Cyfip1 Haploinsufficiency Increases Compulsive-Like Behavior and Modulates Palatable Food Intake in Mice: Dependence on Cyfip2 Genetic Background, Parent-of Origin, and Sex

R.k. Babbs, Jacob A. Beierle, Qiu T. Ruan, Julia C. Kelliher, Melanie M. Chen, Ashley X Feng, Stacey L. Kirkpatrick, Fabiola A Benitez, Fred A Rodriguez, Johanne Pierre, Jeya Anandakumar, Vivek Kumar, Megan K. Mulligan, Camron D. BryantG3 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that a deficiency in the gene Cyfip1 in mice can lead to increased compulsive-like behaviors and altered consumption of palatable foods. These effects are surprisingly complex, depending not only on the genetic background of the mouse but also on whether the gene deficiency was inherited from the mother or father, and the sex of the animal. This work sheds light on the intricate genetic underpinnings of eating disorders and neurodevelopmental conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Binge eating (BE) and related eating disorders are complex, heritable conditions with significant public health implications. While genetic factors are known to play a role, identifying specific genes and understanding their mechanisms has been challenging. Previous research by the authors identified Cyfip2 as a potential genetic contributor to compulsive-like BE in mice. This paper delves deeper by investigating Cyfip1, a gene closely related to Cyfip2. Cyfip1 is particularly interesting because it's located in a region of chromosome 15 that is often deleted in Prader-Willi Syndrome (PWS), a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by hyperphagia (excessive eating) and obsessive-compulsive behaviors. The authors aim to understand how a partial deficiency (haploinsufficiency) of Cyfip1 affects compulsive-like behavior and palatable food intake, and crucially, whether these effects are influenced by the genetic background of the mouse, the parent from which the deficiency is inherited (parent-of-origin effect), and the sex of the animal.

Methods

The researchers utilized a multi-pronged approach involving mouse models and behavioral assays.

  • Genetic Manipulation: They generated mice with a partial deficiency (haploinsufficiency) of the Cyfip1 gene. These mice were then bred onto two distinct genetic backgrounds: a "BE-prone" background (Cyfip2<sup>N/N</sup>) and a "BE-resistant" background (Cyfip2<sup>J/J</sup>).
  • Parent-of-Origin Crosses: To investigate parent-of-origin effects, they performed specific crosses where the Cyfip1 deficiency could be inherited from either the mother or the father.
  • Behavioral Testing: A battery of tests was employed to assess:
  • Premorbid Compulsive-like and Anxiety-like Behaviors: Tests like marble burying and hole board exploration were used to evaluate these behaviors before any specific food intake training.
  • Palatable Food (PF) Intake and Binge Eating Paradigm: Mice were trained to consume palatable food (e.g., high-fat, high-sugar) using a conditioned place preference (CPP) paradigm to assess their motivation and consumption patterns.
  • Light/Dark Conflict Test: This test was used to assess compulsive-like food intake in a novel environment.
  • Molecular Analysis:
    • Quantitative PCR (qPCR): Gene expression levels of Cyfip1, Cyfip2, and Magel2 were measured in the hypothalamus, a brain region critical for appetite regulation.
  • Immunoblotting: Protein levels of CYFIP1 and FMRP (Fragile X Mental Retardation Protein, a known interactor of CYFIP proteins) were assessed in the hypothalamus and nucleus accumbens (a brain region involved in reward).

Datasets

This study did not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it utilized established mouse models and behavioral paradigms to investigate gene function. The primary "dataset" generated was the behavioral and molecular data collected from the genetically modified mice.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cyfip1 is a player in compulsive behavior: Even without specific food training, Cyfip1 haploinsufficiency led to increased marble burying, a behavior often associated with compulsive tendencies. This suggests a general role for Cyfip1 in regulating these behaviors.
  • The genetic background matters immensely: The impact of Cyfip1 deficiency on palatable food intake was dramatically different depending on the Cyfip2 genetic background. On the "BE-prone" background, Cyfip1 haploinsufficiency increased palatable food intake.
  • Parent-of-origin effects are potent and surprising: In a particularly striking finding, on the "BE-resistant" background, maternal inheritance of the Cyfip1 deficiency led to increased palatable food intake in wild-type males (males without the Cyfip1 deficiency themselves). This suggests that maternal factors can influence the behavior of genetically unaffected offspring.
  • Sex differences are critical: The study consistently found sex-specific effects, particularly on the Cyfip2<sup>J/J</sup> background, where maternal Cyfip1 deficiency impacted males differently than females.
  • Dissociation of compulsive behavior and food intake: While Cyfip1 haploinsufficiency consistently increased compulsive-like behaviors, its effect on palatable food intake was highly context-dependent, suggesting these two aspects of eating disorders might be regulated by partially distinct mechanisms.
  • Brain region-specific protein changes: CYFIP1 protein levels were reduced in the hypothalamus and nucleus accumbens, but these reductions showed parent-of-origin specificity (paternal in the hypothalamus, maternal in the nucleus accumbens), hinting at complex regulatory mechanisms.

Key Results

  • Cyfip1 haploinsufficient mice (Cyfip1<sup>+/-</sup>) showed increased compulsive-like behavior (marble burying) on both Cyfip2<sup>N/N</sup> and Cyfip2<sup>J/J</sup> backgrounds.
  • On the Cyfip2<sup>N/N</sup> background, Cyfip1<sup>+/-</sup> mice exhibited increased palatable food (PF) intake.
  • On the Cyfip2<sup>J/J</sup> background, maternal inheritance of Cyfip1 haploinsufficiency led to a significant escalation of PF intake in wild-type males, while Cyfip1<sup>+/-</sup> males on this background did not show this effect.
  • Cyfip1 haploinsufficiency led to reduced CYFIP1 protein in the hypothalamus (paternally-enhanced) and nucleus accumbens (maternally-enhanced).
  • No changes in FMRP protein were observed in Cyfip1<sup>+/-</sup> mice.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while they observed parent-of-origin effects, the precise mechanism for these non-imprinted gene effects is not fully elucidated. They suggest that interactions with imprinted loci or sex chromosome effects could be involved. Future work could explore these possibilities using more advanced genetic models (e.g., the "four core genotypes" model) to dissect the roles of sex chromosomes. Further research into the specific brain circuits and molecular pathways affected by Cyfip1 haploinsufficiency, particularly in relation to the hedonic aspects of food intake, is also warranted. Understanding these complex interactions could have significant implications for developing targeted therapies for neurodevelopmental and psychiatric disorders associated with eating behaviors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Binge eating (BE) is a heritable trait associated with eating disorders and involves episodes of rapid, large amounts of food consumption. We previously identified cytoplasmic FMR1-interacting protein 2 (<i>Cyfip2</i>) as a genetic factor underlying compulsive-like BE in mice. <i>CYFIP2</i> is a homolog of <i>CYFIP1</i> which is one of four paternally-deleted genes in patients with Type I Prader-Willi Syndrome (PWS), a neurodevelopmental disorder whereby 70% of cases involve paternal 15q11-q13 deletion. PWS symptoms include hyperphagia, obesity (if untreated), cognitive deficits, and obsessive-compulsive behaviors. We tested whether <i>Cyfip1</i> haploinsufficiency (+/-) would enhance compulsive-like behavior and palatable food (PF) intake in a parental origin- and sex-dependent manner on two <i>Cyfip2</i> genetic backgrounds, including the BE-prone C57BL/6N (<i>Cyfip2</i><sup>N/N</sup>) background and the BE-resistant C57BL/6J (<i>Cyfip2</i><sup>J/J</sup>) background. <i>Cyfip1</i><sup>+/-</sup> mice showed increased compulsive-like behavior on both backgrounds and increased PF intake on the <i>Cyfip2</i><sup>N/N</sup> background. In contrast, maternal <i>Cyfip1</i> haploinsufficiency on the BE-resistant <i>Cyfip2</i><sup>J/J</sup> background induced a robust escalation in PF intake in wild-type <i>Cyfip1</i><sup>J/J</sup> males while having no effect in <i>Cyfip1</i><sup>J/-</sup> males. Notably, induction of behavioral phenotypes in wild-type males following maternal <i>Fmr1</i><sup>+/-</sup> has previously been reported. In the hypothalamus, there was a paternally-enhanced reduction in CYFIP1 protein whereas in the nucleus accumbens, there was a maternally-enhanced reduction in CYFIP1 protein. Nochange in FMR1 protein (FMRP) was observed in <i>Cyfip1</i><sup>+/-</sup> mice, regardless of parental origin. To summarize, <i>Cyfip1</i> haploinsufficiency increased compulsive-like behavior and induced genetic background-dependent, sex-dependent, and parent-of-origin-dependent effects on PF consumption and CYFIP1 expression that could have relevance for neurodevelopmental and neuropsychiatric disorders.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{babbs2019i,
  author = {R.K. Babbs and Jacob A. Beierle and Qiu T. Ruan and Julia C. Kelliher and Melanie M. Chen and Ashley X Feng and Stacey L. Kirkpatrick and Fabiola A Benitez and Fred A Rodriguez and Johanne Pierre and Jeya Anandakumar and Vivek Kumar and Megan K. Mulligan and Camron D. Bryant},
  title = {{<i>Cyfip1</i> Haploinsufficiency Increases Compulsive-Like Behavior and Modulates Palatable Food Intake in Mice: Dependence on <i>Cyfip2</i> Genetic Background, Parent-of Origin, and Sex}},
  booktitle = {G3},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1534/g3.119.400470},
}
Figure