Hyperuniformity in cyclically driven glasses

Saheli Mitra, Anshul D. S. Parmar, Premkumar Leishangthem, Srikanth Sastry, Giuseppe FoffiJournal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We present a numerical investigation of the density fluctuations in a model glass under cyclic shear deformation conditions. We demonstrate that in our model glass, the compressibility is suppressed in inherently minimally energetic structures, showing a hyperuniform trend at a density which is below the critical jamming density. At low shear amplitudes, i.e. below the yield amplitude, the system reaches an absorbent steady state in which density fluctuations are suppressed, revealing the clear fingerprint of hyperuniformity up to a finite length scale. The opposite scenario is observed above the yield amplitude, where density fluctuations are strongly enhanced. We demonstrate that the transition to this state is accompanied by a spatial phase separation into two distinct hyperuniform regions, as a consequence of shear band formation at amplitudes greater than the yield amplitude.

Introduction: The Quest for Hyperuniformity

In materials science, "hyperuniformity" describes a state of matter that bridges the gap between perfectly ordered crystals and disordered liquids. In a hyperuniform system, density fluctuations over large distances vanish, a property highly desirable for creating materials with unique optical properties, such as "stealth" materials or perfect photonic band gaps. While hyperuniformity has been observed in biological tissues and emulsions, its behavior in glasses subjected to external mechanical forces—specifically the "yielding transition"—has remained poorly understood.

Methods: Simulating the Yielding Transition

The researchers utilized a Kob-Andersen model glass, a standard binary mixture of particles interacting via Lennard-Jones potentials. The system was subjected to Athermal Quasistatic Shear (AQS), where it was cyclically deformed and allowed to relax into its local energy minimum, known as an Inherent Structure (IS). To quantify hyperuniformity, the team measured the wave-vector dependent compressibility $\tilde{\chi}_T(k)$, which follows a power law ($k^\alpha$) in hyperuniform systems, and the density variance $\Delta^2(R)$ across simulations of up to 256,000 particles.

The Yielding Divide

A critical transition occurs at a strain amplitude of $\gamma_y \approx 0.07$. Below this threshold, the system reaches an "absorbing state" where it effectively "learns" the deformation, leading to enhanced hyperuniformity. In this regime, the compressibility follows a power law $\tilde{\chi}_T(k) \propto k^\alpha$ with an exponent $\alpha \approx 0.40$.

Figure 2: (a) Wave-vector dependent compressibility $\tilde{\chi}_T(k)$ for various strain amplitudes $\gamma_{max}$. (b) The hyperuniformity exponent $\alpha$ as a function of $\gamma_{max}$, showing a sharp decrease beyond the yielding threshold $\gamma_y$.

As shown in Figure 2, once the strain amplitude exceeds $\gamma_y$, the system enters a diffusive state. Globally, hyperuniformity appears to vanish as large-scale fluctuations increase significantly, and the measured exponent $\alpha$ drops sharply.

Localized Hyperuniformity in Shear Bands

The most striking finding is that the loss of hyperuniformity above yielding is not a total breakdown of order. Instead, the system undergoes shear banding, splitting into distinct high-density and low-density regions. The researchers discovered that the "noise" or large fluctuations detected globally are actually caused by the interface between these bands, rather than disorder within them.

Figure 4: (a) Directional compressibility $\tilde{\chi}_T(k)$ above yield, showing anisotropy. (b) Comparison of the exponent $\alpha$ measured globally (black circles) versus locally inside and outside shear bands. The inset illustrates the spatial phase separation.

By isolating the analysis to the regions within the individual shear bands (as seen in Figure 4), the authors recovered the same hyperuniform scaling ($\alpha \approx 0.4$) observed in the stable, unsheared glass. This marks the first observation of coexisting hyperuniform regions in a driven system.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This research demonstrates that glasses can maintain "effective" hyperuniformity under cyclic drive, and even when they yield, the resulting shear bands preserve this hidden order. The discovery of coexisting hyperuniform regions opens new doors for material design. Future work could explore how to "texture" materials to have spatially varying degrees of hyperuniformity, potentially leading to the development of complex optical waveguides or materials with tunable transparency based on mechanical processing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We present a numerical investigation of the density fluctuations in a model glass under cyclic shear deformation conditions. We demonstrate that in our model glass, the compressibility is suppressed in inherently minimally energetic structures, showing a hyperuniform trend at a density which is below the critical jamming density. At low shear amplitudes, i.e. below the yield amplitude, the system reaches an absorbent steady state in which density fluctuations are suppressed, revealing the clear fingerprint of hyperuniformity up to a finite length scale. The opposite scenario is observed above the yield amplitude, where density fluctuations are strongly enhanced. We demonstrate that the transition to this state is accompanied by a spatial phase separation into two distinct hyperuniform regions, as a consequence of shear band formation at amplitudes greater than the yield amplitude.
BibTeX
@article{mitra2021hyperuniformity,
  author = {Saheli Mitra and Anshul D. S. Parmar and Premkumar Leishangthem and Srikanth Sastry and Giuseppe Foffi},
  title = {{Hyperuniformity in cyclically driven glasses}},
  journal = {Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1088/1742-5468/abdeb0},
}
Figure