De novo assembly of 64 haplotype-resolved human genomes of diverse ancestry and integrated analysis of structural variation

Peter Ebert, Peter A. Audano, Qihui Zhu, Bernardo Rodríguez–Martín, David Porubský, Marc Jan Bonder, Arvis Sulovari, Jana Ebler, Weichen Zhou, Rebecca Serra Mari, Feyza Yilmaz, Xuefang Zhao, PingHsun Hsieh, Joyce Lee, Sushant Kumar, Jiadong Lin, Tobias Rausch, Yu Chen, Jingwen Ren, Martín Santamarina, Wolfram Höps, Hufsah Ashraf, Nelson T. Chuang, Xiaofei Yang, Katherine M. Munson, Alexandra P. Lewis, Susan Fairley, Luke J. Tallon, Wayne E. Clarke, Anna O. Basile, Marta Byrska-Bishop, André Corvelo, Mark Chaisson, Junjie Chen, Chong Li, Harrison Brand, Aaron M. Wenger, Maryam Ghareghani, William T. Harvey, Benjamin Raeder, Patrick Hasenfeld, Allison Regier, Haley Abel, Ira M. Hall, Paul Flicek, Oliver Stegle, Mark Gerstein, José M. C. Tubío, Zepeng Mu, Yang Li, Xinghua Shi, Alex Hastie, Kai Ye, Zechen Chong, Ashley D. Sanders, Michael C. Zody, Michael E. Talkowski, Ryan E. Mills, Scott E. Devine, Charles Lee, Jan O. Korbel, Tobias Marschall, Evan E. EichlerbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first large-scale, haplotype-resolved assembly of 64 human genomes from diverse ancestries, revealing a wealth of structural variations (SVs) previously hidden by short-read sequencing. This comprehensive resource enables more accurate SV genotyping and opens new avenues for understanding human genetic variation, disease associations, and evolutionary history.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the full spectrum of human genetic variation is crucial for deciphering disease mechanisms and evolutionary processes. However, short-read sequencing technologies, while cost-effective, struggle to accurately resolve complex genomic regions, particularly structural variants (SVs) like insertions, deletions, inversions, and translocations. These SVs, especially those in repetitive regions, are often missed or collapsed in standard analyses, leading to an incomplete picture of human genetic diversity. Previous efforts to assemble human genomes often relied on parent-child trios, limiting scalability and diversity. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a method for de novo assembly of haplotype-resolved genomes without trio data, enabling a more comprehensive and accurate discovery of SVs across diverse populations.

Methods

The core of this work lies in the Phased Assembly Genome Assembly (PGAS) pipeline, which leverages long-read sequencing (PacBio CLR and HiFi) and Strand-seq data. Strand-seq is a key orthogonal technology that provides chromosome-specific strand information, allowing for the phasing of heterozygous variants and the resolution of complex genomic structures. The PGAS pipeline first generates a "squashed" long-read assembly, then clusters contigs into chromosome-specific groups using Strand-seq signals. Single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) are called relative to these clusters, and then integrated with global Strand-seq information for chromosome-wide phasing. This process allows for the tagging of individual long reads to specific haplotypes, enabling the construction of fully phased diploid genome assemblies.

For variant discovery, the authors developed the Phased Assembly Variant (PAV) caller, which directly compares the two assembled haplotypes to the human reference genome (GRCh38) to identify SNVs, indels, and SVs. They also integrated optical mapping data (Bionano Genomics) and other short-read callers for comprehensive validation and discovery.

For genotyping across a larger population, they employed PanGenie, a graph-based method that leverages the assembled reference haplotypes to genotype short-read data from the 1000 Genomes Project (1000GP). This allows for the accurate inference of SV genotypes in individuals whose genomes were not de novo assembled.

Datasets

The study utilized several key datasets:

  • 32 diverse human genomes: These were de novo sequenced using long-read technologies (PacBio CLR and HiFi). The set included representatives from various 1000GP populations, aiming for broad ancestral diversity.
  • Three parent-child trios: These were sequenced to validate phasing accuracy.
  • Publicly available sequencing data: Data from NA12878 and HG002/NA24385 (Genome in a Bottle effort) were included for analysis.
  • 1000 Genomes Project (1000GP) data: Deeply sequenced short-read data from 3,202 individuals were used for genotyping and population-level analyses.
  • Simons Genome Diversity Project (SGDP) data: Used for ancestry and population genetic analyses.
  • RNA-seq data: From 34 lymphoblastoid cell lines and 397 transcriptomes from 1000GP samples were used for eQTL analysis.

No new benchmarks were explicitly introduced, but the study's output (64 phased haplotypes) serves as a new, high-quality resource for SV discovery and analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Trio-free haplotype resolution is achievable at scale: The PGAS pipeline demonstrates that high-quality, haplotype-resolved genome assemblies can be generated without the need for parent-child trios, significantly increasing the feasibility of studying diverse populations.
  • Long reads unlock previously inaccessible SVs: The study highlights that a substantial proportion (68%) of identified SVs were inaccessible by short-read sequencing alone, underscoring the power of long reads for comprehensive variant discovery.
  • Homology-mediated mechanisms are dominant SV drivers: A surprising finding is that 63% of SVs are attributed to homology-mediated mechanisms (like NAHR), a twofold increase compared to previous estimates, suggesting these processes are more prevalent than previously thought.
  • SVs are key drivers of gene expression variation: The identification of 1,525 SV-eQTLs demonstrates that structural variants play a significant role in regulating gene expression, offering new insights into the functional impact of SVs.
  • African genomes are a deep reservoir of structural variation: The analysis revealed that African populations harbor the greatest diversity of structural variation, emphasizing the need for continued inclusion of diverse ancestries in genomic studies.

Key Results

  • 64 haplotype-resolved human genomes: The study successfully assembled 64 highly contiguous haplotypes (average contig N50: 26 Mbp) from 32 diverse human genomes.
  • 107,590 structural variants (SVs) identified: This comprehensive callset includes a significant number of novel SVs, with 68% being inaccessible by short-read sequencing.
  • Identification of new SV hotspots: The research identified new SV hotspots, some spanning megabases of gene-rich sequence.
  • Characterization of mobile element source elements: 130 active mobile element source elements were characterized.
  • 1,525 SV-eQTLs identified: This links structural variants to gene expression changes, providing a resource for functional genomics and disease association studies.
  • High accuracy of assemblies: Phased genomes achieved base-pair level accuracy (QV > 40) and high contiguity (contig N50 > 25 Mbp).
  • Improved SV discovery in African populations: The addition of African samples more than doubled the rate of new variant discovery compared to non-Africans.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Remaining assembly gaps: Despite advances, some repetitive regions (centromeres, segmental duplications) remain challenging to fully resolve even with long-read sequencing.
  • Genotyping limitations: Approximately 50% of the discovered SVs could be reliably genotyped in short-read data using PanGenie, indicating room for improvement in genotyping algorithms for complex SVs.
  • Challenges with multiallelic VNTRs/STRs and large repeats: These regions remain problematic for accurate genotyping and require further methodological development.

The authors suggest that future work should focus on expanding the number of assembly-based haplotypes to create more comprehensive pangenomic references. They also highlight the promise of combining HiFi and ultra-long-read Oxford Nanopore data for resolving complex genomic regions. Continued efforts in understanding human genome diversity, particularly from underrepresented populations, are crucial for a complete picture of structural variation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Long-read and strand-specific sequencing technologies together facilitate the de novo assembly of high-quality haplotype-resolved human genomes without parent–child trio data. We present 64 assembled haplotypes from 32 diverse human genomes. These highly contiguous haplotype assemblies (average contig N50: 26 Mbp) integrate all forms of genetic variation across even complex loci such as the major histocompatibility complex. We focus on 107,590 structural variants (SVs), of which 68% are inaccessible by short-read sequencing. We identify new SV hotspots (spanning megabases of gene-rich sequence), characterize 130 of the most active mobile element source elements, and find that 63% of all SVs arise by homology-mediated mechanisms—a twofold increase from previous studies. Our resource now enables reliable graph-based genotyping from short reads of up to 50,340 SVs, resulting in the identification of 1,525 expression quantitative trait loci (SV-eQTLs) as well as SV candidates for adaptive selection within the human population.
BibTeX
@misc{ebert2020i,
  author = {Peter Ebert and Peter A. Audano and Qihui Zhu and Bernardo Rodríguez–Martín and David Porubský and Marc Jan Bonder and Arvis Sulovari and Jana Ebler and Weichen Zhou and Rebecca Serra Mari and Feyza Yilmaz and Xuefang Zhao and PingHsun Hsieh and Joyce Lee and Sushant Kumar and Jiadong Lin and Tobias Rausch and Yu Chen and Jingwen Ren and Martín Santamarina and Wolfram Höps and Hufsah Ashraf and Nelson T. Chuang and Xiaofei Yang and Katherine M. Munson and Alexandra P. Lewis and Susan Fairley and Luke J. Tallon and Wayne E. Clarke and Anna O. Basile and Marta Byrska-Bishop and André Corvelo and Mark Chaisson and Junjie Chen and Chong Li and Harrison Brand and Aaron M. Wenger and Maryam Ghareghani and William T. Harvey and Benjamin Raeder and Patrick Hasenfeld and Allison Regier and Haley Abel and Ira M. Hall and Paul Flicek and Oliver Stegle and Mark Gerstein and José M. C. Tubío and Zepeng Mu and Yang Li and Xinghua Shi and Alex Hastie and Kai Ye and Zechen Chong and Ashley D. Sanders and Michael C. Zody and Michael E. Talkowski and Ryan E. Mills and Scott E. Devine and Charles Lee and Jan O. Korbel and Tobias Marschall and Evan E. Eichler},
  title = {{<i>De novo</i> assembly of 64 haplotype-resolved human genomes of diverse ancestry and integrated analysis of structural variation}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.12.16.423102},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure