Hysteresis in viscous suspensions

Hugo Perrin, Cécile Clavaud, Bloen Metzger, Matthieu Wyart, Yoël ForterreBulletin 2019

TL;DR

This paper reveals that interparticle friction, not inertia, is the key driver of hysteresis in granular suspensions. By tuning the friction of silica micro-beads, the researchers demonstrate that even in fully overdamped systems, a velocity-weakening rheology emerges due to friction, leading to non-monotonic flow curves and the observed hysteresis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Granular materials and dense suspensions exhibit a fascinating phenomenon called hysteresis during their transition from a solid-like state to a flowing liquid-like state. This means the stress required to initiate flow is different from the stress at which flow stops. This hysteresis is crucial in geophysical events like landslides and earthquakes. While inertia has been a leading candidate for explaining this hysteresis, this paper questions that assumption. Specifically, it investigates whether hysteresis can occur in "overdamped" systems where inertial effects are negligible, and if so, what the underlying mechanism might be. The authors aim to unify the understanding of hysteresis in both dry granular flows and dense suspensions by exploring the role of interparticle friction.

Methods

The researchers employed a rotating drum setup, a standard method for studying granular avalanches. They used two types of particles: large glass beads and smaller silica micro-beads. The key innovation lies in their ability to precisely control the interparticle friction of the silica beads. This was achieved by varying the ionic concentration of the suspending fluid (water with NaCl). At low ionic concentrations, electrostatic repulsion between the silica particles prevents solid contact, rendering them "frictionless." At higher concentrations, this repulsion is screened, allowing for frictional contacts.

They analyzed avalanche dynamics in two ways:

  1. Steady-state avalanches: By observing the angle of the granular pile as the drum rotates at a constant rate, they could infer the effective macroscopic friction coefficient of the suspension.
  2. Transient relaxations: After preparing the system in a steady flow state, the drum was suddenly stopped. The subsequent relaxation of the pile angle provided insights into the rheology close to the flow onset.

By comparing the behavior of frictional and frictionless suspensions under these conditions, they could isolate the effect of interparticle friction.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using commercially available silica particles and large glass beads, with various ionic solutions as the suspending medium.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Friction, not inertia, drives hysteresis: The most significant finding is that substantial hysteresis in avalanche angles is observed even when inertial effects are negligible (low Stokes numbers). This directly challenges previous assumptions that inertia is the primary cause.
  • Tunable friction is key: By using silica particles whose interparticle friction can be switched "on" or "off" via ionic concentration, the authors demonstrate a direct correlation between the presence of friction and the emergence of hysteresis.
  • Velocity-weakening rheology: The hysteresis in frictional suspensions arises from a non-monotonic effective friction law. Specifically, close to the flow onset, the friction decreases with increasing deformation rate (velocity-weakening), leading to flow instabilities.
  • Frictionless suspensions exhibit stable, monotonic rheology: In contrast, frictionless suspensions show a consistent, monotonic relationship between friction and deformation rate, resulting in stable, non-hysteretic flow.
  • Unifying granular and suspension behavior: The results suggest that the fundamental mechanisms driving hysteresis in dry granular flows and dense suspensions are similar, with interparticle friction playing a central role in both.

Key Results

  • Large hysteresis in overdamped frictional suspensions: The study observed significant hysteresis in avalanche angles (e.g., ~4° in a viscous mixture for large beads, and substantial hysteresis for silica beads at high salt concentrations) even at very low Stokes numbers (St = 2 × 10⁻² for silica beads).
  • Frictionless suspensions show no hysteresis: When interparticle friction was eliminated (low [NaCl]), hysteresis completely disappeared, and the flow became steady.
  • Monotonic flow rule for frictionless particles: The effective friction coefficient (μ) for frictionless particles followed a power law (Δμ ~ J⁰.37±0.05) that increased monotonically with the viscous number (J).
  • Non-monotonic flow rule for frictional particles: Frictional particles exhibited a minimum in their effective friction coefficient at a critical viscous number (Jc ≈ 10⁻⁶), with a velocity-weakening regime below Jc (Δμ ~ (J - Jc)⁰.7±0.3).
  • Faster relaxations in frictional systems: The non-monotonic rheology of frictional particles leads to faster relaxation dynamics compared to the slow, asymptotic relaxation of frictionless particles.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Preparation protocol sensitivity: The authors note that hysteresis amplitudes can depend on the cleaning and preparation protocol, although their low-concentration water cases were less sensitive.
  • Understanding Jc: An important open question is the physical origin of the critical viscous number (Jc) below which flow becomes unstable. The authors suggest it might be size-dependent or related to an intrinsic timescale not captured by hard-sphere models.
  • Collective vs. contact-level hysteresis: It remains to be determined whether the observed hysteresis arises from collective particle behavior or simply reflects the intrinsic hysteresis of solid friction at the particle contact level.
  • Discrete simulations: Extending discrete simulations to incorporate hysteresis at the particle contact scale is suggested as a future direction to further investigate the origin of this phenomenon.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{perrin2019hysteresis,
  author = {Hugo Perrin and Cécile Clavaud and Bloen Metzger and Matthieu Wyart and Yoël Forterre},
  title = {{Hysteresis in viscous suspensions}},
  journal = {Bulletin},
  year = {2019},
}
Figure