“I Had No Hope, I Had No Help at All”: Insights from a First Study of Fathers and Recurrent Care Proceedings

Georgia Philip, Lindsay Youansamouth, Stuart Bedston, Karen Broadhurst, Yang Hu, John Clifton, Marian BrandonSocieties 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides the first large-scale insights into fathers involved in recurrent child protection proceedings in England, revealing that these fathers often share histories of childhood adversity, economic disadvantage, and significant mental health and substance use issues. The research highlights the critical role of enduring couple relationships and advocates for more tailored, couple- and father-inclusive support services within the family justice system.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The UK's family courts have seen a significant rise in "recurrent care proceedings," where children are repeatedly brought before the court due to ongoing harm or risk of harm. While research has extensively focused on mothers in these situations, fathers have remained largely "invisible" in this area of study. This lack of understanding creates a critical gap, as fathers play a crucial role in child welfare. The problem is that existing interventions and research often overlook fathers' unique experiences, circumstances, and vulnerabilities, potentially hindering effective support and prevention strategies for recurrent care cases. This paper aims to address this gap by providing the first comprehensive look at fathers involved in these proceedings.

Methods

This research employed a mixed-methods approach, combining three strands:

  1. Population-level administrative data analysis: Examining data from the Child and Family Court Advisory and Support Service (CAFCASS) to understand the scale and patterns of fathers' involvement in care proceedings.
  2. Survey of fathers: A survey administered to fathers involved in pre-proceedings and care proceedings, with a matched component completed by a practitioner involved in the case. This survey used a multiple-choice format with one open-ended question, drawing on established instruments like the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) survey and Understanding Society.
  3. Qualitative Longitudinal (QL) study: In-depth interviews and regular follow-up contacts with a group of 26 recurrent fathers over 6-12 months. This longitudinal approach allowed for a deep exploration of their life trajectories, transitions, and coping strategies.

The QL data was analyzed using a "Frameworks" approach, involving indexing, sorting, and summarizing cases and temporal waves to understand change over time.

Datasets

  • CAFCASS Administrative Data: Population-level data from the Child and Family Court Advisory and Support Service (CAFCASS) was used for the initial analysis of the scale and patterns of fathers' involvement.
  • Father Survey Data: 127 surveys completed by fathers and 106 paired surveys completed by practitioners.
  • Qualitative Longitudinal (QL) Study Data: In-depth interview and contact data from 26 recurrent fathers, with complete or near-complete data for 23.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study built upon existing research on mothers and recurrence.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond the "Missing Father" Narrative: While some fathers are indeed "missing" (indicated by lone mothers reappearing in proceedings), a significant group of recurrent fathers are visible to the court.
  • Enduring Relationships Matter: A substantial portion of recurrent fathers are in long-term, "enduring" relationships, often with the same partner. These relationships, while sometimes fraught, are central to their lives and parenting.
  • Childhood Adversity as a Foundation: Recurrent fathers frequently have histories of significant childhood adversity, including neglect, abuse, parental separation, and instability, which profoundly shape their adult lives and parenting capacity.
  • Cumulative Disadvantage: The challenges faced by recurrent fathers are often cumulative, stemming from early life adversities that cascade into economic hardship, mental health issues, substance misuse, and difficulties in forming stable relationships.
  • "Couple Jeopardy": Local authority approaches can inadvertently create "couple jeopardy," forcing difficult decisions about separation that may not align with the couple's desire to stay together, potentially exacerbating their challenges.

Key Results

  • Demographics: Recurrent fathers are predominantly White British, English-speaking, non-religious, and often become fathers at a younger age, experiencing economic hardship.
  • Childhood Adversity: Around half of recurrent fathers experienced abuse and/or neglect in childhood. A significant portion (37%) experienced "multiple issue" adversities, such as direct physical abuse or parental mental health/substance misuse issues.
  • Economic Disadvantage: Over half of fathers surveyed were unemployed or economically inactive. Recurrent fathers showed a higher rate of unemployment (69%).
  • Health Vulnerabilities: Physical, mental, and emotional health issues are prevalent. Over half (53%) reported daily lives affected by emotional stress. Child welfare concerns directly related to fathers included domestic violence (52%), drug misuse (37%), and poor mental health (26%).
  • Relationship Patterns: The majority of recurrent fathers reappear before the court with the same partner (79%).
  • QL Study Findings: The 26 recurrent fathers in the QL study reported extensive childhood adversity, chronic health issues, substance misuse, and often had learning disabilities or cognitive/behavioral conditions. Domestic violence concerns were raised for 14 fathers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Representativeness: The study acknowledges that the samples, particularly for the QL study, may not fully represent the most marginalized recurrent fathers, as participants needed to be visible or engaged with support services to be recruited.
  • Statistical Modeling: The survey sample size (127) limited the ability to conduct advanced statistical modeling, though an appropriate power analysis was conducted.
  • Causality: The study notes that while there's an association between childhood adversity and recurrent care proceedings, it does not establish a straightforward causal link.
  • Future Work: The authors advocate for the development of bespoke or adapted services for recurrent fathers and couples, moving beyond mother-centered approaches. This includes focusing on emotional regulation, building emotional and relational resources, and exploring the generative potential of fatherhood. They emphasize the need for a gender-sensitive approach to understanding and responding to recurrence, ensuring fathers are held equally accountable while receiving appropriate support. The need for sustainable resourcing for such services is also highlighted.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article presents data from the first large-scale study of fathers involved in repeat (or recurrent) care proceedings in England. The project complements important research on mothers and recurrence. It consisted of three elements: an analysis of population-level administrative data from the Child and Family Court Advisory and Support Service (CAFCASS), a survey of fathers in pre-proceedings and care proceedings, and a qualitative longitudinal (QL) study of recurrent fathers. Here we report findings from the survey and the QL study, offering an expanded definition and description of fathers and recurrence. Elsewhere, we reported that a significant number of fathers appear in recurrent care proceedings and that the majority return with the same partner. Alongside this, there is also a notable pattern of “missing” fathers demonstrated by the proportion of lone mothers reappearing before the court. Our survey indicates a certain profile of recurrent fathers, but also that recurrent fathers are not straightforwardly a homogenous group. We report on the significance of recurrent fathers’ early lives, on the phenomenon of enduring couple relationships and on the prevalence of issues affecting parenting, such as poor mental health, substance use and domestic abuse. Insights from the QL study in particular reveal legacies of harm, loss, and a lack of emotional and relational resources in childhood, which have debilitating and far-reaching consequences. We argue the importance of understanding the vulnerabilities of recurrent fathers and of challenging certain assumptions in child welfare and family justice practices. There is much to be learnt from existing services for recurrent mothers, but also a need for bespoke or adapted services that may be more responsive to particular circumstances of recurrent fathers and couples.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{philip2020i,
  author = {Georgia Philip and Lindsay Youansamouth and Stuart Bedston and Karen Broadhurst and Yang Hu and John Clifton and Marian Brandon},
  title = {{“I Had No Hope, I Had No Help at All”: Insights from a First Study of Fathers and Recurrent Care Proceedings}},
  booktitle = {Societies},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/soc10040089},
}
Figure