Graphical abstract. Solid black arrows indicate the direction (though not magnitude) of gene expression change, following RNAi knockdown of MYB5a/NEGAN in M. l. variegatus . The number of black arrows corresponds to the number of gene copies identified in the transcriptome. Grey symbols denote positive and negative regulatory interactions. RTO is an R3 MYB protein that inhibits anthocyanin biosynthesis by sequestering bHLH proteins away from the MBW complex.
BibTeX
@misc{zheng2020i,
  author = {Xingyu Zheng and Kuenzang Om and Kimmy A Stanton and Daniel Thomas and Philip A. Cheng and Allison Eggert and Yao‐Wu Yuan and Joshua R. Puzey and Arielle M. Cooley},
  title = {{<i>MYB5a/NEGAN</i> activates petal anthocyanin pigmentation and shapes the MBW regulatory network in <i>Mimulus luteus</i> var. <i>variegatus</i>}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.04.09.030536},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure