De novo analysis of bulk RNA-seq data at spatially resolved single-cell resolution

Jie Liao, Jingyang Qian, Fang Yin, Zhuo Chen, Xiang Zhuang, Ningyu Zhang, Xin Shao, Yining Hu, Penghui Yang, Junyun Cheng, Yang Hu, Lingqi Yu, Haihong Yang, Jinlu Zhang, Xiaoyan Lu, Li Shao, Dan Wu, Yue Gao, Huajun Chen, Xiaohui FanbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Bulk2Space, a novel deep learning framework that deconvolves bulk RNA-seq data to reveal single-cell resolution spatial and cellular heterogeneity. By leveraging existing single-cell and spatial transcriptomics data, Bulk2Space reconstructs detailed tissue architectures, identifies cell type variations within tissues, and discovers novel gene expression patterns, offering a powerful new tool for biological and clinical research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the intricate molecular makeup of tissues at the single-cell level is crucial for deciphering biological and pathological processes. However, traditional bulk RNA-seq, while widely used, averages gene expression across all cells in a sample, obscuring the unique transcriptional profiles and spatial organization of individual cell types. Existing spatially resolved transcriptomics methods, while offering spatial information, often have limitations in gene coverage or resolution. This leaves a significant gap in our ability to fully characterize tissue complexity from readily available bulk RNA-seq data. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a computational method that can infer single-cell resolution spatial information from bulk RNA-seq data.

Methods

Bulk2Space employs a two-step deep learning approach:

  1. Deconvolution: The algorithm first estimates the proportions of different cell types within the bulk RNA-seq data. It uses a constrained variational autoencoder (β-VAE) to generate synthetic single-cell profiles that mimic the observed bulk data, effectively transforming bulk transcriptomes into single-cell transcriptome data. This step leverages existing single-cell RNA-seq (scRNA-seq) data as a reference for cell type gene expression.
  2. Spatial Mapping: The generated single-cell profiles are then mapped to spatial coordinates. This is achieved by using either spatial barcoding-based (e.g., ST, Slide-seq) or image-based (e.g., MERFISH) spatial transcriptomics data as a reference. Bulk2Space employs specific strategies for each type of spatial reference to assign cells to their likely locations within the tissue. For spatial barcoding, it assigns cells to spots based on gene expression correlation, while for image-based methods, it maps cells to locations based on similarity in gene expression.

Datasets

The study utilized a variety of datasets for training and validation:

  • scRNA-seq datasets: Ten scRNA-seq datasets were used for benchmarking, including human datasets (peripheral blood, brain, kidney, liver, lung) and mouse datasets (brain, kidney, lung, pancreas, testis).
  • Spatial transcriptomics data:
    • Mouse hypothalamus MERFISH data was used for image-based spatial mapping.
  • Human PDAC, human melanoma, and human prostate cancer data were used for spatial barcoding-based methods.
  • Bulk RNA-seq data:
    • Mouse hypothalamus data from the authors' in-house Spatial-seq protocol.
  • Human prostate cancer RNA-seq data from TCGA.

The paper also describes the synthesis of bulk transcriptome data from scRNA-seq data for benchmarking purposes, creating 40 paired simulated datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the gap: The core innovation is the ability to infer single-cell resolution spatial information from bulk RNA-seq, a task previously unachievable without dedicated spatial technologies.
  • Leveraging existing data: Bulk2Space effectively integrates readily available scRNA-seq and spatial transcriptomics data to deconvolve bulk data, making it broadly applicable.
  • Uncovering hidden heterogeneity: The method can reveal spatial variations in cell type abundance and gene expression that are masked in bulk data, leading to a more nuanced understanding of tissue organization.
  • Re-annotating ambiguous cells: In cases where spatial transcriptomics methods have limited gene coverage, Bulk2Space can help re-annotate and spatially assign ambiguous cells.
  • Discovering novel spatial patterns: The algorithm can predict the spatial expression of novel genes, expanding our understanding beyond targeted gene panels.

Key Results

  • Robust performance: Bulk2Space demonstrated robust performance across multiple datasets and conditions, outperforming other deep learning models (GAN, CGAN) in gene expression correlation and RMSE for single-cell profile generation.
  • Accurate spatial mapping: The method achieved high correlation with ground truth for cell composition and spatial expression patterns in benchmark tests.
  • Biological insights:
    • In tumor regions, Bulk2Space revealed spatial variance of immune cells.
  • It elucidated molecular and spatial heterogeneity in tissues during inflammation-induced tumorigenesis.
  • It identified spatial patterns of novel genes in different cell types.
  • In PDAC and melanoma studies, Bulk2Space successfully integrated spatial gene expression with histomorphology, revealing distinct spatial distributions of cell types and their associated functions.
  • In mouse hypothalamus analysis, Bulk2Space successfully reconstructed hierarchical structures and annotated cell types not identified by original methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dependence on reference data: The performance of Bulk2Space is dependent on the availability and quality of scRNA-seq and spatial transcriptomics reference data.
  • Technical bottlenecks: While Bulk2Space addresses some limitations of existing spatial technologies, it inherits some of their inherent constraints (e.g., gene coverage in image-based methods).
  • Future work: The authors suggest that Bulk2Space has great biological and clinical application prospects, including linking tissue molecular characteristics with histological phenotypes, revealing spatial cell variation, discovering novel gene expression patterns, achieving refined cell clustering, and uncovering molecular mechanisms underlying disease progression. The open-source nature of the package encourages further development and application.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Uncovering the tissue molecular architecture at single-cell resolution could help better understand organisms’ biological and pathological processes. However, bulk RNA-seq can only measure gene expression in cell mixtures, without revealing the transcriptional heterogeneity and spatial patterns of single cells. Herein, we introduce Bulk2Space ( https://github.com/ZJUFanLab/bulk2space ), a deep learning framework-based spatial deconvolution algorithm that can simultaneously disclose the spatial and cellular heterogeneity of bulk RNA-seq data using existing single-cell and spatial transcriptomics references. The use of bulk transcriptomics to validate Bulk2Space unveils, in particular, the spatial variance of immune cells in different tumor regions, the molecular and spatial heterogeneity of tissues during inflammation-induced tumorigenesis, and spatial patterns of novel genes in different cell types. Moreover, Bulk2Space is utilized to perform spatial deconvolution analysis on bulk transcriptome data from two different mouse brain regions derived from our in-house developed sequencing approach termed Spatial-seq. We have not only reconstructed the hierarchical structure of the mouse isocortex but also further annotated cell types that were not identified by original methods in the mouse hypothalamus.
BibTeX
@misc{liao2022i,
  author = {Jie Liao and Jingyang Qian and Fang Yin and Zhuo Chen and Xiang Zhuang and Ningyu Zhang and Xin Shao and Yining Hu and Penghui Yang and Junyun Cheng and Yang Hu and Lingqi Yu and Haihong Yang and Jinlu Zhang and Xiaoyan Lu and Li Shao and Dan Wu and Yue Gao and Huajun Chen and Xiaohui Fan},
  title = {{<i>De novo</i> analysis of bulk RNA-seq data at spatially resolved single-cell resolution}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.01.15.476472},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure