De novo assembly of 20 chickens reveals the undetectable phenomenon for thousands of core genes on sub-telomeric regions

Ming Li, Congjiao Sun, Naiyi Xu, Peipei Bian, Xiaomeng Tian, Xihong Wang, Yuzhe Wang, Xinzheng Jia, Rasmus Heller, Mingshan Wang, Fei Wang, Xuelei Dai, Rongsong Luo, Yingwei Guo, Xiangnan Wang, Peng Yang, Shunjin Zhang, Xiaochang Li, Chaoliang Wen, Fangren Lan, Amam Zonaed Siddiki, Chatmongkon Suwannapoom, Xin Zhao, Qinghua Nie, Xiaoxiang Hu, Yu Jiang, Ning YangbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study constructs the first comprehensive chicken pan-genome from 20 diverse breeds, uncovering over 1,300 previously "missing" protein-coding genes and 3,000 noncoding RNAs. These genes, often found in challenging repetitive regions, are crucial for understanding avian evolution and immune function, suggesting that the chicken genome is more complex than previously thought.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For a long time, bird genomes have been perceived as having fewer genes and slower evolutionary rates compared to mammals. This has been a puzzling observation given the incredible diversity of birds. Previous attempts to fully characterize avian genomes have been hampered by challenges in sequencing and assembling certain genomic regions, leading to the assumption that many genes were lost during avian evolution. This paper aims to resolve this discrepancy by building a more complete picture of the chicken genome through a pan-genome approach, specifically targeting regions that have been historically difficult to sequence.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-platform sequencing strategy, combining PacBio and Illumina data from 20 different chicken breeds to achieve high sequencing depth. They then used a sophisticated bioinformatics pipeline for de novo genome assembly, meaning they built the genome from scratch without relying solely on a pre-existing reference. Crucially, they integrated Hi-C data to help scaffold and organize the assembled contigs into chromosome-level structures. To identify novel sequences, they aligned their assemblies against the existing reference genome (GRCg6a) and extracted unaligned or low-identity regions. These novel sequences were then rigorously validated using transcriptomic data from multiple tissues and by comparing them to other avian and vertebrate genomes. They also utilized advanced techniques like tandem mass spectrometry to confirm the presence of proteins encoded by these novel genes.

Datasets

The study utilized genomic DNA from 20 diverse chicken individuals representing various breeds from different continents. Transcriptome data from 11 tissues of six individuals were also used. Additionally, they incorporated publicly available chicken resequencing data (922 individuals) and data from other Galliformes genomes for validation. For comparative genomics, they used genome assemblies from a range of other species, including mammals, reptiles, and birds.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Missing" Genes Are Real: A significant number of genes previously thought to be lost in avian evolution are actually present but were "hidden" in difficult-to-sequence regions.
  • Sub-telomeric Regions are Gene-Rich Hotspots: Many of these newly identified genes are concentrated in sub-telomeric regions, which are known for their high repeat content and complex DNA structures.
  • Repetitive DNA is a Major Hurdle: The high proportion of tandem repeats and noncanonical DNA structures (like G-quadruplexes) in these regions significantly impedes DNA sequencing and assembly.
  • Elevated Evolutionary Rates: These novel genes exhibit a significantly higher substitution rate compared to previously known genes, suggesting a more dynamic evolutionary history for birds than previously assumed.
  • Immune System Significance: A substantial portion of these novel genes are involved in essential biological functions, particularly in the immune system, highlighting their importance in avian health and disease resistance.

Key Results

  • 1,335 novel protein-coding genes and 3,011 novel long noncoding RNAs were identified.
  • The chicken pan-genome expanded the size of the reference genome by 14.92%.
  • 79.13% of the novel sequences were characterized by a high content of tandem repeats.
  • Novel genes showed a three-fold elevated substitution rate compared to known genes.
  • 176 novel coding genes were identified as housekeeping genes in humans and mice.
  • A significant number of novel genes were found to be involved in metabolism, signal transduction, and the immune system.
  • The study identified 21 novel coding genes and 7 partially missing coding genes related to the NF-κB signaling pathway, crucial for immune response.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that despite their comprehensive approach, some genes may still be hidden in extremely complex genomic regions. They suggest that further improvements in sequencing technologies and assembly algorithms are needed to fully resolve these challenging areas. The study provides a framework for future research into avian evolution, functional genomics, and poultry breeding, emphasizing the importance of exploring these cryptic regions in other species as well.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The gene numbers and evolutionary rates of birds were assumed to be much lower than that of mammals, which in sharp contrast to the huge species number and morphological diversity of birds. It is very necessary to construct a complete avian genome and analyze its evolution.We constructed a chicken pan-genome from 20 de novo genome assemblies with high sequencing depth, newly identified 1,335 protein-coding genes and 3,011 long noncoding RNAs. The majority of these novel genes were detected across most individuals of the examined transcriptomes but were accidentally measured in each of the DNA sequencing data regardless of Illumina or PacBio technology. Furthermore, different from previous pan-genome models, most of these novel genes were overrepresented on chromosomal sub-telomeric regions, surrounded with extremely high proportions of tandem repeats, and strongly blocked DNA sequencing. These hidden genes were proved to be shared by all chicken genomes, included many housekeeping genes, and enriched in immune pathways. Comparative genomics revealed the novel genes had three-fold elevated substitution rates than known ones, updating the evolutionary rates of birds. Our study provides a framework for constructing a better chicken genome, which will contribute towards the understanding of avian evolution and improvement of poultry breeding.
BibTeX
@misc{li2021i,
  author = {Ming Li and Congjiao Sun and Naiyi Xu and Peipei Bian and Xiaomeng Tian and Xihong Wang and Yuzhe Wang and Xinzheng Jia and Rasmus Heller and Mingshan Wang and Fei Wang and Xuelei Dai and Rongsong Luo and Yingwei Guo and Xiangnan Wang and Peng Yang and Shunjin Zhang and Xiaochang Li and Chaoliang Wen and Fangren Lan and AMAM Zonaed Siddiki and Chatmongkon Suwannapoom and Xin Zhao and Qinghua Nie and Xiaoxiang Hu and Yu Jiang and Ning Yang},
  title = {{<i>De novo</i> assembly of 20 chickens reveals the undetectable phenomenon for thousands of core genes on sub-telomeric regions}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.11.05.467060},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure