I. Additional researches on the electrolysis of secondary compounds

John Frederic Daniell, William Allen MillerPhilosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 1844 · DOI

This 1844 paper by J. Frederic Daniell and W. A. Miller represents a pivotal moment in the history of electrochemistry. Published in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, it moves beyond Michael Faraday’s foundational laws to explore the behavior of "complex electrolytes"—salts containing compound radicals like phosphates and ferrocyanides. The authors provide early evidence that ions do not always travel at equal rates through a solution, a discovery that would eventually lead to the modern concept of transport numbers.

TL;DR

Daniell and Miller demonstrate that complex chemical groups (like $PO_4$) travel through solutions as single "compound ions" during electrolysis. Crucially, they discover that different ions move at different rates, challenging the then-prevailing assumption that anions and cations always contribute equally to the transfer of electricity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the mid-19th century, the "molecular hypothesis" of electrolysis (illustrated in Figure 1) assumed that when a current passed through a salt, the anion and cation moved in equal and opposite steps to their respective electrodes.

Diagram illustrating the then-standard hypothesis of equal ion transfer, which the authors' data ultimately challenged.

While Faraday had established the law of equivalents (that the amount of chemical change is proportional to the current), the internal mechanics of how these ions moved remained opaque. Daniell and Miller sought to determine:

  1. Do compound radicals (like the different forms of phosphoric acid) stay together during transit?
  2. Does the "transfer" of matter across a cell always happen in equal halves (0.5 equivalent of anion moving one way, 0.5 equivalent of cation the other)?

Methods

The authors utilized a sophisticated double diaphragm cell (Figures 2 and 3). This apparatus allowed them to divide the electrolytic cell into three distinct compartments: the zincode (anode) cell, the platinode (cathode) cell, and a center cell.

The double diaphragm cell used to isolate electrolysis products.

By analyzing the chemical composition of each compartment after passing a measured amount of current (tracked by an independent gas voltameter), they could determine not just what was released at the electrodes, but how much of each component had actually migrated across the diaphragms. They tested a wide range of substances, including tribasic phosphates, ferrocyanides, and double sulphates of metals like copper, aluminum, and potassium.

Datasets

As a mid-19th-century experimental paper, there are no "datasets" in the modern computational sense. Instead, the authors provide detailed quantitative results from dozens of individual experiments using various aqueous solutions and fused salts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Confirmation of Graham’s Phosphate Theory: The authors proved that the three hydrates of phosphoric acid (ortho, pyro, and meta) travel as three distinct "oxyphosphions." This provided independent physical evidence for Thomas Graham's purely chemical theories on polybasic acids.
  • The "Stationary" Ion Phenomenon: In one of the paper's most surprising findings, the authors observed that while potassium and sodium ions migrate readily, other metals like copper, magnesium, and aluminum "refused to travel" from the zincode to the platinode. They remained largely in their original compartments, even as an equivalent amount of metal was deposited at the electrode.
  • Secondary vs. Primary Action: They distinguished between the primary electrolytic split and "secondary actions"—chemical reactions that happen after the ions reach the electrode (e.g., the formation of Prussian blue in ferrocyanide electrolysis).
  • Challenging the Molecular Hypothesis: The authors realized their data was "irreconcilable" with the idea of equal ion transfer. They observed cases where a whole equivalent of an anion moved to the zincode, leaving the cation behind, rather than a 50/50 split.

Key Results

  • Unequal Transfer: In the electrolysis of sulphate of potassa ($K_2SO_4$), they found that for one equivalent of force, only a fraction of an equivalent of potassium actually crossed the diaphragm, while the rest of the electrical balance was maintained by the movement of the anion.
  • Ferrocyanide Nature: They debunked the idea that "ferridcyanogen" (ferricyanide) was a distinct traveling anion. Instead, they showed it was a secondary product formed when ferrocyanogen reacted at the zincode.
  • Ammonium Behavior: Despite its high solubility, they found that the ammonium ion ($NH_4$) belongs to the class of ions that "refuse to travel" effectively compared to simple alkali metals.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors were remarkably honest about their inability to provide a new theoretical model to replace the one they had just dismantled. They noted that the "molecular hypotheses which have hitherto been imagined" could not account for their results. They concluded by stating they would rather leave the facts for "further investigation" than add to the "already too numerous list of hasty generalizations."

This work laid the groundwork for Johann Hittorf, who a decade later would formalize these observations into the theory of ion transport numbers, fundamentally changing our understanding of ionic mobility in solution.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The authors of the following paper having agreed to work together upon the subject of the electrolysis of secondary compounds as opened by one of them, in two letters addressed to Dr. Faraday, and honoured with a place in the Philosophical Transac­tions for 1839 and 1840, have arrived at some results, which probably will not be without interest to the Royal Society, and which they have now the honour to com­municate. In the two papers just alluded to, the following points were established.First. When aqueous solutions of the neutral metallic salts are exposed to the action of the voltaic current, they are invariably decomposed. When the metal is one of that class which does not decompose water at ordinary temperatures, it is precipitated in the metallic state at the platinode: when it is of the class which does decompose water, its oxide, with an equivalent proportion of hydrogen, appears at the same electrode. The acid at the same time is set free at the zincode, accompanied by an equivalent pro­portion of oxygen. Second. When these results are compared with those of an independent voltameter in the same circuit, it is found that a certain proportion of the force which resolves a single equivalent of a simple electrolyte into its anion and cation, produces the resolution of a full equivalent of the complex electrolyte into a simple metallic cation and a compound anion. Third. When aqueous solutions of ammoniacal salts are electrolysed, similar results are obtained; but instead of a simple metal being disengaged at the platinode, an equivalent of ammonia, accompanied in all cases by an equivalent of hydrogen, appears at the platinode. Fourth. We are thus entitled to conclude that in the electrolysis of complex electrolytes, different elements travel together under the influence of the voltaic current as compound anions and cations, or as iso-electric bodies; that is, groups which are equivalent to each other, and to simple ions, in their relations to the electric forces.
BibTeX
@article{daniell1844i,
  author = {John Frederic Daniell and William Allen Miller},
  title = {{I. Additional researches on the electrolysis of secondary compounds}},
  journal = {Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London},
  year = {1844},
  doi = {10.1098/rstl.1844.0001},
}
Figure